Mini 1591: PFs Flavorless Normal (Game Over)

[reinoe]

Maybe you underestimate yourself.

Why did you kill me?

[Squirrel Girl]

I wasn't there for that decision so can't easily say or produce my thoughts on the kill discussion.

[Cyberbob]

I really wish I'd followed through with my initial feelings about RC way back when I was voting him for buddying me (and I think something else?) That's my chief regret from this game I suppose, I don't regret pushing IAI/reinoe/Drew at all.

[SleepyKrew]

Maybe you underestimate yourself.

After hammering two mislynches and then trying to derail the scum lynch, I definitely would not have even attempted to get into a leadership position. I appreciate the flattery of being the kill though.

[PokerFace]

I would appreciate this thread not being locked as I would like to learn from it, and hear from farside.

I have no intentions of locking it, I plan to let list mods doing the last post locking thing they normally do a week or so after its over

[PokerFace]

also something just dawned on me, I think I forgot to give cyberbob dead thread access when he died. His has the access now but I i still want to appoligize

I anticipated a singer or goofy kill on night 3, when i read scum's reasons for killing SK though they made sence especially after the pops lynch. SK least likly person you could pair with pops next to farside

[singersigner]

Ok I didn't mean poor sportsmanship, I know you guys needed to secure the win, it was just miserable for me and felt like I was such an easy mislynch target that it could've been over with almost immediately. What I hated was the fact that every time I second guessed RCs claim, it seemed to make me look scummier to everyone.

[Squirrel Girl]

I would note that the instant a wagon was within L-1 we hammered it.
I don't think you were as easy of a mislynch as you wish to argue.

[Dessew]

Welp, congrats. That BG fakeclaim was spot-on.

[I Am Innocent]

I for one do not believe RC's claim. Bodyguard is an easy claim to fake for scum.

If RC's wagon falls apart, I am going to move my vote back to Cooldog, though I'm starting to feel there is only 1 scum in {RC, Cooldog}. VT claim/my suspicion of that slot would take precedence over suspicion I have for others at this point (who have not claimed), hence why my vote would go back there.

For dessew

[farside22]

My thought and why I tracked the players I did.
Beck felt like the scum. I told of I thought scum would buss with cooldog.
When sk brought up the points on pops I did a slight meta check to see he is typically more verbose.
I was pissed how people let pops slide through and SG fake he does that is null was crap.

I thought goofy might be scum with pops at the end of day 2.

[farside22]

I need to work on my anger when people made shit cases.

[Goofyd00d]

Your case was why I made sure noone could deny Pops was the target the next day, it also made me want to lynch SG all the more.

[PokerFace]

had the mafia BP got lynched I think it would have brought Red alot of flak or any scum that claimed a protect role

looking at the setup i still feel this game was balanced

Though I think it may have been closer to a true 50/50 if either the tracker was actually a watcher or if there was no BP and the vig was a 1 or 2 shot only

[PokerFace]

I personally love neighbors and as I was the first person to coin the term neighbors
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 6#p1123736
I felt i had to have some in my game

and as I love vigs and lots of people know it I felt I needed one in the setup, but as I did not want the vig to be able to do all the work for the town felt a BP was needed

And I made the tracker in the setup as I wanted some level of wifom investigative follower in the game cause of the vig and the scum

[popsofctown]

Yay! I win!

Fun game guys! I hate playing as scum.

[Dessew]

I for one do not believe RC's claim. Bodyguard is an easy claim to fake for scum.

If RC's wagon falls apart, I am going to move my vote back to Cooldog, though I'm starting to feel there is only 1 scum in {RC, Cooldog}. VT claim/my suspicion of that slot would take precedence over suspicion I have for others at this point (who have not claimed), hence why my vote would go back there.

For dessew :roll:

Iirc, you posted that, then ad nauseam came, right? Mafia isn't about just the reads, you have to get people vote the player you want to lynch.

[singersigner]

Your case was why I made sure noone could deny Pops was the target the next day, it also made me want to lynch SG all the more.

Then why didn't you ever consider her during/after pops. I feel like I was the only one calling her scum at one point. Though I may be biased, I just dropped it because I felt very alone in that sentiment at that point...and thb she bought me by defending me to her scum buddy and bob...fuck, now I'm embarrassed I didn't see through that...

[Drew-Sta]

So I picked Konowa and RC, and you guys managed to lynch me D1

Well played mafia - you did well.

[Goofyd00d]

Your case was why I made sure noone could deny Pops was the target the next day, it also made me want to lynch SG all the more.

Then why didn't you ever consider her during/after pops. I feel like I was the only one calling her scum at one point. Though I may be biased, I just dropped it because I felt very alone in that sentiment at that point...and thb she bought me by defending me to her scum buddy and bob...fuck, now I'm embarrassed I didn't see through that...

I voted her right off the bat day 4.

[Goofyd00d]

Hey Poker, I was thinking of a fun way to end a game without choosing the scum kill. Could PM all the alive mafia at that point saying the game is over and say something like "First one to respond with a kill gets it."

[Drew-Sta]

Well played scum I had 2 of you on D1, and ended up getting lynched! Oh well.

[singersigner]

Gotta dodge the prod, nothing I've seen has changed my mind on Squirrel, I wouldn't mind lynching CD's spot, I just feel more strongly about Squirrel.

You're right, you D&D have to assume we'd be scum buddies, though to vote me, so between that and prod-dodges I kind of didn't take anything you had to say seriously, to be honest. Sorry, I should've, but like, I was town SK I didn't really want to listen to anyone who thought I was scum.

[SleepyKrew]

So I picked Konowa and RC, and you guys managed to lynch me D1

Well played mafia - you did well.

Well played scum I had 2 of you on D1, and ended up getting lynched! Oh well.

[Drew-Sta]

I swear I thought it didn't post - my browser is fucked