Scummies 2009 Nominations

[Mr. Flay]

Is there a rule that says no player can win the same award twice?

Nope, but for me at least it raises the bar for a second awarding.

Also,

I second Llama Fluff for Best Player (Scum)

in Mafia 86. Nice work.

[Kison]

Is there a rule that says no player can win the same award twice?

Nope, but for me at least it raises the bar for a second awarding.

Also,

I second Llama Fluff for Best Player (Scum)

in Mafia 86. Nice work.

Third.

[animorpherv1]

Is there a rule that says no player can win the same award twice?

Nope, but for me at least it raises the bar for a second awarding.

Also,

I second Llama Fluff for Best Player (Scum)

in Mafia 86. Nice work.

Third.

4th?

[q21]

Nominate Mykonian for best Role Claim in Mini 707

The Claim

In Short: A cop (turned out to be insane) claimed and gave an innocent result on Mykonian. Mykonian was scum. He claimed Miller almost immediately. For the rest of the game he pretty much had the town eating out his hand.

It was a major factor in us winning the game.

[animorpherv1]

Nominate Mykonian for best Role Claim in Mini 707

The Claim

In Short: A cop (turned out to be insane) claimed and gave an innocent result on Mykonian. Mykonian was scum. He claimed Miller almost immediately. For the rest of the game he pretty much had the town eating out his hand.

It was a major factor in us winning the game.

2nd

that was pne hell of a breadcrumb.

[Kmd4390]

Nominate VP Baltar for Best Newbie Scum

for Newbie 696

We lynched his IC scumbuddy on Day 1. He survived to endgame for the win. I was killed N1, but followed the game and I thought he was town. Very well played on his part.

[BlakAdder]

Support LlamaFluff's nom for best roleclaim.

[Incognito]

Nominate VP Baltar for Best Newbie Scum

for Newbie 696

We lynched his IC scumbuddy on Day 1. He survived to endgame for the win. I was killed N1, but followed the game and I thought he was town. Very well played on his part.

Seconded.

I was the mod of this game, and I didn't have to prod VP Baltar at any point during the game. He played a very solid first game as scum.

[JDodge]

Nominate VP Baltar for Best Newbie Scum

for Newbie 696

We lynched his IC scumbuddy on Day 1. He survived to endgame for the win. I was killed N1, but followed the game and I thought he was town. Very well played on his part.

Seconded.

I was the mod of this game, and I didn't have to prod VP Baltar at any point during the game. He played a very solid first game as scum.

Since when is "I didn't have to prod him once" worthy of an honorific?

[Incognito]

Nominate VP Baltar for Best Newbie Scum

for Newbie 696

We lynched his IC scumbuddy on Day 1. He survived to endgame for the win. I was killed N1, but followed the game and I thought he was town. Very well played on his part.

Seconded.

I was the mod of this game, and I didn't have to prod VP Baltar at any point during the game. He played a very solid first game as scum.

Since when is "I didn't have to prod him once" worthy of an honorific?

Good ol' JDodge.

I thought his play in general outside of that fact was good. The fact that I didn't have to prod him once during a time where many people in the MD and in games in general seem to complain about inactivity in games was a plus. I think it's something that's definitely worth encouraging in new players, and in this particular case, I thought it was doubly worth noting since his IC scum partner got lynched

Day 1

, which could have easily discouraged any other Newbie scum player from posting within a game.

[Jebus]

Nominate: LlamaFluff

for best roleclaim for mafia 86.

seconded

Oddest yet most effective scum-claim I've seen in a while.

[farside22]

Nominate ZONEACE for best replacement

for this game:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 68#1485268
He came in at L-1 and turned the game around for the person he replaced to the point where most everyone thought he was town.
Good job in my book.

[populartajo]

Nominate ZONEACE for best replacement

for this game:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 68#1485268
He came in at L-1 and turned the game around for the person he replaced to the point where most everyone thought he was town.
Good job in my bood.

Second this and nth any award for Fluff, they are both good players.

[Caboose]

Nominate roflcopter for Best Performance by an Individual

LoL Mafia
The whole town did really well in this game, but rofl led and sustained the lynch wagon on scumRbt D2 and was a major force in the D1 Sly wagon, which eventually won us the game.

[Tenchi]

@Caboose: If you want to nominate that game, I'd rather have you nominated. I think you were the one who drove the lynches of most scum, not to mention your "cold-feet" on the RBT lynch got me NKed. You were Roflcopter++.

[roflcopter]

@Caboose: If you want to nominate that game, I'd rather have you nominated. I think you were the one who drove the lynches of most scum, not to mention your "cold-feet" on the RBT lynch got me NKed. You were Roflcopter++.

word.

nominate caboose

for best performance by an individual(town) in Legends of Literature Mafia

[Mr. Flay]

Nominate JDodge for Professor Mafia for empirically/scientifically showing a glaring hole in the Open Game Nomination process.

Original setup post and nomination: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 84#1470584
Analysis/expose: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 91#1493891
Game thread: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=10486

[Adel]

Nominate JDodge for Professor Mafia for empirically/scientifically showing a glaring hole in the Open Game Nomination process.

Original setup post and nomination: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 84#1470584
Analysis/expose: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 91#1493891
Game thread: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=10486

anti-nominate

intentionally leveraging his experience and reputation to wreck a game to prove a point when he can't even point to a previous example of a broken setup getting into the queue should not be rewarded.

If someone intentionally wrecked a newbie game to prove a point about a flaw newbie game system would that be acceptable to you? Rewarding JDodge with recognition for his unnecessary prank encourages that kind of behavior.

[roflcopter]

i agree with adel. all we learn from this is that jd has both a persecution complex and a massive ego.

[Albert B. Rampage]

agree with Adel and the above poster

[SensFan]

Agree with Adel and the poster above the above poster and the above poster.

[Guardian]

One Shot

3 Mafia
1 One-Shot Cop (may submit "no action" to preserve ability for later nights)
7 Townies

Day start, mandatory lynches and NKs.

[Plum]

One Shot

3 Mafia
1 One-Shot Cop (may submit "no action" to preserve ability for later nights)
7 Townies

Day start, mandatory lynches and NKs.

Wrong thread, methinks. Interesting idea, though. Fairly elegant simplicity.

[Lord Gurgi]

People who hate JDodge and have a vendetta: If it's such a bad idea, let the judges figure it out. The job of this thread is

not

to shoot down nominations. It wasn't an unnecessary prank, he found a problem, and knew nobody would listen to him. Now that you find that he has successfully found and proven his point, you wish to beat him over the head for it, get over yourselves.

[ZONEACE]

People who hate JDodge and have a vendetta: If it's such a bad idea, let the judges figure it out. The job of this thread is

not

to shoot down nominations. It wasn't an unnecessary prank, he found a problem, and knew nobody would listen to him. Now that you find that he has successfully found and proven his point, you wish to beat him over the head for it, get over yourselves.

ITT I agree with Gurgi and feel dirty for doing so.



PS. someone third my nomination.