NY 162: A Week at the Theatres (Game Over)

[JacobSavage]

See here (Note that Hoopla was actually a Vengeful Townie though)

[ZONEACE]

VOTE: ZONEACE

Also I was Under the impression that PGOs claiming early Day 1 was the expected thing. Can someone confirm this?

Oh what a circus, oh what a show.

[Go]

I didn't see that one coming a mile away.

Horrible response to being voted.

Vote: MrZepher

[Go]

PGO claim is legit, wind-up is town. PGO Maf is retarded.

Smashbard, you realize ActionDan is joking about his "lyncher" claim, right?

Same goes for KingdomAces, you seem to be responding seriously to a non-serious post.

[MrZepher]

I was responding more that I was 80% sure Dramonic was going to vote me during RVS because it's Dram and we're friendlies.

Interesting that of all the things I've said so far THAT'S the thing you find suspicious.

[Bacde]

whew I was afraid people might read into my claim

luckily, mafia ALWAYS lie and thus by saying I am mafia, if I were mafia I'd be lying thus I'd be town

logically, I am now confirmed town

So, keep talking guys but I'm gonna choose the lynch for today

[Nobody Special]

PGO claim is legit, wind-up is town.

I have seen mafia claim (town) PGO. I'm not sure I even recall which game, but I know I've seen it.

[Go]

I was responding more that I was 80% sure Dramonic was going to vote me during RVS because it's Dram and we're friendlies.

Interesting that of all the things I've said so far THAT'S the thing you find suspicious.

"I was scummy a bunch of other times and you only quoted ONE thing so neenerneener" - Can we lynch this guy.

whew I was afraid people might read into my claim

luckily, mafia ALWAYS lie and thus by saying I am mafia, if I were mafia I'd be lying thus I'd be town

logically, I am now confirmed town

So, keep talking guys but I'm gonna choose the lynch for today

Your logic is impeccable and irrefutable.

[KingdomAces]

That was RVS. Anyway, there's really no reason to say that his claim is true right now. Scum miller claims have been successful recently, so why would you think they wouldn't start claiming PGO? Assumptions can kill. I

think

PGO's are allowed in normal games, so the claim still could be true.

Bacde, I'll decide that for myself, thank you.

[Bacde]

I think instead of:

"Can town/mafia claim PGO"

a better train of thought would be:

"How often is someone claiming PGO D1 actually a PGO?"

because if its not likely, then we should probably lynch the PGO and hope hes a vengeful/scum

[Bacde]

This is what is going to happen this game:

1) I will lead a bw on scum d1
2) Either scum will be lynched or someone else will push through a mislynch d1
3) I will be NKed for being confirmed town in just 2 pages

Scum is scurred but they should be

[KingdomAces]

Really Bacde? Stop calling yourself confirmed town. You're not, and the way you are going on about it is making me start to doubt you're town at all.
UNVOTE: Human Destroyer, VOTE: Bacde

The best train of thought about the PGO is to ignore the claim during the day, and judge them on other things. All it is is a distraction, because it allows for non-game-specific discussion. Scum can talk about things unrelated to the game all they want, and they end up looking townier for it. Don't give them the chance.

[Bacde]

who's your buddy kingdomaces?

[Smashbard]

PGO claim is legit, wind-up is town. PGO Maf is retarded.

Smashbard, you realize ActionDan is joking about his "lyncher" claim, right?

Same goes for KingdomAces, you seem to be responding seriously to a non-serious post.

Even if that is so, I'm gonna wait to hear that from ActionDan himself as to whether or not he is joking. Because if he is then the possibility of Kiwoto being scum goes up a lot for reaffirming their belief that their vote is on scum. I'd like to think that not ALL information shared in the RVS is useless.

[Smashbard]

PGO claim is legit, wind-up is town.

I have seen mafia claim (town) PGO. I'm not sure I even recall which game, but I know I've seen it.

Since nobody can safely target the PGO at night without killing themselves, obviously it makes him safe from investigations and theoretically night kills. So as scum it would make perfect sense to claim PGO that way he can stay alive all game and nobody will question why he hasn't been nightkilled yet. I don't like it. But there's no way to refute it beyond lynching him. So we have one of those "Hated Townie" situations. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

[Nobody Special]

unvote

Vote: Bacde

Kill it with fire.

[Smashbard]

I was responding more that I was 80% sure Dramonic was going to vote me during RVS because it's Dram and we're friendlies.

Interesting that of all the things I've said so far THAT'S the thing you find suspicious.

"I was scummy a bunch of other times and you only quoted ONE thing so neenerneener" - Can we lynch this guy.

I agree. This is borderline admittance that "Hey, I'm nervous scum that has already said things you should be looking at, why are you suspicious of me over this quote?"

Unvote. Vote: Mr. Zepher

[Bacde]

Personally if I was PGO I wouldn't claim and I would just try to play so well that the scum HAVE to target me

[ActionDan]

Claiming PGO early is legit.

Quadz does it for example

[Smashbard]

Personally if I was PGO I wouldn't claim and I would just try to play so well that the scum HAVE to target me

If that's the case, you're already doing a stellar job my friend. lol.

[Bacde]

^^WTF YOU ARE SAYING WE ARE fRIENDS ALL OF A SUDDEN OBV BUDDYING

VOTE: SMASHBARD

lol

unvote

jk man hows it going

[Smashbard]

Since our last game together I have a feeling what you're doing here is very similar to how you played before with the whole "I'm so obvtown it hurts" bullshit that you and AngryPidgeon like to throw around. So I think you're town. But even if you're scum your presence is going to make this game a lot more interesting. Good to play with you again.

[MrZepher]

I'm willing to believe the PGO claim for now for specifically the example ActionDan stated. I feel like it'll have to be approached at some point though.

I agree. This is borderline admittance that "Hey, I'm nervous scum that has already said things you should be looking at, why are you suspicious of me over this quote?"

No. I was saying that of all the things you could nitpick at why pick the most easily admissible one?
I love having words shoved into my mouth though. Thanks for that.

[Smashbard]

I'm willing to believe the PGO claim for now for specifically the example ActionDan stated. I feel like it'll have to be approached at some point though.

I agree. This is borderline admittance that "Hey, I'm nervous scum that has already said things you should be looking at, why are you suspicious of me over this quote?"

No. I was saying that of all the things you could nitpick at why pick the most easily admissible one?
I love having words shoved into my mouth though. Thanks for that.

May I suggest the gravy or the melted butter to help wash it down?

[Go]

Bacde if you play here like you do on epicmafia all you're going to do is confuse the town and probably get lynched.