Worst Role Mafia - GAME OVER!

[PokerFace]

I thought it was the list mod who locked old game threads, not the game mod. (And for large themes, there's no real reason for them not to stay open pretty much indefinitely, because they don't have a numerical order that they have to be sorted in.)

I hope your right, its taking me sometime to catch up on everything after my death and during my vacation. I'll give some overall comments as soon as I can though

[PokerFace]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 1#p4106841
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 9#p4106849
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p4107192

Counterproductive? I think McQueen's PR combined with the additonal PR from Haddock, would have hard for mcqueen to deal with. The Fonz had 2 mutually exclusive PR's in the original worst ideas thread and as he couldn't fufill one without breaking the other he effectivly could not post until his death

So giving McQueen a PR would have actually hurt the town however the town as a team didn't play well. The action of hurting the town was unecessary and not counterproductive at that point in the game. The lynch of the vote magnet was horrible. I thought my support of an FOS there would be interpreted as encouragement on the magnet but instead it egged on a rather horrible lynch in a long line of town mislynches. The town's play as a whole was pretty rough and I think it would have been nice had we won in the 3 person endgame, but I really don't think we deserved it.

Town had alot of lynch related mistakes throughout the game

As I said in the death thread, my job and my real life did effect my activity in this game. If me role had been as bad as everyone else's I likly would have lurked way moar. My role's skill and info really helped direct my scumhunting and the comments of others in the game gave me grounds on where to start as I often ave trouble hunting when i am in the dark. So scumhunting wise in the truest sence I don't think I did good. My role itself and the play of others did greater things. I made good tracking and inspecting choices. Found mafia that led me to more mafia by association which is something I am good at. Who better to track than the guy who is claiming the most crazy actions? And I found an innocent in a rather confusing situation with noob

I believe I can say I made good vidge and doc choices as well. I shot scum which is always good. And made another shot that helped confirm a townie in my eyes. I feel bad that I had to kill one to confirm one but I feel I still made up for that with the shot on saul. Red Panda was scum and he was likly the scum with the overall best play. I never would have suspected him and had he died night 1 I think the Mafia could have really run away with this game.

Red Panda did the most to identify who the 3 mafia were in this game. The wolves as a hole did more damage to the mafia then the town did.

However they made the crucial mistake of trying to lynch the mafia with the town as apposed to just killing the mafia at night.

Town was playing bad so using them to help you, I feel was a bad choice. Panda obviously thought Haddock and Dana and Bad Mason were scum and he should have talked his werewolf buds into mauling the mafia at night.

That choice and Saul claiming werewolf were only mistakes. Amrun's skill getting the red shirt, lynched was genius

Mafia didn't so much beat the town as they beat the werewolves. The town beat themselves. Mafia killing Amrun and Panda were great choices. Haddock PRing Saul was also a great move. Dana and CFJ's bussing back and forth late in the game, I don't think really got them much. With how bad town was playing and wolves being out of the game at that point, I'd like the think Mafia could have thought of a better strategy to finish off the town faster and keep their numbers, but meh the bussing still worked so I guess no harm no foul.

TLDR, Town didn't deserve the win as a whole, wolves lost to the mafia, so mafia wins.

Yep that says it all. I want to and thought I'd have more to say but yay I'm just going to far at this point, but at least I am concious of it so that's some improvment. I want to thank izak for the great game. Sorry I was not active as much as others this game, but I still had fun.

Also I applaud your efforts to muddy the neighbor mason meta, izak. You had 2 town neighbors and 2 scum masons.

Well done there sir!

[izakthegoomba]

Also I applaud your efforts to muddy the neighbor mason meta, izak. You had 2 town neighbors and 2 scum masons.

Well done there sir!

[callforjudgement]

My bussing of dana was because I didn't think anyone would believe I'd do anything else as town, so not doing it, I'd have been caught out. (That it helped convince people in the endgame was an unexpected bonus.) I'm not sure offhand why dana bussed me, but I don't think it hurt (apart from me confusing what dana and BBmolla had said about me, which in retrospect, was probably a scumslip.)

[callforjudgement]

Oh, and the werewolves deserve quite some credit for town's implosion, because they were clearly focusing on killing competent players.

[Phillammon]

Oh, and the werewolves deserve quite some credit for town's implosion, because they were clearly focusing on killing competent players.

Hey!
I see what you did there!

[inte]

jesus christ you seriously haven't won a game?????

[Phillammon]

No. Out of my 9 complete games, I've won 0.

[Phillammon]

*No, as in, No I haven't won any. So correct.

[izakthegoomba]

Well, I'm glad I didn't disturb your losing streak!

[callforjudgement]

It actually motivated me to try really hard to win, because I didn't want to be responsible for breaking it.

[izakthegoomba]

I wonder what my losing streak is. It's probably quite impressive by now.

[callforjudgement]

Also, sorry for the stealth insult, Phillammon; I hadn't thought of it like that.

[Phillammon]

Nah, s'okay. If I were competent, I might have won something by now. I'm gonna do a little looking around, actually. I think that 9 games on site with no wins is probably a record of some kind...