NY 176: Completely Ridiculous Mafia (Game Over)

[Cabd]

Why did you need a night to tell if MVP was going to be scum?

It was more that I didn't want to act on it yet, just in case i was wrong.

[Cabd]

You're odd night? I didn't realize that.

What made you think AP was crumbing backup? The only early game thing I know of is the Doctor who reference, and that's pretty clearly in relation to looking for a doctor.

I said odd night in my initial claim post, so yes?

Let me go back and find whereabouts I realized it, but without giving away the constant arms race that AP and I are in regarding each other, there were several behavioral tells. And then when I sortaish asked him and he sortish nodded, that was that.

[Cabd]

This game is relatively small for a large, so its more likely. Do you have a particular reason for finding it suspect?

Actually on the topic of this setup, Im a little intrigued by there being 15 slots since 13/17 are more common. Curious what people think about that.

Why the fuck are you trying to go back to RVS, bob?

When you figure it out, feel free to fix your unvote.

I'm curious too, why Aegor is pushing for a mislynch.

How do you know toomai is a mislynch?, >.>

Because, unlike you, I feel there is barely anything I could give a scumread - a real scumread, not a 49-51 read - to. I have townreads, of course. I'm townreading TWIE, for example.

Who are your scumreads? Why?

My face after reading this post


263 reads awfully forced and I don't like it.
Especially coupled with the immediate scumreading of reinoe (a lurker slot) after being called out on not having any scumreads. Reinoe didn't really do anything alignment indicative IMO and TSO's sudden read there sucks.

Huh, well I was going to say I think Toomai/TSO are decent candidates for scum, but Toomai hoping on Reinoe in the same way TSO did immediately after makes me think they arent scum together. Probably one of them is.

Also what are your thoughts on TSO trying to push through a lynch on a soft-claimed cop? Do you think that's scummy or townie?

your predecessor already claimed doc

This is a really poor attempt at scumhunting and if you are town you should feel ashamed.

K well enjoy misreading probable scum then.

Okay blissy, tell me why I should reconsider.

He called KiGi scum for pushing an easy target. An easy target that he also happens to think is scummy and would wagon. When called out on this he speculates about Multiball and then immediately backpedals into "Well actually Id just lynch them both anyways".

Hes scum, bro.

Mostly the last line of the second to last post. Also I call him "blissy" (Blissy being the pokemon that backs up for others in TCG) hinting that I think he's my backup and he doesn't go out of his way to point that out or call attention to it, making me pretty sure, so then the codegate thing a bit after. In hindsight I bet he thought I was calling him a nurse in that post (because blissy in the anime is nurse joy's pokemon family of choice)

[Aegor]

I looked through prior votecounts. It is interesting to me that essentially all players who have been wagoned since the beginning the day are now dead (mainly lynched), with the exception of Cabd and T S O, both wagoned relatively early on Day 1. This suggests to me that either scum is sitting back and got lucky, or that scum is orchestrating the lynches.

[T S O]

Why do you sound so robotic and lifeless this game, Aegor?

[Aegor]

I am currently overcomitted and my own game just started, as you know. Last week was the worst work week ever for me; I worked twenty hours more than usual.

[Aegor]

And all of the people I actually thought were scum, especially Toomai, flipped town. so...

[goodmorning]

man you people post less than an albatross

Votecount 4.3

Cephrir [L-4] - T S O

Cabd [L-4] - Cephrir

Not Voting [7] - ika, Izariael, Aegor, Cabd, Mirhawk, TheWayItEnds, AngryPidgeon

With 9 alive, it takes

5

to lynch. The day will end in (expired on 2014-09-30 17:00:00).

Izariael is, like, V/LA or something.

[Izariael]

Last week was the worst work week ever for me; I worked twenty hours more than usual.

Amen.

Gotta catch up on Day 4 reading, but my head hurts trying to make sense of this game.

[Izariael]

Izariael is not scum, and lynching him will result in a scum win as assuredly as lynching me.

Just how deep are a warthog's pockets?

[Izariael]

Hmm.

At first, I felt like going after Cabd still because too many pieces of his jigsaw don't fit in with the rest of the picture...

Then I felt like going after Ceph because he's been on all 3 mislynches and seems to be quite comfortable with me in his pocket... His day 4 has a different tone than the others and he seems to be reacting strangely to the warning shots of the firing squad. There's more red flags here than all of China.

Then I felt like saying fuck it to both those options, because ika's dumb hammers have shot us in both knees.

VOTE: ika

Anyways, if we have 4 scum, then we probably lose on a no-lynch... so it's not really an option. Town has already lost the game if this is a 4-man scum team though... It's just so much easier to force a no-lynch than to bus a teammate at this point. Since ika is just a pro-scum vote waiting to happen, then I'm gonna nip his ass before we all die.

Come on ika, 1v1 me bro. I've voted you, what have you got?

[ika]

the problem with 1v1 in lylos is that if we are both town, its insta lose.

but if we lose b/c of the 1v1 its your fault then.

ill vote after work so i can see if someon tries to blitz it

[ika]

know what fuck it, ppl have been hating on me all game. if they want to blacklist me post-game or yell at me or whatever shit fine.

1v1 bitch

VOTE: izar

[T S O]

someone kill me

[Izariael]

The problem with keeping you alive is that it keeps town in a win-less situation anyways. The point about 1v1s in lylo is completely moot as a result.

Your consistency in laying down the hammer has been a detriment, and you're intentionally voting in a nonsensical pattern that makes little to no sense. It's like you just spit out the first name that pops into your head, which is usually the last person to vote you.

I gave you the benefit of doubt earlier, but I'm done throwing trolls a freebie. I'd rather be known as the guy who lynched two trolltowns than the guy who let trollscum survive.

[T S O]

you know what

ika is never ever going to co-operate with me, so we'll just nl and lose.

he has a half-decent chance of being scum

but if he's town we've already lost.

unvote
vote: ika

[T S O]

He's not even in my top 3 scum suspects, but whatever. Nice kills, scumteam - it's just me, ika and inactives (and maybe TWIE).

[TheWayItEnds]

At first, I felt like going after Cabd still because too many pieces of his jigsaw don't fit in with the rest of the picture...

Then I felt like going after Ceph because he's been on all 3 mislynches and seems to be quite comfortable with me in his pocket... His day 4 has a different tone than the others and he seems to be reacting strangely to the warning shots of the firing squad. There's more red flags here than all of China.

Then I felt like saying fuck it to both those options, because ika's dumb hammers have shot us in both knees.

I agree with all of this.

the problem with 1v1 in lylos is that if we are both town, its insta lose.

but if we lose b/c of the 1v1 its your fault then.

ill vote after work so i can see if someon tries to blitz it

I couldn't disagree with this more.

[TheWayItEnds]

Like I literally cant put a team together that doesnt include Cabd.

I really dont like Ceph today.

But seriously fuck everything Ika did this whole game.

[ika]

obligatory post of not caring.

waiting for scums to quick hammer me. normally i would self hammer but i feel genrous today

[Cephrir]

Ika and Cabd are both scum, I don't really care.

Really hope there are somehow 3 scum, because we're obviously going to lynch me eventually and lose otherwise

[ika]

then vote me?

[Cephrir]

If you insist

VOTE: ika

[ika]

i fully insists my own myslynch.

[Cabd]

Not hammering. (Also not scum but that's neither here nor there)