Open 296: MAFIA WINS GONNA TEACH YOU TO BURN

[Bella]

I think the way lane went in on the Ranger wagon makes me more sure he's the one.

In what way?

Lanescum jumped quickly onto voting for him when there was a weakish case against him, and the statement he made gave the impression that he was convinced about Ranger's guilt. It felt to me like the kind of vote scum makes when trying to distance between each other.

Votecount
TheButtonmen (4): RangeroftheNorth, ThAdmiral, Empking, Mr. Trow
Not voting (2): Bella, RangeroftheNorth
With six alive it takes 4 to lynch.

[Bella]

I currently think Bella is more likely to be town. Lane jumping on to Bella's

poorly thought out wagon

that quickly without adding anything seems really unlikely if they were both scum.

That's an interesting point of view.

[Empking]

I think the way lane went in on the Ranger wagon makes me more sure he's the one.

In what way?

Lanescum jumped quickly onto voting for him when there was a weakish case against him, and the statement he made gave the impression that he was convinced about Ranger's guilt. It felt to me like the kind of vote scum makes when trying to distance between each other.

Why didn't you think that yesterday?

[Bella]

Bella you still haven't answered my question.

Which question?

[ThAdmiral]

Lane jumped on Ranger.
Emp jumped on lane.

The situation was such that if mafia had banded together they could have just about taken the game out. Vis-a-vis I find it extremely unlikely that either of these two would be scum.

That makes sense.

What do you think of Mr. Trow.

Occams razor says he gets town points for jumping on lane. Less so than ranger or you though.

@ bella: stop avoiding answering questions. Apart from tbm you have also cleverly avoided answering empking's question before your most recent post.

(yes I know you posted at the same time, but you would have seen it after you posted)

[MrTrow]

@ThAdmiral: i think he wants you to comment on his 'wrong tool for the (claimed) job' accusation of me. (+iso?)

Bella you still haven't answered my question.

Which question?

You're being all quiet like over there, other then the comment by Stef about Mutes slot has anything stood out to you?

My current bet for scum is TheButtonman. He hasn't even showed up today yet, and after Hero's behavior, that's a bad sign.

Uhm ranger: do you remember requesting a replacement for hero for 'not posting on the site for 2 weeks'?
note: during his in-between absence from this game he also was gone everywhere else, coming back with a 'sorry been busy' seems credible to me.

I agree more posts by more people 'would be nice', however getting hero involved in the lurker claim, is not improving your point.

[ThAdmiral]

@ThAdmiral: i think he wants you to comment on his 'wrong tool for the (claimed) job' accusation of me. (+iso?)

Does he?

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: TBM

[MrTrow]

Appearantly not.

TBM anything we need to know before day`s end?

[Empking]

Mr.Trow: If you don't vote TBM then I'll do my darndest to policy lynch you.

[MrTrow]

I will
I`m giving him a last chance to provide usefull info for a potential tomorrow.
If he`s scum i`m wasting aproximately 3 hours, if he`s town i may be preventing loss of information.

[MrTrow]

time`s up
VOTE: TheButtonmen

[RangeroftheNorth]

@ThAdmiral: i think he wants you to comment on his 'wrong tool for the (claimed) job' accusation of me. (+iso?)

Bella you still haven't answered my question.

Which question?

You're being all quiet like over there, other then the comment by Stef about Mutes slot has anything stood out to you?

My current bet for scum is TheButtonman. He hasn't even showed up today yet, and after Hero's behavior, that's a bad sign.

Uhm ranger: do you remember requesting a replacement for hero for 'not posting on the site for 2 weeks'?
note: during his in-between absence from this game he also was gone everywhere else, coming back with a 'sorry been busy' seems credible to me.

I agree more posts by more people 'would be nice', however getting hero involved in the lurker claim, is not improving your point.

Perhaps you're right. Both players have been somewhat inactive on the site. In my experience, however, slots that lurk across multiple players are usually scum slots. Its possible that this is just a coincidence, but as it stands right now, distinguishing between Bella and TBM is very difficult. I believe that one of them is scum, but neither have participated enough in the game for me to get a very good read. All I have is a pretty minor town-tell on Bella, and a pretty minor scum tell on TBM. Which is why I was voting for TBM. If we hadn't had such an imposing deadline, I wouldn't consider it enough for a lynch, but with the deadline closing in, and neither Bella or TBM showing any sign of participating, we absolutely had to get rid of one of them. They'd both be liabilities in Lylo, and their lack of contribution is highly anti-town.

[ThAdmiral]

if tbm isn't scum you guys should no-lynch tomorrow.

[saporovirus]

You went after who you thought was the last remaining traitor in your midst.

TheButtonmen, Vanilla Townie

has been lynched! Night Five Deadline: Tuesday at Midnight

[saporovirus]

ThAdmiral, vanilla townie

has been stuffed inside a hookah. Day 6 Deadline: Sunday May 15th at midnight. With four alive it takes three to lynch.

Votecount
No lynch (3): Empking, Bella, RangeroftheNorth

[Empking]

Vote: NL

[Bella]

VOTE: No Lynch

[RangeroftheNorth]

Vote: No Lynch

[saporovirus]

Night Six deadline: Wednesday at Midnight

[saporovirus]

Empking, Vanilla Townie

has been SPOONED TO DEATH!

Day Seven deadline: May 25th.

[RangeroftheNorth]

Well, first off, we're in Lylo, so no votes until you're sure. Shouldn't need to be said, but I'm saying it anyway.

Right now, I'm most suspicious of Bella. Her continued absence would be very convenient for scum. That said, its pretty blatant. I'm going to check her meta and read through the thread again. Expect a larger post tomorrow.

@Bella: I really hope you intend to contribute to the game at this point. If you aren't going to post more, please replace out.

Votecount
RangeroftheNorth (1)

[RangeroftheNorth]

I apologize for taking longer than I meant to get this post out, although I'm not sure what it matters, as I seem to be playing by myself.

I looked over Bella's meta, and it looks like this type of behavior isn't far out of the norm. Its annoying and anti-town, but I don't think it means she's scum.

I've been doing some reading and thinking the last couple of days. Here's what I've come up with:

1) Bella has rarely posted and hasn't posted much content. but this seems to be in character for Bella.

2) Bella has been attempting to find scum. Her case against me wasn't good, but it might show that she was actually looking for scum. Having strong scum reads even if they aren't well backed up seems in-character for TownBella

3)MrTrow was the first on the lane wagon. His post was well reasoned. It could have been a partner preemptively bussing a partner who screwed up. He also voted for lane day 1. Put both together, it doesn't feel like bussing to me, but I'm not entirely ruling it out.

4) It would have made a lot of sense for MrTrow to kill Empking last night. Bellla had already expressed suspicion of me and no one else, and I had said that I was suspicious of Bella. Bringing the both of us to Lylo would be very good for him.

Getting 2 replacements during lylo would be hilarious to me. Anyone who actually posts will be easier to get a read on than Bella has been so far.

[MrTrow]

Sorry i`m late.
Was (am) mainly waiting for more from Bella.

I`ll finish up my cases on Ranger later today.


One thing i just picked up though:

I had said that I was suspicious of Bella.

Where?

Bella: Her read on me wasn't valid, but it was certainly attempting to find scum

I currently think Bella is more likely to be town.

All I have is a pretty minor town-tell on Bella,

You called her (in)action anti-town and accused her of active lurking D1(a charge that you`ve been toning down ever since)

[Bella]

VOTE: RangeroftheNorth

Nothing has happened to change my mind that he's scum.