In post 395, fireisredsir wrote:
feeling that the things being scumread are just personality traits rather than signs of being scum
yeah i guess i didn't say this explicitly but this is the world im entertaining right now
i think if jupiter is scum it'll be more obvious over a longer period of time
that was the thought process that i was expecting you to be having and was wondering if the not saying it explicitly was coming from not having the thought process or from not choosing to share it
I don't particularly want to shut down black mostly I don't think putting pressure on jupiter to explain themself is a bad thing
There's also an element of me thinking the same thing about jupiter having easy to scum read traits last game, but he was scum, so I'm trying to make sure that I actually have reasons to town read them
I still think the push on me is net towny but that's about it so far
i guess looking at the iso i don't actually have that significant of reasons to townread jupiter either
i just was feeling like the reasons to scumread weren't good ones and i probably have a tendency to overcorrect in the opposite direction when i see that happening
In post 395, fireisredsir wrote:
i feel somewhat similarly although slightly more in the direction of feeling that the things being scumread are just personality traits rather than signs of being scum
was curious since i know you also have read some jupiter meta from trying to sort him last game
I've considered that maybe some of Jupiter's behaviors are personality based. Like maybe he just blurts out reads without thinking about them as either alignment. I think there's a greater than random chance this flips scum though
In post 394, Dannflor wrote:
black is factually correct about jupiter making similar posts as scum
I am not certain that I agree jupiter is scum for it or not
I think the last sequence from black leans towny though? something about the inconsistency in pushing jupiter coupled with the shade on hellbooks feels a bit all over the place in a towny way
not a strong read tho insert more qualifiers here
We didn't mention it earlier when the hellbooks read came out cause we wanted to see how black posted but in our experience the more "huh" type pushes Black has the more likely she is to be scum. As town she can be right or wrong but her posts still have that keen insight vibe
Plural | Nameless (They/He) and Alice (She/Her) and C (They/Them) and more
In post 388, Dannflor wrote:
we could probably just kill jacksonvirgo and have a greater than rand chance of hitting scum tbh
Something to consider is if we should be treating this game as "kill A, reset, kill B" or "kill A and B, optimise order for assassination if we're wrong" since killing a lurker d2 probably loses the game if they're town
Plural | Nameless (They/He) and Alice (She/Her) and C (They/Them) and more
In post 388, Dannflor wrote:
we could probably just kill jacksonvirgo and have a greater than rand chance of hitting scum tbh
Something to consider is if we should be treating this game as "kill A, reset, kill B" or "kill A and B, optimise order for assassination if we're wrong" since killing a lurker d2 probably loses the game if they're town
