Shell Game (Night 3)

[SirCakez]

muahaha

VOTE: experience
nobody even TRs this slot, let's get this wagon rolling

[Lukewarm]

muahaha

VOTE: experience
nobody even TRs this slot, let's get this wagon rolling

I think experience is probably the only other person I'd seriously consider voting right now

[wolfbae]

muahaha

VOTE: experience
nobody even TRs this slot, let's get this wagon rolling

cakez if you are a villager please stop being so god damn wolfy lmao

[morph the cat]

{

Hermit Crab

,

Bingle

}
{CSF, Spiffeh, Luke}
{Dunn, ydrahydra, Marci}
{ wolfbae, STD} STD moves up for spayhalf over trying to quell the slapfight. Neuterhalf is still unimpressed
--------------------------- << above this line, all townreads
{PinguinPower, Oblivion, Firebringer, Sunflower, Bagel, Gypyx} This tier is townlean/null.
---------------------------
{ Dannflor]
{Cakez, experience}

[SirCakez]

muahaha

VOTE: experience
nobody even TRs this slot, let's get this wagon rolling

cakez if you are a villager please stop being so god damn wolfy lmao

bruh

[SirCakez]

I'm not altering my play style because half of this game is incapable of reading me
I'm having fun so I'm happy with that

[morph the cat]

Synced. We'd like to start working more closely with the top 3, and especially top 2 tiers.

Luke are you still doing whatever you were doing on day 1 with us?

Also.

Spiffeh and Gypyx: you two should be able to speak with some authority on whether scum-Cabd would have moved heaven and earth to save Brian yesterday, including writing his posts for him if needed. If you won't, then I'm going to link Tenet and dare this player list to read the abomination.

[wolfbae]

the only slots I'm really unsure on are Gypyx, Oblivion, and PenguinPower

I mulled this over. I'm not really sure I'm ever going to be confident getting a read off any of these players socially but if there's scum in there I think Gypyx maybe makes sense? That's a slot I would expect scum would be trying to push if it was town but instead she got a lot of defense, I know there was an attempted wagon on her yesterday but it didn't get very far, need to track who the voters on that were.

For Penguin in particular, the one thing I noted as good for him was that he swapped to Brian almost immediately after Cakez's catchup, before almost anyone had weighed in on it. I expect most scum players in that spot are going to wait to see which way the momentum shifts on the wagons rather than bussing straight away.

---

Unrelated to the above bits, I kind of think Dragons is more likely to be town based on the way he is playing the day - I would imagine as scum he simply tries to blend in and stay under the radar which is sort of the opposite of how he's playing today. I ~feel~ liker the argument he's in with Firebagel is similar to him getting in a TvT in the past but not fully confident on that either.

[wolfbae]

I'm not altering my play style because half of this game is incapable of reading me
I'm having fun so I'm happy with that

okay

ily

[Spiffeh]

Morph why is Shello up so high now?

[Lukewarm]

Luke are you still doing whatever you were doing on day 1 with us?

My scum read on you guys has largely dissipated I think.

When both of my two strongest town reads (notty and pooky) started being super confident on you guys being town, I started question that read, and considered if I should just sheep them on you guys. Skitter made a post that said that maybe the things that I was identifying as being different about you could be that I was detecting you being sick, which I also took into consideration. So, I kinda decided to reset on you guys back to null before Day 1, and wanted to start again.

I then kinda liked your guilty -> reconsidering on shello, but that is really the only real thought about you guys that I have retained so far this day phase.

[experience]

would y'all like it if i post a reads list or something?

[wolfbae]

People who voted Gypyx in VCs: Pooky, Bingle, Hermit, Dannflor, Penguin

That's 3 confirmed town, Dann who is gut town to me, and Pengu. Last is obviously the biggest ? to me, it's not impossible that as scum he picks a rando push and just tries to make it happen but realistically in a vacuum both slots are a tossup in terms of alignment. I'd guess 1 scum between the two and I think Pengu has a little more going for him.

To me Gypyx feels like a slot scum should have been trying to push if it was town and yet there just wasn't traction really which is probably telling.

[morph the cat]

Morph why is Shello up so high now?

Their reaction to our result on them, mostly, along with claiming something that matched our result without knowing exactly what the positive consisted of. Also, like I said, I vibed very well with ydra before skitter became active and even afterwards.

[morph the cat]

would y'all like it if i post a reads list or something?

Putting down game content is definitely preferable to not putting down game content.

[Dannflor]

I feel considerably less strong about gypyx!town today

I think she's starting to reach PoE slot status due to the strength of other town reads

[experience]

i still haven't read half the game so my reads would be mainly based on

what i've read in the hood

and

interactions

.

[wolfbae]

kinda surprised that cakez got a whole 4 votes with like 16 posts which are all somewhat NAI

Honestly this could very easily be an informed read

agree about scum brian, although i find the way morph is pushing on it intriguing

thoughts on cakez / brian potentially being S/S?

Yeah i think we should absolutely keep scrutiny on cakez, or maybe Bingle? my ego tells me bingle was somewhat threatened

will wait before voting to let everyone pop in

These posts kind of maybe feel like setting up for future pushes especially with the "hey +1 on brian" bit like yknow that's kind of


not really a slam dunk, could still be town, but piqued my interest on a reread

[morph the cat]

I feel considerably less strong about gypyx!town today

I think she's starting to reach PoE slot status due to the strength of other town reads

It's a little disconcerting to agree with someone I'm not townreading. the issue is that every time I go through our readslist I don't find compelling reasons to move you up. :/

I'm hoping discussion with people who do townread you will at least help me solidify.

[wolfbae]

kinda surprised that cakez got a whole 4 votes with like 16 posts which are all somewhat NAI

Honestly this could very easily be an informed read

agree about scum brian, although i find the way morph is pushing on it intriguing

thoughts on cakez / brian potentially being S/S?

Yeah i think we should absolutely keep scrutiny on cakez, or maybe Bingle? my ego tells me bingle was somewhat threatened

will wait before voting to let everyone pop in

These posts kind of maybe feel like setting up for future pushes especially with the "hey +1 on brian" bit like yknow that's kind of

a post that can be a bus

not really a slam dunk, could still be town, but piqued my interest on a reread

i should finish my thoughts before hitting post

[experience]

town

spiffeh
marci/luke/std
dann
sunflower
wolfbae
shello
firebringer
[rest of playerlist]
cakez
morph
gypyx

nullscum

[Dannflor]

well if you need anything from me, let me know

[wolfbae]

i still haven't read half the game so my reads would be mainly based on

what i've read in the hood

and

interactions

.

I don't need your input on the complete game

I need to see your thought process on whatever you have seen

what

your reads are are much less important to me than

why

you are reading people a certain way

[Dannflor]

dann

why am i so town?

[wolfbae]

town

spiffeh
marci/luke/std
dann
sunflower
wolfbae
shello
firebringer
[rest of playerlist]
cakez
morph
gypyx

nullscum

Why are you suspicious of morph? I tried to ask you this and never got an answer.