Mini 1425: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey Mafia

[Seanald]

well you guys still did good, i might say Mollie's power was a bit OP but, you still played well.

[qwints]

That was one powerful hobbit.

[CryoChemist]

Wait, there was no watcher or tracker???

[Empking]

Bilbo Baggins: On N1-N3, N5 protected Gollum_
Dwarf Cop: On N1 targeted Qwints

[serrapaladin]

So Ninja's without Watcher/Tracker, and an Enabler for a single PR? o.o

Good stuff, town!

[qwints]

This seems unbalanced. If I don't quickhammer tehbrawlguy, and he gets to claim, aren't we basically in a follow-the-cop scenario?

[CryoChemist]

0 Scum PRs vs an OverPowered ModConf SuperSaint Doc...

Forget the rest of the Town PRs, yeah this was imbalanced.

It was a fun game never-the-less, but holy shit. Even without the AA QuickLynch, there was

no

chance for a Scum Win here from word 1. We're hard pressed to figure out how we got to 3p LyLo...

GG Town,

~Nudist

[qwints]

We're hard pressed to figure out how we got to 3p LyLo...

[TehBrawlGuy]

Fun fact: Qwints was my clear.


Irony is a bitch.

[pirate mollie]

We were debating a no kill or Gollum target to see if pm's PR still worked....assuming pm would protect Gollum again. In hindsight, that would have probably been a better plan....

I pretty much protected gollum nearly every night. I missed n3 I think. I wasn't sure if my night action still worked. but would have protected gollum anyway. certainly not IFM.

[pirate mollie]

oic

it was n4

also yaye for town!

[pirate mollie]

n1 I was super torn between gollum and mockingday

chose gollum cos I thought he would be harder to lynch cos everyone loves character players

[pirate mollie]

cryo you played a really good game

[Faraday]

0 Scum PRs vs an OverPowered ModConf SuperSaint Doc...

Forget the rest of the Town PRs, yeah this was imbalanced.

The scum NK deals with that nicely, pretty sure? You guys not shooting the confirmed doctor earlier and shooting gollum after was quite baffling. I also don't think you needed the fakeclaim - should have just tried to lynch them. (I think the seanald nk was a mistake too, personally)

[Faraday]

+ the enabler.

Mollie's role is too swingy for my liking though. The confirming part would be fine, the elite part just makes it swing a game in an instant. It's a role that won't always be useful (I don't know how often doc's protect correct, less than once every 2 games I'd imagine) but when it does it's kind of shitty. Eh. Yeah. Don't think it's Op'd by itself....just annoyingly swingy. Imagine if Cryo had been the half ninja doing the kill? THis game ends a lot quicker.

[Faraday]

P.s. Arc your reactions were very legitimately scummy - it had nothing to do with policy for me. I just thought wagoning you would be the best way to read you. I either got lucky or it worked but who cares

Mockingjaye didn't even get to post

[Faraday]

+ the enabler.

Mollie's role is too swingy for my liking though. The confirming part would be fine, the elite part just makes it swing a game in an instant. It's a role that won't always be useful (I don't know how often doc's protect correct, less than once every 2 games I'd imagine) but when it does it's kind of shitty. Eh. Yeah. Don't think it's Op'd by itself....just annoyingly swingy. Imagine if Cryo had been the half ninja doing the kill? THis game ends a lot quicker.

To be clear "it's kinda shitty" when a game gives someone 2 CI and a dead scum.

[CryoChemist]

0 Scum PRs vs an OverPowered ModConf SuperSaint Doc...

Forget the rest of the Town PRs, yeah this was imbalanced.

The scum NK deals with that nicely, pretty sure? You guys not shooting the confirmed doctor earlier and shooting gollum after was quite baffling. I also don't think you needed the fakeclaim - should have just tried to lynch them. (I think the seanald nk was a mistake too, personally)

See, that's the thing. Read the half ninja pm's. They directly reference a watcher AND a tracker. As much as we <3 PM, there is a damned good reason we didn't off her and the Gollum. Can you figure out why?

[Faraday]

Well, I guess I assumed the watcher was a red herring once the dwarf cop flipped as both together would be weird.

[Faraday]

(well not that a fuckin' elite doc isn't weird enough by itself)

[Faraday]

(I'd actually probably have assumed a tracker and no watcher after the flip, though. Making both scum roles red herrings is kinda weird + I guess leads to sub optimal kill choices based on what they believe is sound info)

[TheOneWhoKnocks]

This was actually my first scum game on the site, and I didn't even get to do anything lol.
gg, I thought for a while CN might actually clutch it and win without any partners

[CryoChemist]

It's ok towk, we never stood a chance in this setup.

[Equinox]

Mine?