camn's cold, freezing basement pantry

[Nachomamma8]

I think that setup synergy threw things off a bit; I wouldn't have expected duplication in roles because counterclaim situations.

I really loved this game! Playing with Mastin and Gin and Prism and Fate and Aristo was excellent - I felt like I had pretty solid synergy with all of them in my own special way and I haven't felt good about a game like this in a while.

[Nachomamma8]

Thanks for making me your top draft pick!

I think Pine's drafting was a little meh, Mastina was 100% right about him not doing research on players beforehand which is really the move to make.

[Nachomamma8]

I also think drafting obvious choices as town is mostly the way to go in this and would love to see it as a series.

[camn]

Obv you were my #1. When Pine picked someone else first, I was like CHI-CHING!

I have some thoughts for a series of treestump games.. it could be awesome.

[Firebringer]

so town winning?

[camn]

now? Not really.
Most of the power is nullified at this point.

But good old-fashioned scumhunting may prevail.

[camn]

Welcome Katsuki!
Sorry I cooked you.

[MagnaofIllusion]

And that is how a Day with a guilty should go when you are not in LYLO / MYLO.

Great work on the Hide breadcrumb Nacho. As as previously said it was crystal clear and couldn't be screwed up by Town.

Unfortunately I think that flip will end up hurting Town in the short term in that ...

Spoiler:

Fate and Dreal will both come under scrutiny for their defense of the Godfather slot for meh reasons.

[Katsuki]

NACHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

I misplayed that day slightly due to having to rush to post but I doubt it would have saved me anyways.

[Katsuki]

While I'm sad at not having had more time to interact with this playerbase, this works out for the best in the end. I'd be surprised if the scumteam didn't win off the back of my flip.

[camn]

They might. You replacing in really rescued that slot.
If you hadnt, Jin would be dead, Nacho alive, and another 100-page gameday ;/

[Nachomamma8]

Nah, I don't think we would have spent 100 pages on Day 2. Game goes smoother after a Day 1 scum lynch after lots of talking.

[camn]

Holy shit I need advice:

Spoiler: help

So, Gin used his Eavesdrop on Aeronaut, and this is the post I owe him:

So what's our play here friends?

Do we kill Mastina? Also; it's just me and SC now, but I'm 90% sure if one of us flips, SC is like conftown to them.

Obviously its a doozy, I need to redact it some. But How much?
It is damning for Aeronaut no matter what.
I gotta take out SC, right? And do I leave in the clear on Mastina?

I am thinking full redaction, like this...

So what's our play here friends?

Do we kill

>REDACTED<

? Also; it's just

>REDACTED<

and

>REDACTED<

now, but I'm 90% sure if one of us flips,

>REDACTED<

is like conftown to them.

Is that too much? Does he deserve more, since Gin has actually claimed, Aero KNOWS HE IS IN PLAY?
THis is why I had 2- so that the scumteam would be WARNED, and curtail their communication!

[Firebringer]

its too cold in this pantry, can we get some heat in here camn?

[Firebringer]

Is that too much? Does he deserve more, since Gin has actually claimed, Aero KNOWS HE IS IN PLAY?
THis is why I had 2- so that the scumteam would be WARNED, and curtail their communication!

I think thats the perfect amount to be honest, given how much was in that post that could ruin scum team.

Town can fill in blanks pretty well if they try hard enough.

[Firebringer]

Actually I would include the "me" part, because I don't think thats much of a spoiler.

[camn]

I lovethe mystery tho

[camn]

This is a huge blunder for the scum, I think.
Like.. I anticipated this role could totally swing, which is why I cripppled it by making it 1-shot, AND making it take 2 nights to implement.
But its even crazier-

Gin

has CLAIMED his role. So the scum KNOW what he can do.. then, in

Aero's

FIRST POST OF THE NIGHT.. he just blabs out EVERYTHING! Its crazy.

Can I/should I redact it FURTHER..? No, right? This is this just an unlucky 2 guilty investigations in a row?

[camn]

The Irony?

Gin

had the more powerful shot- he could target Pine. I was really surprised when he DIDNT, and targeted

Aero

instead... but the post of PINE'S that he would have received? This one:

Spoiler:

Hell, I don't know. Part of me says leave Gin and Mastina alive long term so people start doubting the Masonizer bullshit, the other says kill her so the gambit is exposed.

Which would have cleared Mastina, but that's really it.

So its not too overpowered as redacted, right? Its a guilty. But one based on good choices from town, and poor choices from scum. Unless they kill him or something.. then its easy.

[Nachomamma8]

Holy shit

[MagnaofIllusion]

As on outside observer Camn I have a question - exactly how did you specify the ability of the Eavesdroppers in their PMs? Because I really am uncomfortable with you making a decision to redact certain parts of the post if you didn't include a caveat in the role PMs. Especially sine Gin made his counter of BTD6 clear. Aeronaut has no-one but himself to blame for basically outing his partner in the first post of the Night in the PT. I don't fancy making on the fly changes to the game you deemed balanced set-up simply because scum chose to play poorly.

[Nachomamma8]

- Once you have reconned someone, in some SUBSEQUENT night, tell me you want to listen in on them . The next thing they post in a PT will be sent to you.. partially redacted, I am sure.

She said that she would redact part of the message in their PMs.
I agree with redacting the names.

[MagnaofIllusion]

She said that she would redact part of the message in their PMs.
I agree with redacting the names.

Well then I think redacting all names in the post is within reason and any objection I had is null and void ...

[camn]

very good!
The actual PM is in the OP.

Though I agree- Aero knew. Pine knew.

But I like even games. The AMOUNT of redaction was always meant to be in my hands.

[camn]

Omg, pine is making such bad decisions right now. I want to help him... But I won't.