Mini 684: Quacks and Masons Mafia- Game Over

[Netlava]

Hmm... I like the idea of scum not knowing who the masons are and missing the last scum if a mislynch occurs. Scum pulling a fake claim on the final day is harder.

[Porochaz]

no its not, they have to say doctor no matter what.

[Porochaz]

no its not, they have to say doctor no matter what.

if there is a claim that is. If there isnt they have the choice of saying either.

[Jazzmyn]

I can see the logic behind a mass claim, but I don't think it's the best option atm.

Why not? Please explain.

Regards,
Jazz

[Riceballtail]

I know! Let's all mass-claim, but the masons claim doc! It'll protect them!

It's a great idea!

Or it would still provide us with the same amount of information that we ALREADY HAVE NOW.

[Jazzmyn]

Riceballtail, a question for you. Do you believe that Porochaz is the quack?

Regards,
Jazz

[Riceballtail]

I have no way to say if he is or isn't. Should I protect someone tonight to find out?

[Porochaz]

Sigh... then it turns into a guessing game... if we claim then it actually involves skill...

[militant]

I know! Let's all mass-claim, but the masons claim doc! It'll protect them!

It's a great idea!

Or it would still provide us with the same amount of information that we ALREADY HAVE NOW.

Your confusing me as ever. What the hell is the point of the masons claiming doctor when the real doctor will not be confirmed. Doing that just confuses everybody. What the point in claiming a role your not?You saying you will protect the masons that are claiming doctor but for you to do that you would have to be a doctor. Are you counterclaiming me? If so I know you are scum. Also, why have the masons not claimed yet? What are you waiting for?

[Riceballtail]

The doctor won't be confirmed no matter what happens. We know there's 2 masons, a real doc, a quack, and scum. It will show up as 2 masons and 3 quacks. I'm fairly sure that there's no need for a massclaim, because all it's doing is outing the masons. We don't need that.

[Netlava]

Why not? Please explain.

The advantage of a mass claim is that the masons are definitely verified. The disadvantage is that the scum know who the masons are. I think the advantage of the scum not knowing who the masons are outweighs the definite verification since a mason fake claim on the final day does not seem advantageous for the scum.

[Jazzmyn]

Hmm... I like the idea of scum not knowing who the masons are and

missing the last scum if a mislynch occurs

.

Please explain what you meant here. Thanks.

Regards,
Jazz

[Netlava]

I meant missing a mason.

[Jazzmyn]

I meant missing a mason.

So, why did you say "missing the last scum"?

Regards,
Jazz

[muffinhead]

Official Vote Count is still

militant (1)- riceballtail
porochaz (1)- Netlava

not voting (3) porochaz, militant, jazzmyn

3 votes to lynch.

[Netlava]

So, why did you say "missing the last scum"?

Because I made a mistake.

[Porochaz]

Ok ive thought about this. Im now 50-50 about the mass claim. Time to lynch militant I think

vote militant

[Jazzmyn]

Oddly enough, I just logged in after deciding that I should claim and I see that you've changed your mind at least partially, Porochaz. Can you help me out as to why you're now only 50-50 on the idea?

Regards,
Jazz

[Porochaz]

Because my plan only worked if I could act as a vig, which I cant because I cant kill scum. It doesnt matter now whether the masons claim or not, im indifferent.

[Jazzmyn]

Because my plan only worked if I could act as a vig, which I cant because I cant kill scum. It doesnt matter now whether the masons claim or not, im indifferent.

Ah, I see.

Well, it seems that we're at a deadlock over claiming so although it's against my better judgment, I'll refrain from claiming.

Vote: militant

Good night.

Regards,
Jazz

[muffinhead]

The final vote count for the day

militant (3)- riceballtail, porochaz, jazzmyn

porochaz (1)- Netlava

not voting (1) militant

After trying everything possible to explain himself militant was eventually lynched. Unfortunately you open up his jacket to find his doctors badge. Everyone then goes to bed in shock that there is still 1 scum upon them and that militant was just an innocent doctor.

militant- Doctor- lynched Day 4

It is now night. All night choices are due in 72 hours as of this post.

[muffinhead]

You wake up the next morning to find a trail of blood. You then follow the trail which leads to riceballtails room. After opening the door you see riceballtail dead. You then notice his mason identity card.

riceballtail- Mason- Killed during night 4

It is now Day 5. With 3 people alive it takes 2 to lynch.

[Jazzmyn]

I am the third mason. I believe Porochaz's claim that he is the quack. Therefore, the only thing for me to do is:

Vote: Netlava

Regards,
Jazz

[Netlava]

Oh, wow. I guess that makes Jazz the final scum, not Porochaz. I am the third mason.

Vote: Jazzmyn

Porochaz, if you have any questions, feel free to ask.

[Jazzmyn]

Oh, wow. I guess that makes Jazz the final scum, not Porochaz. I am the third mason.

Vote: Jazzmyn

Porochaz, if you have any questions, feel free to ask.

Ha. Nice try, Netlava. I doubt that Porochaz will be fooled by you, though. I think he can read the thread and the voting patterns for himself, and come to the correct conclusion.

Let me know if there's anything more you need from me, Porochaz. Then vote Netlava, as he is most definitely scum as his fake claim has made 100% clear.

Regards,
Jazz