Mafia 44: Generic - Abandoned!

[BrianMcQueso]

I've grown tired of living.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Deadline: one week or so from now.

[Shamrock]

It doesn't look like anything else is going to happen.

Vote: Dukester

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Generic Vote Count:
Dukester - 5 {Shamrock, TSAGod, Fritzler, BrianMcQueso, Dukester}
Not Voting: Blackberry, ArielT, StrykkerVerde, Sotty7, Don Gaetano

With 10 alive, it's 6 to lynch

Prodding Blackberry.

Looking for a replacement for Don Gaetano.

[Fritzler]

unvote, vote: Ariel T

if we can get an extra lynch actually, im all for it.

[Shamrock]

Why Ariel?

[Blackberry]

Vote: Shamrock

Aint Dukestar going to die anyways? Why would we relynch him?
Shamrock also said this earlier, yet he goes and votes Dukestar. Very hypocritical of you.

[BrianMcQueso]

We do it because we've probably had enough deaths today. Lynching either myself or Dukester is essentially the same as no-lynching. However, I have realized (and Shamrock probably has to) that at this point it's simply easier to lynch Dukester than to try to start some other plan that will have exactly the same result.

Fritzler: Again, why Ariel?
Blackberry: Why are you defending Dukester and attacking Shamrock when it is widely believed that Dukester is scum? If Duke does turn up scum, I advise the town to look at Berry. It doesn't prove his guilt, but it's suspicious.

P.S. Why am I, a soon-to-be-dead-man who has given up on today, still posting more than most players in this game?

[Fritzler]

why not?

unvote, vote: shamrock

[Dukester]

Hmm, this is very interesting. Just think about this: Would a mafia member really make the mistake of fake role-claiming to try and kill a townie? I think that the mafia jumped on me for this 'mistake' it was a really punishable mistake but I think only the mafia would really take advantage of it. At this late in the game when the town is almost lost I don't think we should be killing people for lame reasons like "he faked role-claimed".

unvote: Dukester

vote: shamrock

[Shamrock]

Hmm, this is very interesting. Just think about this: Would a mafia member really make the mistake of fake role-claiming to try and kill a townie?

WIFOM much?

Anyway, if you'd prefer not to lynch Dukester, suggest someone else. I'm at a loss here.

[BrianMcQueso]

Just think about this: Would a mafia member really make the mistake of fake role-claiming to try and kill a townie?

Yes. They would.

I think you're all frikkin crazy. I fully believe Shamrock to be innocent, and the scum is having such an easy time pulling all of your strings.

[TSAGod]

What was so bad about what Shamrock did? He's trying to ask Fritzler about his logic...and since when has that been a poor decision?

[Dukester]

We are suspicious of smashrock because of his recent behavior and he aided in lynching two key townies previously in the game.

[BrianMcQueso]

"because of his recent behavior"

Please elaborate-- this is the same line that I've seen scum use to get townies lynched. Players, unwilling to go back and actually look for any behavior, oftentimes take the word that there was "suspicious behavior" and just lynch blindly.

[Dukester]

The burden of proof is not on me; if people want to vote blindly then it is their choice. I can't stop anyone from doing. The burden is on shamrock to prove that he is not mafia.

[BrianMcQueso]

The burden is on shamrock to prove that he is not mafia.

That is the biggest load of crap I've ever heard. Guilty until proven innocent, eh? I'm glad I shot you. It's this kind of faulty reasoning that's misleading the town. Tell me why Shamrock is mafia; he

can't

defend himself if you're

not giving him anything to defend against

.

EDIT: I know I'm not suppose to edit my posts, but the formatting was all wrong. Sorry 'bout that.

[Shamrock]

The burden of proof is not on me; if people want to vote blindly then it is their choice. I can't stop anyone from doing. The burden is on shamrock to prove that he is not mafia.

Wow, completely wrong. The burden of proof IS on you if you're accusing me of being mafia - you have to give me something to refute.

[Dukester]

IT HAS ALREADY BEEN GIVEN! Can you read? Shamrock has not defended himself against either arguement. I really have no reason to say anything because the town is really gay and is cavalier with the votes/day kill. Ya know, there are 3 other people voting for shamrock; I'm not the only one.

[BrianMcQueso]

Dukester, I'm not sure how I'm not explaining this clearly. Shamrock isn't defending himself because you haven't accused him of anything other than not defending himself. You're running in circles!

Three other people are voting for him because they are blindly following you. But if you have no reason to your bandwagon, then they have no reason to follow. The ends don't justify the means.

You are the scummiest player I have ever met. You accuse him of something he can't defend himself against because it has no substance. You use circular logic and don't address the points. And, for some reason, other people follow you. Perhaps it's because they're your scum buddies? You know you're a dead man, so you're trying to drag him down with you, and you're becoming frustrated that some people (myself) aren't buying into your sleaze.

[Fritzler]

unvote, vote: dukester

i just want this day toend

[Dukester]

Dukester, I'm not sure how I'm not explaining this clearly. Shamrock isn't defending himself because you haven't accused him of anything other than not defending himself. You're running in circles!

Three other people are voting for him because they are blindly following you. But if you have no reason to your bandwagon, then they have no reason to follow. The ends don't justify the means.

You are the scummiest player I have ever met. You accuse him of something he can't defend himself against because it has no substance. You use circular logic and don't address the points. And, for some reason, other people follow you. Perhaps it's because they're your scum buddies? You know you're a dead man, so you're trying to drag him down with you, and you're becoming frustrated that some people (myself) aren't buying into your sleaze.

Are you blind? I have given reason against shamrock and he did not address them. I just have to laugh at you thinking I am scum and being the "scummiest" person you have ever seen. And I like how you assume that through my persuasion skills I have made others follow me. This day will end tomorrow due to the deadline anyways. So if you guys want to lynch me you better do it quick.

[BrianMcQueso]

Not lynching you is the same as lynching you. *waits for deadline*

I'll be gone all day tomorrow, for the record. And I'll be dead by in-game tomorrow. So, uh, goodbye.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

EDIT: I know I'm not suppose to edit my posts, but the formatting was all wrong. Sorry 'bout that.

Then double post. You simply don't edit your posts. Ever. It's a matter of principle.

BrianMcQueso, day-vig, has been modkilled

Generic Vote Count:
Dukester - 3 {Shamrock, TSAGod, Fritzler}
Shamrock - 1 {Blackberry}
Not Voting: Blackberry, ArielT, StrykkerVerde, Sotty7, Don Gaetano

With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch

[Fritzler]

oh shit, we're on deadline?

unvote, Vote: Shamrock[/b

i've got thumper's back