BooneyToonz XV: Dance of the Dark Fairy [Third Moonlight]

[SirCakez]

So MC is not confscum then you're just spouting stuff
I just want to vote Titus here but too quick for hammer
I really want to hear from quiet and Elements

What do you want my take on?

Is 5946 a townslip from Lunar? Assuming a vanilla read = a town read?
Why does scum!Lunar tunnel push Math from day1, from before they replaced in?

who is your scum pool rn?
I know everyone else's pretty well

[SirCakez]

cakes i cannot remember

i'm a villager, named VT

[SirCakez]

I think I was wrong about Lunar and it's just (Titus, Elements, Gamma)

[SirCakez]

murdercat just doesn't make sense as scum here with what we know about the setup
also his play has been way townier then most everyone else who is left

[Titus]

I think I was wrong about Lunar and it's just (Titus, Elements, Gamma)

That's literally backwards.

[Lunar Martian]

I think I was wrong about Lunar and it's just (Titus, Elements, Gamma)

That's literally backwards.

You're trying to convince me, MURDER, and Cakez that the scumteam is me, MURDER, and Cakez?

[Titus]

I think I was wrong about Lunar and it's just (Titus, Elements, Gamma)

That's literally backwards.

You're trying to convince me, MURDER, and Cakez that the scumteam is me, MURDER, and Cakez?

No. I am telling Cakez it's you and MURDERCAT. His entire scumpool is town.

[quiet]

I'm here, having a rough day.

My reads in this game are terrible atm; Murder put in a lot of work in the PT to try and get me onsides and push lunar, but given math flip + how different Lunar's play here is vs. their scumgame in my first newbie (here Lunar is putting out a lot more opinions vs. being a lot more cagey in the newbie), and given that I don't see the utility in hardbussing from day1, Lunar is in my townbucket.

fmpov it's very much Murder v. Titus, one scum. I have repeatedly stated in the hood that I buy Murdercat's track claims, as I don't see the utility of fake claiming a confusing/nonsensical track as scum, and again, Math was pushing hard vs. that, which I don't read as scum distancing.

Given

So Titus is scum or all of (Lunar, Elements, MC) are scum
Unless quiet and Gamma just haven't checked recently

And given that I don't find Math distancing from both Lunar and MC as happening with very high frequency vs. just trying to get me, the relatively naive replacement, to misvote one or the other, or at least protect Math, this makes me feel like Titus is scum here.

Elements voting today and yesterday has been...interesting. I'm concerned about the slot, and it's on my shortlist of slots to review.
Gamma is another such slot that I've heard raised a number of times as possibly scummy. It's another slot on my shortlist.

I'm leaning town on SirCakez (this is strictly tone and positioning last few days, and not a strong read), town on Murdercat (think track results come from town with much higher frequency than from scum), town on Lunar (from my experience with the slot, and from struggling to see Mathblade trying to distance from two slots).

Or I'm getting rolled by Lunar again, or more likely Murdercat, but gut feel, I think there are better plays for Murdercat than claiming the track results they got, which makes me feel like with all the transport action going on, it's viable. But I'm ready for someone to step in and tell me I'm missing some obvious stuff here.

[quiet]

Maybe to try and put this more concisely:

Finding Titus town means finding Lunar+Murdercat as scum together.
I don't think I buy that. I'll try to more specifically figure out why and defend that position.

[quiet]

Titus, what is your towncase on Gamma?

[Elements]

So Titus is confirmed scum at this point
Everyone not currently voting Titus has checked the thread and there hasn't been a hammer

[Lunar Martian]

I think I was wrong about Lunar and it's just (Titus, Elements, Gamma)

That's literally backwards.

You're trying to convince me, MURDER, and Cakez that the scumteam is me, MURDER, and Cakez?

No. I am telling Cakez it's you and MURDERCAT. His entire scumpool is town.

OK. That means you're trying to convince me that I'm scum though, right?

[Lunar Martian]

I think I was wrong about Lunar and it's just (Titus, Elements, Gamma)

That's literally backwards.

You're trying to convince me, MURDER, and Cakez that the scumteam is me, MURDER, and Cakez?

No. I am telling Cakez it's you and MURDERCAT. His entire scumpool is town.

OK. That means you're trying to convince me that I'm scum though, right?

[Titus]

I think I was wrong about Lunar and it's just (Titus, Elements, Gamma)

That's literally backwards.

You're trying to convince me, MURDER, and Cakez that the scumteam is me, MURDER, and Cakez?

No. I am telling Cakez it's you and MURDERCAT. His entire scumpool is town.

OK. That means you're trying to convince me that I'm scum though, right?

This is utterly a ridiculous viewpoint.

[Titus]

So Titus is confirmed scum at this point
Everyone not currently voting Titus has checked the thread and there hasn't been a hammer

There's not 4 scum. I said this before. 4 scum makes this game busted as hell.

[quiet]

So Titus is confirmed scum at this point
Everyone not currently voting Titus has checked the thread and there hasn't been a hammer

Does a miselim instawin still? I thought we were starting to feel like it wouldn’t necessarily in a 3 scum world.

It does feel like Titus is indeed scum, though.

[quiet]

That’s some timing. How am I being willfully stupid, Titus? I think my strongest feeling on murdercat is that their fake track/tracking record doesn’t make a ton of sense to do as scum, and that I struggle to see Math positioning himself in the hood pre-sequence flip against both Lunar and Murder as a distancing play vs. just trying to run me over and pocket me. Accepting you as town means kinda accepting both lunar and murdercat as scum here, and that world is hard for me to accept.

[Elements]

So Titus is confirmed scum at this point
Everyone not currently voting Titus has checked the thread and there hasn't been a hammer

There's not 4 scum. I said this before. 4 scum makes this game busted as hell.

If there are only 3 scum and you flip town then there is confirmed scum in murdercat/lunar

[Elements]

as in
if you flip town and the game doesn't end

[Elements]

wait no that doesn't work does it

[Titus]

Right, so even if you think I am scum, we should still be scum hunting. This belief that I am scum is based on the mistaken belief that there are four scum.

Scum vote me on the front end. Then they know town deliberate. Then argue I am scum bc no hammer.

[Elements]

UNVOTE:

[SirCakez]

How could there be only three scum? This is 16p with a shitload of town power.

[SirCakez]

So Titus is confirmed scum at this point
Everyone not currently voting Titus has checked the thread and there hasn't been a hammer

Either that or everyone voting Titus is scum

[Titus]

How could there be only three scum? This is 16p with a shitload of town power.

We have practically no power wtf are you talking about.