Newbie 934 - Game Over!

[Deer]

Nice game all.

Sorry to have blown your mind, Charlie. But I thought you actually did a good job - I would have thought you were town even if I wasn't scum.

[ElectricBadger]

Vote Count:

With 5 players alive, it took 3 to lynch.

(3) Super Smash Bros. Fan: Deer, Charlie, Adrien C

(2) Not Voting: Super Smash Bros. Fan, Lord Chronos

The game is over - congratulations, Mafiosos!

Super Smash Bros. Fan,

Vanilla Townie

, has been lynched.
Charlie,

Vanilla Townie

, was killed in endgame.
Lord Chronos,

Vanilla Townie,

was killed in endgame.

Deer,

Mafia Goon

, survived!
Adrien C,

Mafia Goon

, survived!

[mb53]

=(

Very well played by Deer, I thought for sure he was town. Was suspicious of shad/adrien.

http://www.quicktopic.com/44/H/tF4X39DdVrEPb

[ElectricBadger]

Mafia, any problem with my posting your QT?

Moderator QT roles and actions

Green Room QT dead player chat

Overall an excellent performance by the scum team. That a total of 4 players in two newbie roles avoided any serious suspicion throughout the game is shocking. Deer and her 'obvtown' confirmation definitely cemented the win for scum, especially when she was set up against SSBF in the end.

Town didn't make any fundamental mistakes in my opinion. It was definitely a bad roll to have the IC end up as the doc, though. Razor definitely upset things, coming at a time iirc that some suspicion was mounting on Shad, so wound up a major coup for scum.

[mb53]

Overall, I am very proud of my improvement from my first game... even if I did lose.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

I think I did OK in this game, but I really need to improve big time, especially after Day 3 when I got lynched. At least it went better then this.

May join another Newbie game as a SE once I win a Mafia game surviving.

[Adrien C]

I thought the town did very good in this game. I replaced into a role that already had a cloud of suspicion so I just tried to keep the pressure on everyone with the easier lynch target and had to sweep in when he was L-1. But you guys did a great job, I hope to play a full game with you guys one day.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

@Everyone: Aside from telling me not to give up on a game (I know that), what suggestions would you give me to improve on my future games?

[Deer]

No, go ahead and post the QT. Shad wasn't there for the last day - I had to kill mb53 by myself. Razor replacing sure did help us D2. I was against the lynch just to sort of win "townie points."

SSBF, I actually thought you did a good job considering the pressure I was putting you under. You just never really made a case on anyone, especially D3. If you had stepped up to the plate and maybe posted something against Adrien it could have swayed the game.

By the way, EB, I'm a guy. hahaha

[Adrien C]

You did strong in the beginning, honestly, but you just lost confidence as the game went on. Just avoid letting your confidence and motivation spiral like that.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

@Deer and Andrien C: Just want to say thanks for the suggestions. Maybe I need to join fewer games so I don't have to worry about losing confidence and motivation.

[Adrien C]

Wow, where did that second "n" come from?

[mb53]

You complain too much about your name being spelled wrong... lets look at where mine was spelled wrong:

Questions by mb54:

Possibly busing super.

What makes you think this? Do you know what bussing means?

Which brings me to the possibility of a nacho-charlie scum team.

@Coach Travis & Mb50

I agree with mb50 and his comment on Coach Travis.

mb530 wrote:

@mb50:

mb50 criticism is scummy

[Charlie]

Allright. I'm done sulking. So...

Congratulations to the mafia team of Deer and Adrein C. Kudos also to the replacees, Shadsticle and Eklipse. You've managed to fool town with great success!

Some comments/opinions/positive criticism to each player:

Adrien C - Aha, you replaced in the game late and I detected your lack of attention to the thread because if you've read it properly, you'll notice that I place myself in my suspects list each time. That comment "wow you've suspected yourself" gave you away. Still, you've managed to pull through till the end so there is no difference I guess.

Shadsticle - You've managed to remain neutral throughout most of the game, and that is the main reason you became suspect. Your responses to my unusual comments were interesting and entertaining, to say the least. I had fun playing with you.

Deer - Master manipulator. I didn't think much of Eklipse being town, but I was thinking you were town all the way up till the end, when you looked like you knew exactly what you were doing. However, at the end of the day I thought "what the heck, making a case against him now would seem kinda pointless". I believe I need to eat my other hat... so nom nom nom.

Eklipse - I wonder why everyone thought you were town! I don't know how you did it. Good job there.

Coach Travis - What can I say, I messed up with the hammer on you. Sorry about that.

Nachomamma8 - Looked very town and I could already guess that the NK would be you... Really unfortunate you were the doc, if I were the doc instead, (or any other townie) I strongly believe the protection will be on you. Thanks for IC-ing for us.

Razorback - When playing a text based game that has multiple players in it, being considerate with use of proper grammar and punctuation helps. It increases the fun factor 10 fold.

Matteh - I wished you would have stayed in the game!

mb53 - It felt strange and fun when we were both posting in the same style. I guess there was a sort of 'click' and I trusted your intentions more. Your post content was good. Glad I was right that you're town.

Super Smash Bros. Fan - Commit. I'm sure you had suspicions, you just didn't tell it out. Townies change their suspects all the time. Even if your reasoning is 'gut', that still works. I've heard that in Lylo, gut is more often correct that logical reasoning (don't quote me on that!). Also, you need to defend yourself with activity. You knew that basically EVERYONE was suspecting you, two of them have false intentions. Get your suspects talking to you.

Charlie - What I did in this game particularly is adopt a very different style of play. I was intentionally lackadaisical, sarcastic, impulsive and just went with the flow. The reasons? I got pegged as scummy and subsequently lynched in 3 out of 3 of my first newbie games for playing with seriousness. I learned something from this game eh?

Lord Chronos - Well... I felt like I was playing with a talking robot computer. Twas fun. I truly changed my thought about you being scum because the real scum convinced me otherwise. Sigh.

Robocopter87 - That bickering with SSBF didn't really help town in the end so c'est la vie. We live and learn I guess.

[Charlie]

Ah rats. I forgot our mod Electricbadger.

Electricbadger - Thank you lots for moderating our newbie game. You made timely vote counts and there no complains from me here. Smooth game throughout.

...only...
I can has mafia quicktopic?

[Deer]

yeah, here let me get that for you:

http://www.quicktopic.com/44/H/MKedJgDe6eceG

[Adrien C]

I never got to post in it.

[razorback]

yerah i'll remeber that but peace i'm outta here for a while.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

Super Smash Bros. Fan - Commit. I'm sure you had suspicions, you just didn't tell it out. Townies change their suspects all the time. Even if your reasoning is 'gut', that still works. I've heard that in Lylo, gut is more often correct that logical reasoning (don't quote me on that!). Also, you need to defend yourself with activity. You knew that basically EVERYONE was suspecting you, two of them have false intentions. Get your suspects talking to you.

Pretty good suggestions. I'll keep that in mind for future games I play in here.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Last Post.