glowball wrote:Think about it like this:
We have 6 Doctor
2 Vigs
1 SK
3 Mafia Aligned(1 Doc)
To prove that Neil is the Serial Killer we would have to have both of our vigs target him, and we would need to direct his shot.
Now, if Neil is fake claiming scum he already knows that if BOTH the vigs target him he sees death so the directed shot probably won't happen. Yes, we would vig scum at night if we followed through with testing, but letting him slide by into the night phase means we probably mislynch today which is what all of you are virtually opting for by trusting him- a mislynch.
If Neil is the serial killer then both vigs target him we forfeit our vig abilities because we waste them on testing Neil, while we direct his shot and hope that he listens. If he does listen, great but he still has his own win condition and a VOTE everyday he is alive, he could come in to hammer and play against us anytime he chooses to. Neil has nothing left to lose or gain if he really is the Serial Killer- he's outed himself.
If we do NOT test Neil at all, we are just stupidly accepting his claim then he really gets a free pass and if he is fake claiming scum we are setting ourselves up for a super fail down the line because as I said before he is 1 more body and voice that is against the town.
Really think about it... you want to let Neil slide, trust him, probably mislynch today, and Neil truly believe that he has NOTHING to gain from this?! At the very least he could just be toying with us and like I said if he is the serial killer he has nothing to lose or gain. He knows he will catch death eventually, the fact that he is even begging town for life knowing that signals to me that he is concerned with the numbers which is what scum care about.
No no no no NO! You're ALREADY going to vig someone tonight. You're ALREADY going to lynch someone tonight. Changing the order of that does NOTHING, unless I'm the SK. Then, you have a proven SK to help you with your kills. Simple. Don't complicate things. I'm not forcing you to mislynch, because who you choose to lynch will be who you're choosing to Vig. So either way they are going to die. You're simply switching the order. And if I'm fake claiming, I'm dead anyway. If I'm not, then you have an SK to help you with your kills until you kill me. Simple. Don't overthink or complicate anything. Seriously guys.
Grey is scum, and Glow you're either scum or you're playing right into his web. If you guys seriously opt to lynching me instead of using me for your benefit, you're stupider then I thought and deserve to lose this game. And I'll sit back from the grave and watch Grey and his team run to victory, all over your stupidity and horrible decisions.
I told you, me being the SK will be proven tonight. Vig me. You're not wasting a day, because you're going to lynch me and vig another target. So instead, switch the targets around. Lynch them and Vig me. If I'm fake claiming, I'm dead either way. If I'm not, you can use me as confirmed SK to your advantage? What's the issue there if I'm fake claiming again?
