Mastermind of Sin - 4(Zindaras, AndrewS, Primate, TheEyeOfMordor)
Battle Mage - 2(~N9V~,Battle Mage)
Raffles - 2(Raffles, Cephrir)
Kison - 1(mole)
Cheesefan - 1(Kison)
Panzerjager - 1(Panzerjager)
Rand Althor - 1(Rand Althor)
Primate wrote:Andrew, it should really go without saying, but you have my word that I will not actually execute anyone unless I find them scummy. I've actually only ever played with BM in one game before, and we both died N1, so I doubt that counts.
vote mastermind of sinis good though. Until we know better, we should put the most solid players in the most powerful positions. Mos's main fault is that he's not great at getting people to go along with him, so this should help circumvent that.
@Panzer: No. Your king says that would be unecessary. Dropping more role info will not further convince people, and will just aid hannibalscum in coming up with claims. No offence, but the reason I don't want you on the tribune stand is because I don't think you're a particularly good player yet. You'd veto people for the wrong reasons. And you really, really, need to stop this habit of claiming early for bad reasons. I've seen you do it in a few games now, you figure that if you claim a your role, you will get someone to listen to you, be trusted more. All it really does though is tell the mafia who to actually kill, and prompt paranoia in a town. all the things you're trying to gain can also be gained by simply acting like a townie, putting forward your suspicions well, etc.
AndrewS wrote:if the tribune vetos a person, can that person be re-scheduled for execution?
Rand Althor wrote:Touchy.Panzerjager wrote:BM, never speak about how I play again because you don't know and before I called you a bad player in a different game you said that I was a good player. I belief it was in Mini 400.
What game was this?AndrewS wrote:Primate: Sorry, I hate to be so suspicious, but I was in another game where a similar situation arose, and a player nearly got lynched for absolutely silly reasons. At any rate, my best suggestion is MoS/Mole for Tribune, but I can only vote for one.
Good ol mafia, Mach-Mafia's game.BM wrote:i dont think so. Please reference that game to me. Also, we are currently together in another game. Neither of us are dead YET.
Dude, the guy hasn't got a machine gun. Saying we need 4 veto's to stop zindies reign of terror is a little extreme.Panzer wrote:So You'd rather have someone with one veto instead of two? That makes sense, and primate, I have only claimed by choice in 2 games, this and MK on WIFOM. I actually am not bad at catching scum and I think between me you and MoS we could stop Zindy from lynching the entire world
Do you think it common for scum to lock themselves into a claim this early in the game? There isn't even much of an upside to trade for the flexibility either. The powers of a tribune are hardly game-breaking enough to hit the mindset. You think he's lying about his claim? Why?AndrewS wrote:Panzer: It's not that - we just don't believe your claim.
I wasn't trying to imply that you said that. I agree that it's dubious, yet I also believe that even if he is telling the truth about his role, it's not guaranteed that he'd use it to our advantage.AndrewS wrote:Kison: I'm not saying that because he has 2 vetoes, he's scum - I'm saying that I find it dubious that he does, indeed, have 2 vetoes.