Succession Mafia II: OVER!

[Flameaxe]

Cobble
Spring
Chrono

Which is almost the same list I would have had on page seven. This has been a helpful day. >_>

[Nobody Special]

Oooooh Porochaz getting owned by a girl!

I have questions about one of the facts you seem to take for granted in this sentence.

What

Exactly

is your problem?

Your email is curious, as it clashes with your persona here.

Google is your friend. I honestly expected more from you. Unless you're purposely mudslinging, in which case, get bent.

My list will be coming later in the day.

[DrippingGoofball]

Unless you're purposely mudslinging, in which case, get bent.

Agreed. It ain't right. No game-related motive here.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Google is your friend. I honestly expected more from you. Unless you're purposely mudslinging, in which case, get bent.

My list will be coming later in the day.

Hey NS, what do you mean?

[Nobody Special]

I mean that a quick Google search of the name contained in the email he referenced is enlightening. Therefore, I think he's purposefully stirring up shit for no good reason.

[Fritzler]

Oooooh Porochaz getting owned by a girl!

I have questions about one of the facts you seem to take for granted in this sentence.

What

Exactly

is your problem?

Your email is curious, as it clashes with your persona here.

Hahaha, that is pretty funny. I never noticed that.

Lady Lambdadelta
Lady Lambdadelta
Lady Lambdadelta

If that is not applicable:

Lady Lambdadelta
Xvart
Chronopie

[bvoigt]

My top 3:

Cobblerfone
springlullaby
xvart

@Mod:

I don't think NS is selfvoting.
Fixed. -Flay

[Lady Lambdadelta]

A couple of things about my e-mail:

1) It's my brother's
2) Did you even bother googling the name? Do you watch 24?

[DrippingGoofball]

LLD, we don't care, and no more needs to be said about this. Let's get on with the game.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

You don't care, and I understand it is distracting.

But I'm not going to stand around and have my name dragged through the mud by someone who doesn't even know me.

The simple fact is that

I care

.

Now, moving on, if we are done launching personal attacks at people, maybe you cane spend more time hunting scum, and less time being a douchebag, hmmm Kinetic?

Who's scum, Kinetic?

[bvoigt]

Who's scum, Kinetic?

He is.

[ooba]

Kinetic's bringing this up cause his recruit is getting some heat over the last few pages. Combine that with the fact that he tried to disparage my "I've found scum" post even before I posted (and after I'd said I'll be taking a look at Magister and tajo), I'm guessing tajo is Kinetic's recruit ..

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Who's scum, Kinetic?

He is.

Doesn't mean he isn't hunting for ABR's recruits.

[Yosarian2]

And as for commenting on the major wagons, there are two, I repeat, TWO cult recruits alive in the game. That means there are only TWO anti-town people running about. If I believe I have nailed them, why waste time at all commenting on any other people in the game?

I have you for one recruit, I had Batt as the other. Chrono's lurking/anti-town behavior has me worried though, and I think it is now a distinct possibility that he was recruited just as you were.

Well, you're obviously wrong about at least one of those. More to the point, I'm trying to figure out if you've been recruited or not, so i want to hear your thoughts about people other then "two people you can safely make halfharted attacks against to look busy because they're probably not going to get lynched today." Your case against Battousi, especially, is pretty terrible, and I think it's pretty unlikely he's scum here; I really don't think that a scum who just wants to survive day 1 at all costs would draw all kinds of attention to themselves like he has with his silly gambits.

I'm trying to figure out if all of your "scumhunting" is just you trying to look active, because none of it really looks like you're saying anything you really expect to be taken seriously.

[populartajo]

Kinetic's bringing this up cause his recruit is getting some heat over the last few pages. .

that would be a very retarded way to redirect attention.

Combine that with the fact that he tried to disparage my "I've found scum" post even before I posted (and after I'd said I'll be taking a look at Magister and tajo), I'm guessing tajo is Kinetic's recruit ..

why are you taking CONFIRMED SCUM actions at face value when they know we know they are scum?

[Yosarian2]

Top 3 suspects:
Xvart
Cobblerfone
Magister Ludi

(dis)Honorable mention: (suspect #4) populartajo

[populartajo]

yosa, seriously, why cobblerfone?

do you seriously think kin and abr would have gone with a risky selection and predicted people buying the wifom to not lynch a weak player?

[Kinetic]

A couple of things about my e-mail:

1) It's my brother's
2) Did you even bother googling the name? Do you watch 24?

I did. I knew who Mr. Palmer was. Googling the name, however, doesn't change the fact that it is a man's name, even if it is the name of a character from a show. Add to that, googling the "email address" provides multiple hits of other forums where the email was used by someone claiming to be a "David". Surely you two aren't the same person, hence my question "Who are you". However, if you WERE the same person, I think it would be relevant to this game that you were lying about a lot of things. Mafia is a game of trust in many ways, and this is a very odd thing to explain.

It's all very odd is all, and I didn't make any claim one way or the other as to what it was. I simply said it was an irregularity, and that is what it is. If you read more into it than that, then perhaps you are misunderstanding me. The very fact that my simple bringing it up, with virtually no commentary from myself sparked this much of a reaction SHOWS how odd an irregularity it is.

I personally have never shared an email address with anyone, and really don't know anyone who ever has, at least since the 90s when you could only have like 3 email addresses per family. I'm not trying to "drag your name though the mud", in fact I was very reticent about bringing it up when I discovered it, and thought about simply PMing you about it, but as we're in an ongoing game I felt that might be improper.

Also, I'm scum. Didn't you read the front page?

[Lady Lambdadelta]

If you want to know my life story and why my brother's email account is assigned to this account, you can PM me. It's not game related.

Stop being an ass, and play the fucking game. Who did ABR recruit? You should be looking for that because it helps you as much as it helps us to have his recruits die.

[Kinetic]

If you want to know my life story and why my brother's email account is assigned to this account, you can PM me. It's not game related.

Stop being an ass, and play the fucking game. Who did ABR recruit? You should be looking for that because it helps you as much as it helps us to have his recruits die.

I'm not being an ass, calm down. I noticed an irregularity, I pointed it out. I didn't claim you were lying about your explanation, nor do I make that claim. The fact that you're getting so bent out of shape about this says more about it than anything else.

[Yosarian2]

yosa, seriously, why cobblerfone?

do you seriously think kin and abr would have gone with a risky selection and predicted people buying the wifom to not lynch a weak player?

(shrug)

Out of my top 4 suspects, 2 of them are the "WIFOM outguess the CR's" suspects, people who I suspect because of a combination of their likeliness to be recruited and their behavior (you and Xvart), while the other two are just incredibly scummy, the most likely suspects if you ignore WIFOM stuff and look at their behavior (cobblerfone and Magister Ludi).

The WIFOM "outguess the recruiters" stuff is useful and does have it's place, but I am strongly tempted to just ignore it and lynch people who are acting like scum. Because, yes, if the scum's only goal was for their first recruit to survive the first day, it's possible that a recruiter might have been counting on us not lynching a new player today. Especially if the recruiter personally had reason to believe that they were a decent player, just an unknown one.

Cobblerfone, Magister Ludi: Have either of you ever played with Kinetic or Albert before?

[Yosarian2]

LL: IF I were you, I'd ignore it. We already know Kinetic is scum; if he talks about actual game related stuff, it could work to our advantage, but if we let him distract the town into a pointless side conversation that slows us down, worsens the signal/noise ratio, and waste valuable time, it only helps him and hurts us. Kinetic is smart, he doesn't do anything without a reason, and this is probably a gambit. It looks like he's trying to bait you for tactical reasons, trying to make you mad and keep you talking about non-game-related stuff to make you look worse, to both stall and confuse the town and probably make you easier to lynch. Don't fall for it.

In related news, I am pretty convinced now that at least Kinetic did not recruit Lady Lambdadelta. Baiting your lone cult recruit like that, making them more visible, would be terrible play; and I also don't think LL would get this angry at her cult recruiter, and, no offense, but I don't think she's probably the kind of player who's willing or able to fake that kind of anger. That doesn't prove she's town, of course, but it lowers the odds of her being scum.

[populartajo]

The WIFOM "outguess the recruiters" stuff is useful and does have it's place, but I am strongly tempted to just ignore it and lynch people who are acting like scum. Because, yes, if the scum's only goal was for their first recruit to survive the first day, it's possible that a recruiter might have been counting on us not lynching a new player today. Especially if the recruiter personally had reason to believe that they were a decent player, just an unknown one.

I agree its possible a recruiter might have been counting on us not lynching a new player today.

But its a very risky move, specially since new players tend to get lynched sooner or later, and this pick becomes a high risk, low reward situation in the long run.

We are assuming surviving the first day was the critical variable, but we know for sure that kin and abr definitely thought on the long run when making that decision.

And picking a newbie is not a good decision.

[populartajo]

In related news, I am pretty convinced now that at least Kinetic did not recruit Lady Lambdadelta. Baiting your lone cult recruit like that, making them more visible, would be terrible play; and I also don't think LL would get this angry at her cult recruiter, and, no offense, but I don't think she's probably the kind of player who's willing or able to fake that kind of anger. That doesn't prove she's town, of course, but it lowers the odds of her being scum.

It was time I started to agree with you, yosa.

[Battousai]

NS
Ludi
Tajo

Though, I'd be willing to put anyone under 1.3 posts in place of Tajo.


694 total, 26.6 total avg and 1.7 posts per day avg

First number is total posts (before my last post), second is posts per day

populartajo 20 1.3
Yosarian2 55 3.6
Lady Lambdadelta 44 22.0
ooba 19 1.2
bvoigt 25 1.6
DrippingGoofball 86 5.7
Fritzler 21 1.4
Nobody Special 26 1.7
Flameaxe 28 1.86
Dry-fit 10 .6
Cobblerfone 43 2.8
ThAdmiral 19 1.2
Herodotus 34 2.26
Chronopie 17 1.13
Tanarin 14 .93
Magister Ludi 46 3.06
Porochaz 37 2.4
Battousai 31 2.0
Zdenek 21 1.4
Seraphim 8 .5
Bunnylover 10 .6
springlullaby 30 2.0
xvart 22 1.4
Katsuki 18 1.2
Cecily 6 .75
RaudhrGarm 4 .2

Game Start May 22, for Lady June 4th, for Cecily ended May 30th


Those under 1 post a day:

Dry-fit
Tanarin
Seraphim
Bunnylover
RaudhrGarm

Under 1.3, but at least 1:
Tajo
Ooba
Thad
Chrono
Katsuki

Those who should be prodded:

Raudh (Did he flake out, his last post was BEFORE Cecily? To anyone who has been prodded this game: Do you have to respond in thread to avoid replacement or can you just reply back?)
Katsuki
Xvart
Spring
bunny lover