Open 322: C9++ [Game Over - Scum Win]

[jasonT1981]

Grrr night 0 kills suck!

[Honest Abel]

You played well regardless, jason.

I'm okay with releasing the QuickTopic. projectmatt can approve and link it if he wants.

[Honest Abel]

Wow, clutch roleblock on N3 matt. High five.

[Honest Abel]

Also, in anticipation of criticism, I'm going to restate/maintain that I flirted with the idea of quitting the game because it wasn't a good environment in which to ask questions as a new player (no fault to anyone here, honestly). I will be sticking to the newbie queue for my next few games for that and other reasons.

[DonJosh]

Good job, PM and Abel! I kinda failed :S
Anyway, my miller claim would have worked if I had read my role PM right. I thought I flipped town and appeared scum to cops, but it was the other way around -.-

[projectmatt]

I have no problem with releasing the quicktopic.

http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/gjG3ypivkXT3f

True fact: I WAS online and hiding my status when KDCA and SGR were arguing because I didn't want to take the easy win quite yet. I don't know, it felt mean to snag up the win so easily when SGR is defending himself. Then, when KDCA voted SGR again I just said "screw it" and own.

GG, Abel and DonJosh. I thought we were screwed at some points but we actually managed to pull off a win. -highfive- Excellent. Sorry for bussing so hard so early, DonJosh.

[Honest Abel]

PM, I was going out of my mind yesterday. I saw that Kcd voted, so I was refreshing the game every couple minutes to see when you were online. After only like 5 minutes, I saw you online, so I voted SGR. THen you just disappeared 5 minutes later. I was so pissed.

Next time, go for the easy win please.

[Honest Abel]

I'm lucky that I made a case on SGR earlier, because I would have voted for him regardless, seeing you online. Don't hang your buddy out to dry like that.

[Honest Abel]

Also, don't claim scum before the game is officially over. There could have been a SK or Vig left, which would have meant there was a 50/50 chance that the game would end in a draw if we killed the wrong person at night.

[Honest Abel]

I was afraid of that happening considering we knew that there was a power role left somewhere. Luckily, izak was only doc.

[projectmatt]

Haha, I'm really sorry Abel. I generally like working really, really hard for my wins so I guess I'm not a giant blitzer. I should have gone for the easy win sooner. My bad. Also, it was pretty much confirmed there was not a serial killer OR a vig, but alright.

[Honest Abel]

Not true. I could see a hesitant vig not killing until the end. "Pretty much confirmed" isn't definitive enough.

[projectmatt]

As far as I knew, a vig generally kills at least once during the course of the game, but maybe I was wrong on that meta. And with my rolebocking and our killing we would have a 2\4 chance of hitting this possible vig, and with KDCA being obviouslynotaPR, it would be bigger. But hey, I'm sorry. We won, though.

[Honest Abel]

Oh, yeah, you're right actually. Adding in the roleblock, we still would have definitely won. No harm, then. Just play it safe, though.

[Honest Abel]

matt, you got yourself out of suspicion pretty well, too. Good player.

I'm disappointed that I wasn't ever forced to explain my case on projectmatt. I was putting it off as long as possible. I guess I could have done it and made a good case, but I wouldn't have done it on my own, and someone considering that should have made the connection there.

My first night, I considered killing Kcd, but I'm glad I didn't. It's good to leave volatile/precipitous voters like him in the game if you want an easy last day.

[Honest Abel]

I won Newbie 1092 the same way, by leaving Sloth alive because I knew he was a volatile voter.

My kills in this game and in that game were very straightforward. I've gone after the people who suspect me the most or are most likely to push for a case on me. I really don't believe in reverse psychology. Getting rid of the direct threat is much more important to the overall psyche of the town. That said, I'm probably going to have to change up my strategy next time I'm scum if I don't want an easy read of my meta.

[Kcdaspot]

.......

I don't know if i can accept this loss...

Between DCJ NS and SGR, NONE OF THOSE 3 WANTED TO HELP CONTRIBUTE.

Blacklisting the lot of em.

[Kcdaspot]

PM and Abel.

No harm, no foul you guys played your butts off.

[Zachrulez]

I kinda gave this game a glance during the last day, and was able to pin down abel scum based on interactions with the quickhammer.

... just sayin.

[Honest Abel]

Yeah, seriously. I thought it was curtains when PM decided not to hammer there. I don't understand why Kcd would vote SGR again. We really should have lost because of that.

This was a pretty bad town performance... the game was rather dull most of the time, NS and DCJ were awful, and SGR/izak didn't really do anything. I don't really like Kcd's play style, but at least he tried. Amor was easily town MVP but could have been even better if he kept up with the discussion more. don_johnson kicked in late with some good deduction but was killed immediately, so no real discredit to him there.

[Honest Abel]

I wanted to kill Muffin because he seemed to be the strongest combination of smart and active. He didn't really get a chance either, no discredit to him.

[Amor]

Guys those turbolynches were AWFUL. I didn't even get a chance to post D3! And I told you Abel was scum.

Ah well. Good game, all.

[Amor]

I will admit I had no idea about Matt though.

[SGRaaize]

.......

I don't know if i can accept this loss...

Between DCJ NS and SGR, NONE OF THOSE 3 WANTED TO HELP CONTRIBUTE.

Blacklisting the lot of em.

You're to blame as much or at least almost as much as any one of us, really.
Good game, thanks for modding it, GMAN

[Kcdaspot]

SGR at least you manned up at the last.

Consider NS and DCJ actions thoo.