Succession Mafia II: OVER!

[Flameaxe]

I thought we determined on page 5 that we should basically ignore everything Kinetic and ABR say? Why is this still a topic of discussion? It's not that complicated.

Re Chrono: Chrono can easily be seen as a probable recruit, as someone who was recruited for a good majority of S1. It wouldn't surprise me at least one recruit is a returning player.

Re LL/Cecily: While I agree with the thought behind Tajo's 905, something is just really bothering me about the playerslot. Cecily wasn't exactly anywhere near townie to me, and LL hasn't improved my view all that much. As unlikely as it may be, I'm finding this one difficult to just ignore.

EDIT: What Prozac said.

This was on the last page.

[populartajo]

I dont understand,

He was recruited for a good majority of S1? How did cults work there?

[Flameaxe]

The cult wasn't different, just the leaders weren't stumped.

[populartajo]

I see.

So the two cults tried to recruit him.. In what day? Also, how was his play in that game?

[Flameaxe]

I was the only one who tried to recruit him on I want to say night four. I didn't think his play was all that bad there.

[populartajo]

So if you were the only one trying to recruit him night 4 and his play was so-so, then how does he become a viable recruitment day 1 with white flag rule?

[Battousai]

xvart- I'm of the opinion that the vigs shouldn't blow their load D1 if they only have 1 shot. It would be better if they prolongued it as long as they could.

I don't understand the reason behind discussing if the CR recruited a past recruit from S1. It just seems like extra useless information.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

xvart- I'm of the opinion that the vigs shouldn't blow their load D1 if they only have 1 shot. It would be better if they prolongued it as long as they could.

I don't understand the reason behind discussing if the CR recruited a past recruit from S1. It just seems like extra useless information.

Every day that passes, it's more likely they become scum vigs.

What possible benefit comes from them waiting? Wouldn't it be better to have all those one shot vigs shoot tonight as town?

[populartajo]

xvart- I'm of the opinion that the vigs shouldn't blow their load D1 if they only have 1 shot. It would be better if they prolongued it as long as they could.

I don't understand the reason behind discussing if the CR recruited a past recruit from S1. It just seems like extra useless information.

I just dont understand why a mediocre player is the most suspected player to be recruited.

[DrippingGoofball]

I just wish we'd go back to lynching xvart. We are derailing ourselves.

[Zdenek]

I'm back, but I won't have time to post tonight. I'll do it tomorrow.

[Battousai]

DGB- True. But I'd expect the vigs to be unrecruitable (I think similar to the loose cannon roles, IIRC). If they are recruitable, then they can blow their load early I guess (though it's a risk/reward thing if they wait until their are more recruits to kill).

[Lady Lambdadelta]

DGB- True. But I'd expect the vigs to be unrecruitable (I think similar to the loose cannon roles, IIRC). If they are recruitable, then they can blow their load early I guess (though it's a risk/reward thing if they wait until their are more recruits to kill).

Oh, hmmm. That's fair.

Still though, I think one-shot vigs should all shoot tonight. Best chance of hitting the scum while there is a low amount of them.

If we could eliminate a scum team based on Vig kills tonight, that would be lovely~

[bvoigt]

UNVOTE: Cobblerfone, though I definitely prefer his lynch if there is enough support.
VOTE: xvart

[Fritzler]

I just wish we'd go back to lynching xvart. We are derailing ourselves.

Good point. Why is xvart dead yet?

[Nobody Special]

There seems to be love for the Batt

mobile

wagon, so:

Unvote

Vote: xvart

[Battousai]

Lady- That last post is just wrong. The best chance at hitting the scum is when there is a high amount of them. There is a high chance of the vigs weakening the town tonight if they misfire.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Lady- That last post is just wrong. The best chance at hitting the scum is when there is a high amount of them. There is a high chance of the vigs weakening the town tonight if they misfire.

Yeah, there's a higher chance of hitting them...

but there's still MORE TO HIT.

So I still advocate it being fired tonight.

[populartajo]

wtf are you talking about?

The best chance at hitting the scum is later, when there are a lot of recruits.

With a reduced number of recruits, a vig shoot is dumb.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

What do you people not understand about cults?

If you shoot on Day 3 when there are, say, 6 recruits between the two teams plus 2 recruits that night?

It is MUCH LESS LIKELY you will be able to put a dent in the scum team, when they have more members.

Than if you say, shot tonight tonight.

[Tanarin]

OK, finally catching up.

Guess i need to throw in 3 names to nominate huh?

Yos2
Chrono
LL (Not liking her last few posts about OSVs shooting tonight. Logic is just completely off IMO.)

As far as this whole D1 recruit thing, TBH I think people are thinking too much on it. In the end it does not matter. All that does matter is we get the recruits.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Tanarin, can you explain what part of the logic you don't like?

[Battousai]

The logic's not off... just worded weirdly.

The fewer the scum, the more impact a scum vig kill will have (going into D2 with 1 recruit still). I don't agree with that should be done, but it is reasonable.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

The logic's not off... just worded weirdly.

The fewer the scum, the more impact a scum vig kill will have (going into D2 with 1 recruit still). I don't agree with that should be done, but it is reasonable.

Yeah, that's a better way of saying it.

[Dry-fit]

The more I think about it the less likely it seems that Chrono was recruited.

@Chrono, what do you think of the fact that you got the most votes in ThAd's list?