Mini Normal 1797 Probably Not Actually Normal Mafia [GG]

[Dwlee99]

and I never get night killed so I didn't need to worry about that lol

[Nahdia]

except I'M NOT A WEREWOLF.

[Nahdia]

well good for you. i get nightkilled frequently so i had to fly low.

[Dwlee99]

but you ARE a werewolf

[Nahdia]

no im not holy shit

[Dwlee99]

lmao

[Nahdia]

lmao.

you should probably let me claim before hammering me, just throwing that out there.

i crumbed my rooolleeeeee

is that what you were hoping for? because i did the thing. even though it's stupid and shouldn't equal an automatic clear.

you're ignoring all the other points i raised. they're all strong points, i think. i don't know what else i can do here. PLEASE reconsider. i'm begging you. i was mad at myself for weeks after zelda mafia because i couldn't believe i was too stupid to reconsider on the final day.

this is all i've got. at this point i feel like i've played to the best of my ability and if you still hammer me, the blame is out of my hands. murder, if you're reading this, im begging you to reconsider. snoe, if you see this, please talk it out with murder and don't just sheep him. i am town here.

just gonna quote this. snoe please read this day and don't just cast a vote. i'm far more likely town than dwlee if you just look at the facts.

[Dwlee99]

In post 310, Dwlee99 wrote:
like my town case for him is:
Joined: April 26, 2016
^ despite some of their pushes being p bad their join date makes me see their efforts to scum hunt as town.

pedit who tf is prof

defending for the sake of defending. If sick flips scum then dwelee scum.

yep this is bussing mhmm

[Nahdia]

cooldog wasn't on a team with sick. he might have thought sick would flip town.

[Dwlee99]

Wait don't we need to policy lynch you because if you're a scum doublevoter in lylo you could auto win?

because town double voters don't exist? This vote is scummy as fuck d1.

:Roll:

Wait don't we need to policy lynch you because if you're a scum doublevoter in lylo you could auto win?

because town double voters don't exist? This vote is scummy as fuck d1.

Since when is fucking scummy?

ignore cooldog. He just missed me changing my mind in the very next post with the very amazing voting feature that adds a white fill to the text somehow. Totally not just trying to throw shade~

defending for the sake of defending. If sick flips scum then dwelee scum.

Why can't I be scum white knighting someone?
Why can't I be town considering all angles?
What if sick flips self-aligned scum, am I still scum?

Lastly, why are you trying to line up lynches?

defending for the sake of defending. If sick flips scum then dwelee scum.

Why can't I be scum white knighting someone?
Why can't I be town considering all angles?
What if sick flips self-aligned scum, am I still scum?

Lastly, why are you trying to line up lynches?

in every fucking game that I do this everyone always says, "but CooLDoG, you bastard, why u line up lynches?" well, put simply, I'm not. There is no reason for a town member to defend someone weakly. Either there is a solid reason someone is town that would logically prevent them from being lynched (a good claim, for instance) or there is a soft bullshit reason reason for keeping them alive. Every time I see someone defend someone else it begs the question, "why?". What initiative does a town member have to defend a player that is soft town-null? There is none. The only reason someone would come out and

randomly defend

someone else is if they had a self-interested reason in defending someone. This is scummy. Town's motivation is collective survival, scum motivation is for individual players to survive. Thus defending players is scummy. If you buy meta bullshit you can look this up in pretty much all of my games going back ~two years and you will note:

1) I rarely defend players, normally refraining from such until d3 or later provided no contingent bullshit claims.
2) I have called out players on this "tell" before.
3) I am right and you are wrong.

fuck his claim

^why? This is scummy as fuck considering we still have time.

I was writing a bit of a long-winded response to cooldog but it isnt worth it. Basically just soft town reads are there for a reason and talking about those reasons isnt scummy. And I dont think you answered my questions about if sickofit flips town/selfaligned,

I feel like my wagon has to be all werewolf or werewolf has no daytalk. That means Im fine lynching cooldog.

VOTE: Cooldog
Him and fire are least likely to be mafia.

I would prefer not to lynch mafia and lose.
pedit Nahdia and cooldog are on my wagon.and I havent been hammered yet. That means the werewolf team is probably nahdia cooldog and one of fire and dramonic.

[Dwlee99]

cooldog's entire game was trying to lynch me lol

[Dwlee99]

let's finish this perfect win @murder @snoe

[Dwlee99]

IS THIS WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR? I CRUMBED.

I.
DO.
NOT.
PLAY.
SUBOPTIMAL.

wait why would werewolf shoot the mafia if they would have just gotten end gamed by the masons???

WHY ARE YOU SAYING THIS IF YOU AGREED WITH ME YESTERDAY YOU WOULD DO WHAT I SAID I WOULD DO.

IS IT NOT OBVIOUS DWLEE MADE THE MOVE?

COME ON.

the play we're talking about isn't even optimal lmao

LOOK AT THIS. HE'S DEFENDING HIS MOVE -_-'

except I'M NOT A WEREWOLF.

I also think that nahdia is too mature to be capsing about this lol

[Nahdia]

Hold up. I just thought of something major I hadn't considered before

[Dwlee99]

that you realize town deserves this win and you should self-hammer, yea? ^-^

[Nahdia]

Dwlee is basing his towncase around him not being partners with the werewolves.

Why are we assuming the last scum is a werewolf? We had a cop, which is a role that gets guilties on mafia, not werewolves.

[Nahdia]

That would be a major imbalance between the scumteams unless there was a seer too

[Dwlee99]

so you believe that the setup is 4 mafia goons, and 2 werewolf goons. Really. Really? That's the best bullshit you could come up with?

[Nahdia]

Or an SK, yeah. It makes sense that you'd base so much of your defense on not being partners with cooldog on it.

[Nahdia]

Maybe I'm talking gibberish but this just occurred to me. It screws with a lot of assumptions as well as some of my own points though.

[Dwlee99]

you're reaching so hard

[Nahdia]

so then why are the scumteams unbalanced? i think im onto something.

[Nahdia]

you're smart enough to know this isn't completely farfetched, dwlee. so you insinuating it's a reach makes me think im actually on the right track here

[Dwlee99]

Yes THREE scum kills in this game is totally winnable for town in any way.
pedit it is farfetched, it is so stupid

[Nahdia]

so then why is there a cop and not a seer?