Open 564: Duck Duck Goose - Game Over!

[Riddleton]

I'm interested in just kibble's lynch at the moment, because he's the only person I'm confident enough to say is 100% scum.

[kibbles0515]

im surprised you didn't try to kill me

also fairly certain the saki wagon had the entire scum team on it

So you think it is Anatole, myself, and....?

[zMuffinMan]

im undecided on the third but seeing as i said i think the entire scum team is on the saki wagon, i'm sure you can take a guess at who i think is likely

also pretty sure that post is a scum claim seeing as you have two votes on you and you don't seem at all concerned about that

rather you're concerned that i called you and anatole scum

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

Okay, I think zMuffin is town, Riddleton is town. Both of their predecessors seemed shaky but I got a newb town read off of them, and having since replaced, they both seem to be on more solid ground.

I am still liking Ranon for scum based on chaos. It's really annoying that the slot is just kind of sitting there.

Aergor and Anatole both had naked votes on Saki (Saki did as well tbh) and all three of those votes happened with alarming speed. I am starting to think that one of them might be scum. There were still a few days left and even though I didn't think Saki did much to act like town I think Saki reacted hella emotionally (especially now knowing that the role was town). It might have been something which he could have cooled off and come back from. But he didn't get the chance because he was hammered.

I still like Kibbles as a probably scum too, but I'm really not a big fan of the quick hammer, I think voting him puts him at L-1 and I don't want to do that just yet. Maybe later. I don't even think Aergor has shown up yet today. I'd like to hear something from him before by some chance kibbles gets lynched before he even shows up again.

VOTE: Anatole

[zMuffinMan]

no, Anatole is super-town, can't you tell? He quick-hammered saki even though his reads were that ranon, kibble and I are scum, but that wasn't opportunistic in any way, that was because he had a change of heart and felt cutting discussion off immediately was super protown

and yes I am newbie town, thanks for noticing

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

I actually didn't call you newbie town, I thought your predecessor was. You look like you know what you're doing.

[Anatole Kuragin]

he played against wincon and was kind of a shit head for voting himself, maybe a bad move to hammer him in hindsight

[kibbles0515]

im undecided on the third but seeing as i said i think the entire scum team is on the saki wagon, i'm sure you can take a guess at who i think is likely

also pretty sure that post is a scum claim seeing as you have two votes on you and you don't seem at all concerned about that

rather you're concerned that i called you and anatole scum

So...is that post a scumclaim because I'm not concerned that I have two votes, or that I'm concerned you called me and Anatole scum? I'm...I'm a little confused.

I'm not concerned about two votes because there are still people to hear from; No need to go on the crazydefensive to respond to two votes. I'm not worried. Should I be? Are you hoping I'll be a mislynch?

[zMuffinMan]

nobody can be that dumb

there's 7 alive, today is lylo, you have 2 votes on you, in a theoretical universe where you were town, you'd know you have at least one scum currently voting you, and there's basically no way any two people off your wagon can be scum together from your PoV unless one of them is ranon

you're not worried though because you don't have anything to worry about

you're not in danger of being quicklynched because you're scum

[kibbles0515]

nobody can be that dumb

there's 7 alive, today is lylo, you have 2 votes on you, in a theoretical universe where you were town, you'd know you have at least one scum currently voting you, and there's basically no way any two people off your wagon can be scum together from your PoV unless one of them is ranon

you're not worried though because you don't have anything to worry about

you're not in danger of being quicklynched because you're scum

Or maybe the people we haven't heard from are...well, not here. Maybe scum is bad and nooby. Maybe they are just biding their time. It is all purely speculation.
Ranon's slot

could

very well be scum, which might explain why a quicklynch hasn't happened yet. I'm not going to freak out yet. Relax.
Or, you could vote if you are so sure of my alignment. But you aren't voting, which means you aren't sure you want to put me at L-1, which means you don't want me lynched because you have doubts.

I would like to hear what

Anatole's

reasons for his vote are...

[Aegor]

Feeling really good about muffin; feeling really bad about kibbles for objective reasons stated by muffin. I will look at the wagons tomorrow and post my conclusions.

[SMP]

VOTE COUNT 4.1

4 votes for a lynch

kibbles0515

(L-2) - Riddleton, Anatole Kuragin

Anatole Kuragin

(L-3) - ForWhomTheJellyRolls

Not Voting

- kibbles0515, Aegor, zMuffinMan, Ranon

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2014-10-07 15:00:00)

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

Who do you suspect aside from Kibbles, Aegor?

[Aegor]

Catching up

[zMuffinMan]

prod dodge, this game really needs a ranon replacement or all meaningful discussion about the votes in this day phase is moot since it's technically possible for a scum team involving ranon to not be able to quick-hammer here

also got to thinking at some point about the possibility of a kibbles-anatole-ranon team but meh, it's something to go back and look at later maybe. probably not all that likely

[Riddleton]

Have you caught up yet, Aegor?

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

Aegor, what's your read on Anatole?

Anatole what's your read on Aegor?

[Aegor]

My read on Anatole has remained constant throughout the game. I have been scum with him and town against scum-him, and his play here is not like either his play in either of my previous games with him. While he is certainly intellectually capable of altering his scumgame, unless he has changed it drastically, he is town in this game. I would be happy to read why his play has been scummy if someone has compiled such a case.

I have run ISOs of kibbles and chaos. Kibbles ISO leans town to me; I am happy to explain why upon request.

chaos is still scummy, and Ranon has obviously not changed that.

[Aegor]

I did a limited VCA.

The only non-town-confirmed players who were on the Day 2 and 3 wagons are Aegor, Anatole, Jelly, and kibbles. From the Day 1 wagon, we additionally have Riddleton, muffin, Ranon slots.


I would say there is almost guaranteed scum in the Day 2/3 wagons.

Cursory Psychotropia ISO also leads to a town lean. So either scum was completely off the two most recent (near-)lynch wagons, or my read of at least one of Anatole, kibbles, and Jelly slot is off.

[Riddleton]

So you think it's Ranon + {who else?}

I'd appreciate it if you explained your town lean on Kibbles.

[SMP]

MODNOTE

Micc is replacing Ranon.
24 hours will be added to the day for the replacement.

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2014-10-07 15:00:00)

[Micc]

Sup

I heard you guys needed a replacement

[Micc]

From what I gathered in my pre-replace in scan this is basically 7p lylo. I see votes which is weird since youve been waiting on a replacement for so long and its lylo.

So....explain votes please. Im going to go

do homework

read some stuff.

[Micc]

VOTE: saki

lynch this

this seems pretty sheepable to me.

Anatole please explain what was going through your mind for that hammer.

[Micc]

Also. you guys should unvote.