Dethy IX! GAME OVER!

[springlullaby]

But then I could be naive and Tajo could be sane, couldn't that work too?

yep, thats what i was thinking but spring took a decision

that's bullshit, from your point of view if you were town there there the only possibility is my being scum

so you not 'taking a decision' is the best indication of you being scum

[knox]

Give me a minute to think

[populartajo]

But then I could be naive and Tajo could be sane, couldn't that work too?

yep, thats what i was thinking but spring took a decision

that's bullshit, from your point of view if you were town there there the only possibility is my being scum

so you not 'taking a decision' is the best indication of you being scum

this is my first game as deathy so i have no idea how to play it
you took a decision since from you pov it was only you and me
how does that not show scum behaviour?

[populartajo]

spring ---> innocent knox/ innocent on image/ innocent tajo (naive, sane)

why did u assume you were naive?
it doesnt make sense

[populartajo]

i mean why did u assume you were sane?
you had an inocent on me and an inocent on knox, that only makes sense if you were only naive.
or you are scum.

[springlullaby]

But then I could be naive and Tajo could be sane, couldn't that work too?

yep, thats what i was thinking but spring took a decision

that's bullshit, from your point of view if you were town there there the only possibility is my being scum

so you not 'taking a decision' is the best indication of you being scum

this is my first game as deathy so i have no idea how to play it
you took a decision since from you pov it was only you and me
how does that not show scum behaviour?

No,

1. When I pointed out the problem in the result, you didn't even try to figure thing out

2. Your 'I must be naive' is actually pretty indicative because from the result you can't be naive if you are town ---> methink you tried to impersonate naive by claiming innocent all the way - this is a hard tell, because you didn't even try to figure the setup up

3. This is the second time I play dethy, and I'm not playing the lame newbie card

[knox]

spring - innocent by tajo
- innocent by knox

There can't be two naives

[knox]

But then I could be naive and Tajo could be sane, couldn't that work too?

yep, thats what i was thinking but spring took a decision

Then this does not work

[springlullaby]

spring ---> innocent knox/ innocent on image/ innocent tajo (naive, sane)

why did u assume you were naive?
it doesnt make sense

What are you talking about, I never assumed I was naive by the above result.

I'll repeat it once again for knox, because you are obviously trying do pull shit on me:

knox - innocent by tajo/ spring
- guilty by image

This result is impossible, because if knox were scum, one of tajo or me would have gotten a guilty on him

hence knox is innocent and it's down to tajo or me

and I know i'm innocent

so it's tajo

[populartajo]

spring ---> innocent knox/ innocent on image/ innocent tajo (naive, sane)

why did u assume you were naive?
it doesnt make sense

What are you talking about, I never assumed I was naive by the above result.

I'll repeat it once again for knox, because you are obviously trying do pull shit on me:

knox - innocent by tajo/ spring
- guilty by image

This result is impossible, because if knox were scum, one of tajo or me would have gotten a guilty on him

hence knox is innocent and it's down to tajo or me

and I know i'm innocent

so it's tajo

its your word against mine, I corrected myself, please read, you assumed you were sane when the only logical assumption was to assume naive.

[populartajo]

i mean why did u assume you were sane?
you had an inocent on me and an inocent on knox, that only makes sense if you were only naive.
or you are scum.

[knox]

Lynch Tajo

[springlullaby]

Do I need to repeat myself again?

[populartajo]

spring ---> innocent knox/ innocent on image/ innocent tajo (naive, sane)

why did u assume you were naive?
it doesnt make sense

What are you talking about, I never assumed I was naive by the above result.

I'll repeat it once again for knox, because you are obviously trying do pull shit on me:

knox - innocent by tajo/ spring
- guilty by image

This result is impossible, because if knox were scum, one of tajo or me would have gotten a guilty on him

hence knox is innocent and it's down to tajo or me

and I know i'm innocent

so it's tajo

seems like you prepared all this
and im not using the lame newbie excuse, kaybaythx

[springlullaby]

Lynch Tajo

thanx

[populartajo]

Lynch Tajo

Nooooooooo
its voting.
GG, spring.
Town loses

[springlullaby]

[Alduskkel]

springlullaby and knox agreed it was tajo;
so they went to the lynching place, with tajo in tow

Well, he was scum!
springlullaby and knox settled down for some lunch. Yum!

[springlullaby]

Yay :p

[image]

The amount of time that took was aggravating... I had it figured out within a couple minutes of D3 results being posted, using only info in the thread. (I was insane btw)

So, spring had innocent on knox and Tajo, meaning he's either naive or scum.
Tajo had innocent on knox and spring, meaning he's naive or scum.
knox had three innocents so he could not be insane or paranoid, and since one of Tajo or knox is naive he must be sane. He had an innocent on spring, therefore Tajo is scum.

[Battousai]

'bout time. Took you guys long enough to vote tajo nah, jk. Good job. I narrowed it down to all three of you being naive/sane. Then went back through and only one person of the three could be sane and that was Knox (both tajo and springlullaby got innocents on the other two players. Sane would have one of the results be guilty). Knox got an innocent on Springlullaby and thus Tajo is scum.

Good job of blaiming Spring and trying to make him look bad for making a decision.

[knox]

Woot!

[populartajo]

Lol, no I got a cop role.

GG people. This was indeed my first game in dethy. Its pretty clear I had no idea how to defend myself or why did I kill Batto or image.
GG, knox and spring.

[Alduskkel]

ROLE REVEAL:
populartajo - scum
springlullaby - naive
image - insane
Battousai - paranoid
knox - sane

[springlullaby]

The amount of time that took was aggravating... I had it figured out within a couple minutes of D3 results being posted, using only info in the thread. (I was insane btw)

So, spring had innocent on knox and Tajo, meaning he's either naive or scum.
Tajo had innocent on knox and spring, meaning he's naive or scum.
knox had three innocents so he could not be insane or paranoid, and since one of Tajo or knox is naive he must be sane. He had an innocent on spring, therefore Tajo is scum.

yeah that