Y wrote:First of all, I'm sorry to inform you and the other you that the post is very confusing, and it was hard for me to understand what you were trying to say (And I'm not completely sure I did).
I'll rephrase: I should have been clearer. And I am talking to Imaginality aka Charles the kidnapper.
I find it interesting that I am in your first list of possible players who made the scum kill, even though you claim to have kidnapped me and to believe that Tina roleblocked Richard (therefore, did not block you). So if you're telling the truth you would have firsthand knowledge that I could not have made the scum kill; but it's not in your first list, even though you reiterate your claim in the "killing roles" paragraph. Why didn't you rule me out?
I don't particularly think you're scum just because you kidnapped me; as you say it's prudent to kidnap me in order to keep the body count from piling up. But if I were scum my role would be the one to kidnap; it's got a plausible reason; it's not as scummy looking as kidnapping the watcher or tracker; and it's the one that can try to kill off scum.
Y wrote:From what I did understand, you're asking why you weren't ruled out as the killer if you were blocked? If so, Vicki did put you on the unlikely list both as the SK and mafia killer.
Oh yes,
Vicki/Tarhalindur
ruled me out later. But why didn't
Charles/imaginality
do so in his early list, especially since he would have firsthand knowledge that I couldn't possibly have killed? Instead he puts me as a possible mafia killer. Which I can't be if he kidnapped me.
Because if I were Charles/imaginality trying to find the killer, it would go like this:
* Tina, Richard, and Tom seem (assuming they're not lying) to be verified as doing other night actions. So they're not the mafia killer.
* Tina roleblocked Richard, so she did not roleblock me.
* I kidnapped Mary Rose, so she couldn't have done a night action.
* So Mary Rose could not be the mafia killer.
The last two are things that CHARLES HIMSELF claims to have done, so why wouldn't they figure prominently in his logic?
But if, for example, Charles/imaginality was scum who hadn't actually roleblocked me, but only claimed to (after all, I chose not to target anyone, and there doesn't seem to be a missing kill, and there's no stabbing kill), then he might forget what he claimed to do, and leave me off his list.
Y wrote:That said, you can still be mafia, but not the one who made the kill.
Yup, there's no evidence yet ruling me out as a mafia member.