Lay of Leithian Mafia: Game Over!

[Cobalt]

the cyberbob case is way better

Vote Count 18: Lynch

Starbuck - 1 - PaltryExcuse
xvart -

5

- Budja, Kmd4390, FeFiFoFum, Anon, Jack
Anon - 1 - Elscouta
xofelf - 4 - SensFan, Drippereth, Papa Zito, xvart
Jack - 4 - SpyreX, curiouskarmadog, Steam-Powered Shovel, Elmocrates
Cyberbob - 2 - Cobalt, Iecerint
Papa Zito - 1 - ooba
Cobalt - 2 - Cyberbob, Starbuck
Steam-Powered Shovel - 3 - farside22, SocioPath, MehPlusRawr,
FeFiFoFum - 1 - J-Scope

Not Voting (1): xofelf

With 25 players alive it'll take 13 to lynch and 13 to no-Lynch.

There are no players in the

Halls of Mandos

, so right now there are no

Revive

or

Destroy

counts.

[Papa Zito]

What's the cyberbob case then?

[Cobalt]

Uh oh, I thought you remembered.

[Papa Zito]

I frequently forget things. Tell me again. Use small words.

[Elmocrates]

Cyberbob isn't the type of player to fall for the daykill trap even if he was scum, so that maneuver was a pointless one at best.

The question I want answered is should Jack know this?

Beyond that, I think all of the current cases are fairly lame right now and am thinking a lurker wagon is the way to go right now. We have too many people in this game who are total non-entities.

I mean, MPR is total fail but at least they have posted, which is more than I can say about Ooba or FeFiFoFum.

Since I have seen FeFi lurk like this as town but I haven't seen Ooba do so (not in a "Ooba only lurks as scum!" sense, but more in a I have no meta knowledge of Ooba sense) I like that vote best.

Maybe Anon would be Ok.

unvote, vote:Ooba

How does everyone feel about a lurker wagon at this juncture?

-crates

[Elmocrates]

Someone give me the xvart case. I remember thinking it was weird and not knowing what it was about.

As I understand it, he says joking about being scum is suspicious and used it as a D1 reason. This is pretty thin at best, and a bunch of people don't believe this stance is legit. Maybe some other stuff.

A "secret towntell/scumtell" is a valid tell that cannot be elaborated on because of the rules of the board

That's rather different from what I thought you meant. Secret is, uh, something you want to keep secret. Something you can't talk about is.. that. If the rules of the board didn't preclude you doing so, would you state this publicly? (I kind of assume it's connected with an ongoing game. I don't know if you're allowed to confirm or deny this, fwiw.)

I don't see why announcing "secret town read" would change other people mind. I don't think you should have announced it at all, or as "his last post made me change opinion on him".

It influenced me. Counter-point? What's to lose from saying that?

Pointing out that a daykill is fake makes scum less tense and less likely to slip up. Town have no reason to point it out prematurely whatsoever.

is correct. It's very obviously anti-town. If you believe anti-town=scummy, then it's scummy. I imagine that's where a bunch of people are going; I'm not joining them.

I would be extremely happy to kill any one of the sizeable group not pulling their weight. In fact, I will vocally support any proposed lurker lynch until matters improve and that would probably be my wagon of choice right now.

Elmo

[Elmocrates]

Hey, we randomly posted at the same time again. Cool

-crates.

[Elmocrates]

Yeah! Have I mentioned that my other head is extremely awesome?

Elmo

[SpyreX]

I, of course, will happily and with extreme prejudice help eliminate the lurker problem.

[Drippereth]

MPR is town. VI town.
I'm now also leaning toward town on Jack and Cobalt.
Sens vs. Xof was a nondecision. Have a big gut town read on Sens from his tone.
Xofelf wagon is now ALSO a LURKER wagon. More people should hop on.

[Elmocrates]

I am awesome? Lies. Clearly you are wilely scum trying to buddy up to me.

...

Ohwait.

(<3 Elmo)

-crates

[Cobalt]

I frequently forget things. Tell me again. Use small words.

bob is scum
see bob hang
die bob die!
bob is scum

[SpyreX]

Vote: Ooba

[Drippereth]

What do all you people have against voting Xof.

[Elscouta]

I fully endorse an Anon wagon. Free cookies for everyone participating.

[Iecerint]

OMGUS at Budja and Cobalt and "rhetorical" expression of a desire for the cop crumb to be made explicit. He said it wasn't OMGUS because he had valid reasons for his suspicious (fence-sitting and lurking, IIRC, and he backtracked on the former). I don't think he ever explained the latter.

He also said I couldn't read.

My favorite lynches are CB and SPS.

Drip, who do you mean by "VI"? MPR?

[SensFan]

Xofelf wagon is now ALSO a LURKER wagon. More people should hop on.

This. Active Lurking is a far greater scumtell than inactive lurking, and xofelf has done nothing but active lurk.

[ooba]

Sorry have been busy in some of my other games - will catch up and post here - expect a post in less than 12 hours ..

[SensFan]

DGB (Assuming it's you, if Elli, question still stands), what's your take on the fact so many people are either defending xofelf or unwilling to vote her?

[SpyreX]

Called out at 3:59. Posted at 4:14. NOICE

[Cyberbob]

What's the cyberbob case then?

There is no case, Cobalt thinks he's pounced on a SCUM OVERREACTION in my supposed attack on Kmd over what was, to him, an obviously-sarcastic comment. In reality I simply did not spot the sarcasm and my "attack" consisted of "WTF this must be sarcastic but I don't see any signs of it, can kmd/someone else point it out to me plz".

[Iecerint]

I replaced lurkerXofelf in the only game I shared with her. So. If she's not just always a lurker, please inform me of the fact.

Other than that, I don't see the case.

[Elmocrates]

Sorry have been busy in some of my other games - will catch up and post here - expect a post in less than 12 hours ..

Worked like a charm.

I humbly request more Ooba votes.

[Cyberbob]

Re xofelf: Still waiting on her reaction to the pressure on her before I decide whether or not to lay my vote on. Note that she has not posted (in this thread, I don't know about anywhere else with searching down) since Wednesday.

[Drippereth]

Yerk, VI = Villade Idiot, MPR = MehplusRawr

DGB (Assuming it's you, if Elli, question still stands), what's your take on the fact so many people are either defending xofelf or unwilling to vote her?

It's Elli. Lack of xofelf wagon makes me unhappy. No names now, but I dislike the people who just ignore her wagon more over the people who are vocally against it. So yah, I've been suprised over how hard it has been to build.