Scummers Mafia: Greatest Bash? (Game Over, Scum wins?)

[Diacria]

Spy, you've been Miller before?
I would have expected to just go SUPERTOWN and hope to be NK'ed instead of claiming.

[MonkeyMan576]

I don't really see the point in claiming miller in the RVS, it certainly raises suspicions...

FOS: SpyreX

And kudos to Starbuck for the Inspector Gadget reference...(has theme song stuck in my head)...

[Diacria]

FoS: Monkey

[MonkeyMan576]

Care for a reason?

[SensFan]

To be clear, if Spy really is a Miller, claiming was 100% correct.
He still needs to go. It's just way too convinient a claim for Scum to be able to dodge Cops all game long.

[MonkeyMan576]

To be clear, if Spy really is a Miller, claiming was 100% correct.
He still needs to go. It's just way too convinient a claim for Scum to be able to dodge Cops all game long.

Maybe it's just me, but this seems like a strange double position to take. Care to elaborate on how claiming Miller is "correct" if he's town but he still needs to be lynched? Do you just not believe him?

[SensFan]

It's just you.

[MonkeyMan576]

So you admit to taking a double position...and you don't seem very interested in backing up your statement.

Vote: SensFan

[Zang]

So you admit to taking a double position...and you don't seem very interested in backing up your statement.

Vote: SensFan

He said it was just you so he did not admit to taking a double position.

[MonkeyMan576]

So you admit to taking a double position...and you don't seem very interested in backing up your statement.

Vote: SensFan

He said it was just you so he did not admit to taking a double position.

Well, if he's not going to defend himself or elaborate then I'm going to assume that my read on him is correct.

[SensFan]

Let's say you got the role "You are a Cursed Townie. Every Night you are alive, 4 random Town people will die. You win with the Town."

a) Is it correct to claim ASAP?
b) Is it correct for the Town to lynch you ASAP?

Please try to think before posting in the future, and not jump to stupid conclusions.

[MonkeyMan576]

Let's say you got the role "You are a Cursed Townie. Every Night you are alive, 4 random Town people will die. You win with the Town."

a) Is it correct to claim ASAP?
b) Is it correct for the Town to lynch you ASAP?

Please try to think before posting in the future, and not jump to stupid conclusions.

I didn't reach any conclusion, stupid or otherwise.

So are you arguing that any town role which could potentially hurt the town should be lynched, say, Paranoid Gun Owner?

[Starbuck]

Starting with the insults early I see.


Anyways, hi Monkey, it's been awhile. How are you?

[ortolan]

Vote: Zazier

Zazier who would you kill n0 if you had a kill as town/scum?

[animorpherv1]

I'm going to interject into MM/Sens's convoersation to say. PGO should claim, but they don't need to get lynched right away.

[Diacria]

Care for a reason?

Why FoS, No vote.

[Diacria]

Disagree with Sens about Miller's claiming btw. i think they shouldn't but I don't want to debate this here/now.

[MonkeyMan576]

Care for a reason?

Why FoS, No vote.

I thought he was suspicious, not necessarily scum, as I said in the post.

[Diacria]

You don't vote for suspicious people?

[dramonic]

SensFan has requested replacement! First on the list for coming in is... Hasdgfas! PMing him now!

[MonkeyMan576]

You don't vote for suspicious people?

Sure, but if I voted for everyone I thought was suspicious I'd probably be accused of wagon hopping. Thus, FOS can be used tactically for a variety of good reasons.

[MonkeyMan576]

Starting with the insults early I see.


Anyways, hi Monkey, it's been awhile. How are you?

Pretty good, nice to have a chance to play with you again.

[Diacria]

You don't vote for suspicious people?

Sure, but if I voted for everyone I thought was suspicious I'd probably be accused of wagon hopping. Thus, FOS can be used tactically for a variety of good reasons.

Why do you care about what other people think?
And I can't see the difference in situation between where you FOSed Spy and VOTED Sens. Not to mention that was your first post (I think) in the game.

[MonkeyMan576]

You don't vote for suspicious people?

Sure, but if I voted for everyone I thought was suspicious I'd probably be accused of wagon hopping. Thus, FOS can be used tactically for a variety of good reasons.

Why do you care about what other people think?
And I can't see the difference in situation between where you FOSed Spy and VOTED Sens. Not to mention that was your first post (I think) in the game.

I don't see any rule where your first post has to be a vote rather than an FOS. Spy didn't rise to the level of a vote imho and Sens did(him asking for a replacement only reaffirms my suspicions).

I'm not overly concerned about what other people think, but voting for whoever you think is suspicious really isn't practical. Most of the time the best strategy is to vote for who you think is

most

suspicious.

[Diacria]

My guess of why Sens asked replacement is because of Star.

Were there any games you've played with D1 miller claims or have discussed miller strategy and stuff before?