Mini 990: YuGiOh! The Abridged Mafia - (OVER)

[Jarti]

If Seto ever died via NK I would have become town. And it looks like Rebecca could have become town too. So I don't think it's too crazy of 5 scum roles to be there, especially when 1 of the 3 mafia is just a traitor.

[charter]

When the Lyncher is targeting the scum Godfather it's really more like four . . .

Not at all. He's not scumhunting, he's hunting for that player. If he had claimed lyncher, we really have no choice but to lynch him immediately.

I don't think you guys realize the severity of five anti town roles. What if there was a day one mislynch, night one, two townies dead. Now it's 4 town, vs 3 scum, vs SK, vs lyncher. That might be technically winnable for town (though it would require some amazing doc/commuter luck), but in reality, the game would have been lost night one.

[charter]

Who reviewed this game?

[FakeGod]

When the Lyncher is targeting the scum Godfather it's really more like four . . .

Not at all. He's not scumhunting, he's hunting for that player. If he had claimed lyncher, we really have no choice but to lynch him immediately.

I don't think you guys realize the severity of five anti town roles. What if there was a day one mislynch, night one, two townies dead. Now it's 4 town, vs 3 scum, vs SK, vs lyncher. That might be technically winnable for town (though it would require some amazing doc/commuter luck), but in reality, the game would have been lost night one.

It does seem harsh once you put it out like that...... wow we were really lucky.

oooohh so that's why Jarti got off my case soon as I claimed Joey...

[FakeGod]

@mod: Would Serenity have gained any powers if I had died first?

[AlmasterGM]

I agree 100% with charter. This game was well modded in terms of smooth operation, but the setup seems incredibly unbalanced against the town. Town is EXTREMELY fortunate to have walked away with a win.

[AlmasterGM]

As a point to this, notice that despite lynching correctly

three times in a row

, had the Vig not shot correctly OR had the doctor missed his target on Night 3, the game would have been in mylo on Day 4. In addition to showing how swingy and dependent on power roles the game was, it also seems very unfair for the town to be in mylo despite three days of stellar performance.

[Chronopie]

My FakeGod is Joey crumbs got pretty blatant near my end, looking back on it. Good thing the scum NK'd me, rather than anyone else, giving the town a vig.

@Mod: I second FakeGod's Question. Would the Joey/Serenity VT -> Vig have occured if the scenario had been reversed?

[FakeGod]

I think it would be cool if Serenity became a cop after Joey dies.

Because doesn't Serenity start out blind, and later regains her sight thanks to Joey?

[Brandi]

Yes FG but this is based off of the ABRIDGED SERIES< this has nothing to do with the actual yugioh plotline! Even if it's mentioned in the abridged it's not really relevant to any jokes.

Oh and watch this if you haven't already FG! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HM9tyNkUAg (It'll make you appreciate your role more)

[Riceballtail]

Question to the mod: did MaxMouse knew that he would convert back to VT if doc saved him?

Standard part of a psychopath role, but I didn't explicitly state it in the role PM

Who reviewed this setup?

This setup was reviewed by Empking. And I was told it was too imbalanced to town, and needed to take more PRs out.

Also, no, Serenity didn't have anything cool if Joey died.

[MeMe]

last post