Mafia 1010 - Perpetual MyLo - Game Over

[nopointinactingup]

Wouldn't that be supposedly everyone's argument? That argument alone means nothing.

[xRECKONERx]

I know

I'll respond more appropriately in the AM

[Shadow Dancer]

Hmmm... I think our problem is that in a vanilla MyLo no one trusts any one else... So we've got quote some panic reactions... Readinf those as town is maybe a good idea to go with D1.

[Shadow Dancer]

Did'tn't read your whole argument. Too drunk

Stop playing mafia while drunk.

[Exilon]

Pro-tip: Reck is drunk lots of times. Sometimes, he posts on MS while being drunk. When that happens, you should either ignore it or take advantage of his weakness moment and get the truth out of him.

Damn, I missed his "drunk" period.
By the way, where's the other players?

[nopointinactingup]

And this game is supposed to test the town's ability to get every single town to agree on a lynch .. =.=

[Shadow Dancer]

Hmm... In vino veritas...

How ever, being drunk explains pretty well why he mist my points :p

[Shadow Dancer]

mist=missed, lol...

[DavidParker]

Sorry guys, didn't realize I had gotten a PM for this game, just got prodded! Doing a quick read-through now.

[DavidParker]

What do you guys think of a day 1 mass-roleclaim?

[Quoi]

@Reck: Wow, even more scum slip. From your action I can infer that you like bandwagoning.

What makes you say that?

[destructor]

I don't have much time to post and am very tired.

Please give me some feedback on these thoughts:
• Since we can only afford to No Lynch once, we should ALWAYS aim to lynch.
• We should ONLY consider No Lynching if we have mislynched twice and REALLY want another day to discuss the next lynch.
• Not doing the above significantly increases the chances of a loss due to a deadline.

In my fatigued state, that seems fairly comprehensive to me and I hope it can put the lynch/no lynch discussion to rest.

---

@ brianj

,

That being said: Let's stop this whole discussion now and start some real scumhunting! Yes: With real discussiun and real votes and a real lynch threat. And I mean that.

@ Exilon

, can you point out what Reckoner has done in this game that gives you a meta-based town read of him?

@ Everyone voting SD

, can you post a concise, dot point case on SD?

Also, can we try to keep banter/noise to a minimum? Especially battles of the ego? They're lame and clutter the thread.

What do you guys think of a day 1 mass-roleclaim?

Wtf?

[nopointinactingup]

What do you guys think of a day 1 mass-roleclaim?

What's the point?

@Reck: Wow, even more scum slip. From your action I can infer that you like bandwagoning.

What makes you say that?

Through the way he bandwagons SD to this

So SD's IIoA and mechanics-theorizing which doesn't count as scumhunting makes him town?

Also, bandwagoning is not a scumtell

, I don't know how far up your own ass your head is, but I suggest you pull it out as soon as possible.

[Shadow Dancer]

What do you guys think of a day 1 mass-roleclaim?

Wow, 12 people c,ai,img vanilla will help a lot, I guess @_@

[Shadow Dancer]

...claiming...

[destructor]

^ I find this kind of sarcastic wankery really irritating. If that's all someone has to post I think they're better off not posting at all.
PLEASE don't give this game more pages than it needs. <3

[nopointinactingup]

we're currently short of pages actually.

[Shadow Dancer]

I don't have much time to post and am very tired.

Please give me some feedback on these thoughts:
• Since we can only afford to No Lynch once, we should ALWAYS aim to lynch.
• We should ONLY consider No Lynching if we have mislynched twice and REALLY want another day to discuss the next lynch.
• Not doing the above significantly increases the chances of a loss due to a deadline.

In my fatigued state, that seems fairly comprehensive to me and I hope it can put the lynch/no lynch discussion to rest.

Bad plan... But we should not tollerate any lurking... Absens of Whoever is not officially V/LA should not be tollerated... Maybe we should intriduce a second deadline 48 hours befor the real one, after that town should only vote for the agreed on lynchee, no one else. Problem could be players being V/LA over the DL... Maybe we should also rather FoS than vote before the first deadline to make sure that mafia cannot quicklynch.
But you're definitely right, if there's gonna be a problem it's deinitely the danger of DL no lynchs rather than the danger of mafia waggon hopping in unison...

[Max]

Replacement List

KnightofZero
<Potentially Thief/DavidParker> (I've prodded them btw)
destructor (starting 29th July)

[DavidParker]

Claim:

Cop

[MagnaofIllusion]

Along with lots of other stuff, but on to serious matters: what's that have to do with Lowell offering a contentless vote?

My comment has nothing to do with your comment on Lowell and everything to do with you ‘gut’ suspicion of me.

@Magma: no power role so why not?

What good does your claim do? It’s at best a Null tell. Nobody is going to claim scum

Hmmm... I think our problem is that in a vanilla MyLo no one trusts any one else... So we've got quote some panic reactions... Readinf those as town is maybe a good idea to go with D1.

Convenient that we should just look at reactions under pressure Day 1 as Town tells when you are under pressure. Scum have just as much reason to react that was as Town.

What do you guys think of a day 1 mass-roleclaim?

Look at me I’m creating a VI persona knowing that Town can’t afford to policy lynch!!!

Claim:Cop

WIFOM alert – look at me acting all random and stupid. No scum would be so foolish as to claim an non-existent role.

[Shadow Dancer]

@DP: Stop it... Just plain stop it. Antitown behaviour won't help any one.

@MoI: Before I answer any further accusations of yours I'd like you to go back to the post you're citing and understand what I really meant.

[DavidParker]

Since when can town not afford to policy lynch??? Especially if they get ahead (ie 2 scum lynches : 0 town lynches) a policy lynch is fine.

[Shadow Dancer]

i) We're not ahead.

ii) scum lynch >>>> policy lynch in

any

situation.

iii) Asking for a replacement >>>> having yourself policy lynched, in any situation!

[DavidParker]

Don't worry, I'm done with my jokes. I just figured out this game had started and was sad to have missed out on the RVS mostly.. As things have got moving pretty quickly.