Open 253: Sea Container C9++ [GAME OVER]

[jmj3000]

Right now, there isnt, but you are trying to take a game I had replaced out of, and trying to build a case on it.

[Katsuki]

Unvote, Vote Sleepless

For reasons stated by mafuyu

[Sleepless Assassin]

The fact that you replaced out means nothing.

[jmj3000]

It means everything, because there is nothing in that game to go off of for me. I also lurked most of day 1 due to unforeseen circumstances. Therefore, there is not enough evidence to support your case. Why don't you try looking at games I actually played in if you are going to target me, and stop making a flawed case.

[mongoose]

this game is slow. people should post more

[andrew94]

people like youself?

[Alduskkel]

Sleepless Assassin is stretching and jmj3000 is overreacting.

Neither action/reaction strikes me as scummy. Stretching a case at this point in the game is just to fire up discussion, and overreacting just seems sensitive, not scummy.

[andrew94]

and ur just sitting on the fence and posting stuff to seem like a townie

[mongoose]

And you are just randomly trying to accuse people of things to see if you can start a wagon

[Sleepless Assassin]

Jmj, if I was metaing your play, you would have a point. Let me lay this out.

A) you were scum in harry potter mafia
B) because you were scum, you knew the scum team
C) in that game furcolow connected your two scumbuddies who were being treated as confirmed town
D) even if you replaced out, you admittedly "watched" the game
E) knowing the scumteam, furcolow being the only one to catch scum must make his scumdar look good to you
F) furcolow died night 0 in this game
G) it makes sense that you would kill furcolow
F) I have an actual reason to suspect you, so no reason to random vote anyone

[mongoose]

Honestly thats a really weak case. How do you know the scum didn't rand kill him? How do we know YOU didn't kill him, and planned this set up? I'm not really accusing you of anything, but I would just like to point out that is a really weak case.

[jmj3000]

If I was scum, I would have left Furc alive solely because of HP Mafia, because he had problems convincing the town to lynch his reads.

[Nexus]

Katsuki's gone from calling a2rudeboy obv. scum, and not elaborating on it, to hopping aboard the Sleepless wagon.

I'm sure her first vote was a RVS, but even so, I'm keeping an eye on her.

[Mafuyu]

Hey guys, scumbuddies arguing, making sillies of themselves to start the day?

Ey? Eeeeyyy?

[sirdanilot]

Votecount:
Katsuki (1): Nexus
Alduskkel (1): mothrax
yellowbounder (1): andrew94
jmj3000 (1): Sleepless Assassin
andrew94 (1): mongoose
mothrax (1): Alduskkel
Sleepless Assassin (2): Mafuyu, Katsuki

Not Voting (10): yellowbounder, jmj3000, a2rudeboy

[sirdanilot]

NOTE:

Yellowbounder has requested v/la for a short period due to computer problems.

[Mafuyu]

If I was scum, I would have left Furc alive solely because of HP Mafia, because he had problems convincing the town to lynch his reads.

Now now, 'would have' arguments lead to very dark places with bad mistakes.

[jmj3000]

If I was scum, I would have left Furc alive solely because of HP Mafia, because he had problems convincing the town to lynch his reads.

Now now, 'would have' arguments lead to very dark places with bad mistakes.

Its no worse than SA saying me watching a game when I knew the scum team makes me scum.

[sirdanilot]

a2rudeboy has been prodded.

[sirdanilot]

And the OP has been tidied up a bit.

[andrew94]

its wifom, and meta fails anyway

[Sleepless Assassin]

If I was scum, I would have left Furc alive solely because of HP Mafia, because he had problems convincing the town to lynch his reads.

This is true, but his reads were still accurate. And part of the reason he couldn't convince anyone is that the scum were being treated as confirmed town.

Now now, 'would have' arguments lead to very dark places with bad mistakes.

Not really. How would we catch scum if we were clueless about what they "would" do?

Its no worse than SA saying me watching a game when I knew the scum team makes me scum.

Misrep!

You're scum because a player who had very accurate reads against your scum team in another game is now dead. Not because you "knew the scum team" in another game. That could be said for most, if not all, of the players in this game.

its wifom, and meta fails anyway

*Sigh*

[mothrax]

SA, I don't see any validity in your argument... actually, it looks really WIFOMish. I'm not sure I like how quickly the last two players jumped on you though so I won't vote yet.

To all:
Massclaim, Yes or No and why?

[andrew94]

excuse me, first time playing c9+++
can someone explain what the first page of letters is about?

[jmj3000]

It is how the set-up is determined.