Multiple Personality Mafia (Game Over)

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Wow. So Elli has a No Lynch vote, with no reasoning behind it, in RVS stage.

Yeah, I'm not seeing how Elli's vote and Shado's "I wanna look like I'm doing something" vote are in any way equal.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

EBWOP: Note that Elli has 2 posts, the second of which came on this page.

[Parama]

Day 1 Vote Count #2

[5] ShadoWolf

- Exe, Yasuda, Lady Lambdadelta, Scott Brosius, Beefster

[3] Fate

- Llamarble, CupcakePanda, Lateralus22

[1] Lateralus22

- mongoose

[1] Lady Lambdadelta

- themanhimself

[1] TwoHeadedBoy

- ortiz1193

[1] CupcakePanda

- Rena

[1] Rena

- Mafuyu

[1] Beefster

- Fate

[1] Llamarble

- ShadoWolf

[1] Exe

- TwoHeadedBoy

[0] Mafuyu

-

[0] Yasuda

-

[0] Scott Brosius

-

[0] Tuniogen

-

[0] KitoMo

-

[0] mongoose

-

[0] themanhimself

-

[0] Robocopter87

-

[0] ortiz1193

-

[0] Ellibereth

-

[1] No Lynch - Ellibereth

Not Voting: KitoMo, Robocopter87, Tuniogen

With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch. Deadline for Day 1 is on 1/25/11 at 8:30 PM CST

[Ellibereth]

adundundundunnn
People who voted Shado
Exe, Yasu, LadyLam, Scott, Beef, 2head
I don't think I missed any of you??? BECAUSE THERE'S SCUM IN YOU.

AAA DAMN YOU PARA GETTING THERE FIRST.

[ShadoWolf]

Shado, yet another example of "why me?" You're asking why I'm voting you and not Elli. That's scummy as shit.

I didn't ask why you're voting me. I know why you're voting me. I still think it's odd that you haven't even questioned the other person who NLed, that's all.

And yes, I find it suspicious that Shado is answering questions directed to us.

I'm trying to defend myself. These questions are still relevant to me, even if they're not directed at me.

Wow. So Elli has a No Lynch vote, with no reasoning behind it, in RVS stage.

Yeah, I'm not seeing how Elli's vote and Shado's "I wanna look like I'm doing something" vote are in any way equal.

Because you didn't question Elli on their intentions, while I was intensely grilled for my vote.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Very well, at Shado's request.

Elli, what was your intent behind you NL vote?

[TwoHeadedBoy]

First off, I knew you'd use that, so I'll point out that I suggested that you be looked into as well. Not exactly "sheeping" now is it?

Just because you added a little extra to essentially an "I agree" post doesn't mean it's not sheeping. Logic fail.

Secondly, did you just accuse me of OMGUS? I'm sorry. This all started thanks to a comment in which I stated that you were a point of interest for me. Not the other way around.

I realize how it started, which I why I pointed out how drastically your views changed in a matter of a few posts. Just because you cast suspicion first doesn't mean you're not being OMGUS-y now. You're just using logical inconsistencies now.

Thirdly, my opinion changed. I no longer view you as a point of contention. You are full out trying to defend Shado. If he flips scum, you're a HIGHLY likely scum buddy. So yeah, if he flips scum, you're damn right I'm going to string you up.

I am doing no such thing. I'm not actively campaigning for him to not get lynched. He's still scummy, even if I think him probably frustrated town, there's just much bigger fish to fry. Misrepping. +1 scum.

FINALLY, you STILL haven't answered my FUCKING QUESTION. You gave me a bullshit answer of "content has nothing to do with this". LIES. Tell me EXACTLY how I'm playing off of him.

I like easy questions. You're getting your panties in a bunch after our Exe vote and defedning it. You're agreeing with nearly every point Exe makes. You're denying a CLEAR connection between the two of you (even using stupid reasons like, "well Exe doesn't post content so it can't be buddying.")

P-Edit 2: Ok, thanks TwoHeaded

You're welcome

~Fugi

[Ellibereth]

PARA, CAN YOU ADD WHO'S IN WHICH HYDRA TO THE FIRST POST PLZ? THANKS

Curious as to why Shado's being jumped on, but no one seemed to bat an eye at Elli. Yes, Shado's reasoning for it was crap (so I completely understand the wagon on him), but a vote for NL is still bad. I'd expect at least some comments on Elli, but no one has brought it up yet. Odd.

Take a guess why.
[quote="manhimself"
However, this is very true. As there's already enough pressure on ShadoWolf I'm going to VOTE: Elli until new information arises.[/quote]
heeheeheee

Elli, what was your intent behind you NL vote?

Nothing.
Actually that's a lie. I'll stick with it though.

Something calls for me.

[Exe]

adundundundunnn
People who voted Shado
Exe, Yasu, LadyLam, Scott, Beef, 2head
I don't think I missed any of you??? BECAUSE THERE'S SCUM IN YOU.

AAA DAMN YOU PARA GETTING THERE FIRST.

You scum bro?

[Tuniogen]

Tuniogen is confident, for the time being, in Exe being scum. Tuniogen could go into his ISO and do a PBPA, but Tuniogen feels such analysis would be moot. So, Tuniogen will simply quote his latest post (#108):

You scum bro?

QFS: Quoted For Scumness.

VOTE: Exe

[Beefster]

Also, directed at the bolded line: if you can find me one post that I have made that is a sheeping of Exe, I'll eat my (very decorated) hat.

Scum with Shadowolf. Lynch #2 found.

True enough

, but I think TwoHeadedBoy needs to be looked at aswell.

I hope you enjoy hats.

Also, I agree with my other head, that was a scummy response. Just because someone hasn't provided much content doesn't mean you can't play off them. Playing off someone has no relevance to content at all actually. So that's a null point. Then there's the fact that you say we're next if Shado flips scum. 1) planning lynches is scummy as shit. 2) this has a really OMGUS-y feel to it. You went from "should be looked into" to "you're next" in a matter of a few posts.

~Fugi

I wouldn't call it sheeping anyway. Agreement =/= Sheeping.
...
I don't recall seeing many posts from exe and Elli. I'll take a look at them because they seem to be the topics of the day.

[Scott Brosius]

@Shado: We're doing this because we like to sign our posts. We're a hydra, remember? Also, I don't like that you're attacking our tone without really addressing the accusation aside from (basically) a "nope".

Curious as to why Shado's being jumped on, but no one seemed to bat an eye at Elli. Yes, Shado's reasoning for it was crap (so I completely understand the wagon on him), but a vote for NL is still bad. I'd expect at least

some

comments on Elli, but no one has brought it up yet. Odd.

FoS: Scott

- your thoughts on Elli and Fate, please?

~Pie

My vote for Shado isn't because of his NL vote. If you actually read my vote, instead of probably just looking at the VC, you would see this. Voting for NL is completely null, its the 5th page. So your attempt to point out a discrepancy is baseless (at least in terms of my vote).

Fate and Elli haven't done anything interesting to me.

[Beefster]

PARA, CAN YOU ADD WHO'S IN WHICH HYDRA TO THE FIRST POST PLZ? THANKS

Curious as to why Shado's being jumped on, but no one seemed to bat an eye at Elli. Yes, Shado's reasoning for it was crap (so I completely understand the wagon on him), but a vote for NL is still bad. I'd expect at least some comments on Elli, but no one has brought it up yet. Odd.

Take a guess why.
[quote="manhimself"
However, this is very true. As there's already enough pressure on ShadoWolf I'm going to VOTE: Elli until new information arises.

heeheeheee

Elli, what was your intent behind you NL vote?

Nothing.
Actually that's a lie. I'll stick with it though.

Something calls for me.[/quote]
That something is activity. Stop posting fluff and get serious.

Or maybe that something is a vote. (I still think Shado is scum, though. He hasn't really made a breakthrough.)

unvote

VOTE: Ellibereth

[Beefster]

To be honest, I don't really think Exe is that bad. Cavalier, yes, but I don't see anything blatantly scummy in his ISO. It's too early to tell much about him other than his playstyle.

I don't like how THB has been pressing LLD about buddying with Exe.
On the other hand, I don't like LLD not giving her opinion of Elli.

[KitoMo]

UNVOTE: Fate, VOTE: Robocoptor87

Well. Things are happening. Its pretty intense. But I doubt that most of this matters to catching scum. But whatever, lets just continue as normal.

I don't much like this post. I'd like to see some legitimate content from you. Thoughts on Scott, themanhimself and the wagons thus far?

Fate, shape up. Two less than satisfactory votes in a row. I was expecting good things from you!

Tuniogen could go into his ISO and do a PBPA, but Tuniogen feels such analysis would be moot.

Why would it be moot? Why are you even telling us this?

- Kit.

[Robocopter87]

UNVOTE: Fate, VOTE: Robocoptor87

Well. Things are happening. Its pretty intense. But I doubt that most of this matters to catching scum. But whatever, lets just continue as normal.

I don't much like this post. I'd like to see some legitimate content from you. Thoughts on Scott, themanhimself and the wagons thus far?

- Kit.

Its all fluff. Just a big pile of Fluff. IMO, nothing important ever happens at the beginning of the game. People just act crazy and until theres some sort of foothold. Then once someone does something important, it rebounds and rebounds till a lynch hits.

So really, we are catching scum by not catching scum. How do you like them apples?

[Robocopter87]

Parama: Just out of curiousity, what happens after we run out of personalities?

The cycle starts over. Did you even look at your timeline?

[Lady Lambdadelta]

UNVOTE: Fate, VOTE: Robocoptor87

Well. Things are happening. Its pretty intense. But I doubt that most of this matters to catching scum. But whatever, lets just continue as normal.

I don't much like this post. I'd like to see some legitimate content from you. Thoughts on Scott, themanhimself and the wagons thus far?

- Kit.

Its all fluff. Just a big pile of Fluff. IMO, nothing important ever happens at the beginning of the game. People just act crazy and until theres some sort of foothold. Then once someone does something important, it rebounds and rebounds till a lynch hits.

So really,

we are catching scum by not catching scum. How do you like them apples?

No. This is bad.

You're coming up with reasons NOT to hunt scum?

[Robocopter87]

Did I say that? I don't recall coming up with reasons to not scumhunt.

[mongoose]

This seems like a really pathetic wagon. Whether or not we want to admit it, we all try to look townie even when we are on the town's side. At least, I do. Once you've been lynched a couple times trying to follow that idealist logic of "only scum tries to be townie" you realize its not true, whether its subconscious or not. Like it or not we are playing this to enjoy ourselves and no one wants to be lynched, whether or not it is for the good of the town. I used to be in the exact same position as shadowolf, so I can understand his predicament. I don't like this early wagon at all.

[Tuniogen]

Parama: Just out of curiousity, what happens after we run out of personalities?

They recycle. Notice how your MPM timeline is a continuum and doesn't stop at your fifth personality.

Tuniogen could go into his ISO and do a PBPA, but Tuniogen feels such analysis would be moot.

Why would it be moot? Why are you even telling us this?

- Kit.

Tuniogen thinks that it would be moot because simply put, there is nothing to analyse. His posts speak for themselves. Tuniogen tells you this to preempt requests for a case by players who are either too lazy, too stupid or trying too hard to look protown.

---

Tuniogen's thoughts on players so far:

Beefster:

Leaning about 45% town at this point. Dislike his constant theory debates, sudden vote of Ellibereth without any explanation whatsoever and reference to honesty in ISO post #6.

CupcakePanda:

Can not read yet. Get out of RVS and post game-related content.

Ellibereth:

Looking fairly in line with his town meta. 80% town.

Exe:

Already done.

Fate:

Stop posting in random alignments. Stop posting nonsense.

KitoMo:

Has voted 3 times in 2 posts. Choices of Scott and themanhimself seem arbitrary when questioning Robocopter87. Possible Fate coaching?

Lady Lambadelta:

Gah... she's pushing things that don't matter and won't listen to reason. Tuniogen loves her dearly but yeesh. She only seems to be focussing on those who disagree with her instead of providing broader, impartial views.

Lateralus22:

Post some content and stop being wishy-washy with your votes.

Llamarble:

Needs to post more.

Mafuyu:

See Llamarble.

mongoose:

See Mafuyu.

ortiz1193:

See mongoose.

Rena:

Undecided. Seems to be picking out the right things but not addressing them correctly. 55% town, Tuniogen would say if Tuniogen had to.

Robocopter87:

Not posting actual content and advocating flawed theorems.

Scott Brosius:

Seems fairly town to Tuniogen. Like his calling out of Shado and subsequent reasoning.

ShadoWolf:

Don't get Tuniogen started on this one. The NL vote, the arguing of indefensible positions, the lack of actual content beyond his defense. Tuniogen understands this playstyle and has seen it many times over and will give ShadoWolf the benefit of the doubt in this case. Take this as a warning, Shado. Straighten up and fly right.

themanhimself:

Neutral. Like his views on Shado (he's neither a newb nor a hydra, for the record) but dislike Ellibereth vote. Any vote can be cloaked in waiting for new information; Tuniogen would like to see his vote elsewhere or justified in its existing place.

[mongoose]

Eh, forgot to read 5th page, but I have to go to school now, so I'll comment on that later

[TwoHeadedBoy]

My vote for Shado isn't because of his NL vote. If you actually read my vote, instead of probably just looking at the VC, you would see this. Voting for NL is completely null, its the 5th page. So your attempt to point out a discrepancy is baseless (at least in terms of my vote).

Fate and Elli haven't done anything interesting to me.

I was just asking your thoughts. Thank you for the reasoning behind your vote, despite it being unprompted. Your response is noted for later.

Nothing interesting? Not at all? Hmm. What about opinions on Tuniogen, or Lamb? Or if you have nothing on them, anyone else is fine too.

@Robo: Ah, so you're one of the types of players that chastises RVS and sits around till the interesting part. Noted.

@mongoose: I agree, in both looking townie and the bad feeling about the wagon. There's at least one scum on board here for sure, IMO. Is there any one person that stands out to you (out of the 5 on Shado at the moment)?

@Tuniogen (I'm guessing Richard's head): >mfw you left us out of your list


Post something about Yasuda too, while you're at it. In addition, your post prior to your list felt strange. Almost detached. Just something of note.

~Pie

P.S. - I'd like everyone to read Tuniogen's read list again, specifically Lamb's and Shado's. To me, Lamb's entry seems like coaching and separation. Shado's entry seems like Tuni KNOWS Shado is town. Do not like.

[Tuniogen]

Later.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

Later.

Thanks for postwhoring, Rich.

~Pie