Bomb Mafia -- Game Over

[Katsuki]

Vote: Jack

[danakillsu]

Vote: katsuki

Blatant bw vote is blatant. Thought I needed time to post something worthwhile, but then realized that most of the material here was worthless.

[AurorusVox]

Vote: danakillsu

Katsuki is blatant but Fate isn't?

[Hoopla]

VOTE: danakillsu

[Hoopla]

VOTE: Jack

You dismiss the accusation of softclaiming bomb-related role info as ridiculous, then you actually claim bomb-related role info. I don't buy this.

Yeah, this isn't the sort of thing Jack just gets to ignore.

Jack?

[Jack]

I don't understand that "thing". What I suggested was reasonable (I really was in a previous game with the same kind of mechanic) and it was annoying to have it called role related information, even though I did have separate role related information.

[RedCoyote]

Vote Count 1.1

• Jack

  (5) (Benmage - StrangerCoug - themanhimself - Fate - Katsuki)
  
  
  Katuski
  (2) (hitogoroshi - danakillsu)
  
  
  danakillsu
  (2) (AurorusVox - Hoopla)
  
  
  Benmage
  (1) (Cogito Ergo Sum)
  
  
  Not Voting
  (4) (Nobody Special - SpyreX -

  AurorusVox

  -

  StrangerCoug

  -

  Fate

  -

  Katsuki

  -

  danakillsu

  - Jack -

  Hoopla

  -

  hitogoroshi

  - AntB -

  Cogito Ergo Sum

  -

  themanhimself

  -

  Benmage

  )
  
  
  
  Bomb possessed by: Jack

With fourteen alive, it takes eight to lynch.
Current Deadline: Feb. 9th, 2011 at 2:00 AM (CST)

[Fate]

Pass the bomb to dana.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Unvote, vote: Katsuki

[Nobody Special]

Vote: Jack

Evasive evasiveness is waaaay evasive.

[danakillsu]

Hahaha. I call out a bandwagoner, and people vote me because I didn't vote another. To prove that had a scum motivation, you'd have to prove that Fate is scum. And he just passed the bomb to me, so us being scumpals doesn't exactly make sense. So the votes on me are pretty obviously not well thought out. On the other hand, voting Fate for his bandwagon vote would not be a problem with me in any way. It's just that Katsuki's was even worse.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Katsuki is an easier target than Fate, dana.

[Hoopla]

Look at dana flail. Jack needs to bomb dana.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Are you bad at being scum, Hoopls?

[Hoopla]

Are you bad at being scum, Hoopls?

Hit and miss, really.

[AntB]

[Fate] just passed the bomb to me, so us being scumpals doesn't exactly make sense.

Uhm... yes it does. Could be a bus, could just be a random passing off. The fact you've used that as a defence raises an eyebrow.

[SpyreX]

Hahaha. I call out a bandwagoner, and people vote me because I didn't vote another. To prove that had a scum motivation, you'd have to prove that Fate is scum. And he just passed the bomb to me, so us being scumpals doesn't exactly make sense. So the votes on me are pretty obviously not well thought out. On the other hand, voting Fate for his bandwagon vote would not be a problem with me in any way. It's just that Katsuki's was even worse.

What?

(A)bort, (R)etry, (F)ail.

[AurorusVox]

Hahaha. I call out a bandwagoner, and people vote me because I didn't vote another. To prove that had a scum motivation, you'd have to prove that Fate is scum. And he just passed the bomb to me, so us being scumpals doesn't exactly make sense. So the votes on me are pretty obviously not well thought out. On the other hand, voting Fate for his bandwagon vote would not be a problem with me in any way. It's just that Katsuki's was even worse.

Your poor response makes me happy with my vote.

- You may not have wanted to confront Fate so early on because you're worried he'd turn on you and pile the pressure on.
- You may have already discussed passing bombs to each other as a viable distancing tactic to use early on. Come back and tell me "he passed me the bomb" when you've got no passes left, then I might listen.
- Was Katsuki's worse purely by virtue of the timing? If Katsuki's is worse, why would you happily vote Fate?

[StrangerCoug]

Still sick; just throwing in some quick thoughts.

danakillsu's WIFOM doesn't look good, but I'm a stronger supporter of the Jack wagon. Jack denied as ridiculous and then claimed bomb info. Lynch all liars.

[Katsuki]

Jack is not above taking risks either, ala [REDACTED]

[themanhimself]

DKU's post was not a town thing to say but for D1 I don't know how much more solid we're gonna get than the Jack wagon (hah! Get it?). Let's lynch him today, DKU tomorrow and win D3

[Benmage]

Hit.

I have a thought, help me through it because I know its not right.

Give X (being a scumbolina) said bomb. Force them to hold it.

IF they don't, lynch them.

This actually works fine, provided that a.) we all vote on who the scumbolina IS and b.) there is no one out of passes. There are two stable equilibrium points (voting for the bomb target, or a rapid pass chain

played to completion

) and an in-between that is badtimes jackson. People have shown an dislike to using the bomb as a targeted second lynch, and if we're gonna be having individually planned passing at ALL we want to play it out to the end.

And if the scummer knows when the bomb will blow and passes it at the last minute? Or passes it just before a hammer?

The pass/pass/pass/hold reduced all risk.

If we all vote for a bomb recipient, would you pass it to that person when your business is over?

I'd like this answered....where is jack anyways?

Moar Jack Votes....infact everyone not voting Jack state what you think of him.

NS is scum.

CES

, was that a random vote/pass on me?

[SpyreX]

It'll become rapidly apparent if the scum know when a bomb blows. Further, early game throwing a bomb right before a hammer is invitation for a death so I'm down with that clown.

I think this is waaay to high-risk / low-reward to be a scum maneuver and watching the salivation at it gives me the twitch something fierce.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

CES, was that a random vote/pass on me?

Why are you asking?

[Benmage]

CES, was that a random vote/pass on me?

Why are you asking?

..........................When you voted me and passed me the bomb...was there reasoning?