A Storm of Swords - Lay your swords down!

[Magua]

Magua, bro. Whatever happened to THIS? Seriously, every time I see a player "outsource" his daykill/nightkill/vote he flips scum. Its because the scum don't want to take responsibility for anything that could bite them in the end.

Er. I didn't say those words. Magna did. Magna who was scum and hasdgfas' partner. You may recall.

<_<
>_>

hasdgfas *didn't* outsource his kill. He vigged xtoxm when he could've easily vigged Raivann or Bunnylover or the like, and that's what really what cemented the town read in my eyes.

Which was wrong. But -- and I mean this in all honesty -- if played again I would react to that action the exact same way. You day vig scum D1 unprompted, I will treat you as town the entire game. Promise. Feel free to abuse this meta on me. It's high-risk, high-reward. Like I said in the Dead QT, if hasdgfas had ended up killed by BWB N1 we all would've had a good ol' laugh at his expense.

[Magua]

Also, in case anyone missed it, you must listen to Faraday's narration of Magua's lynch scene. It's in my sig. Be sure to tell Faraday what you think afterwards.

[Zdenek]

ZDENEK
Besides for your shit play, that Tywin Lannister claim was bollocks. In order for you to become bulletproof when Tyrion dies, the mods would therein confirm that Tyrion is, in fact, in the game and as town. Yet you argue that you're too dumb (or whatever) to realize that the only other Lannister that was ever a Hand of the King in the series is Tywin and Tyrion. Oh, that kind of rules it out. And you obviously didn't treat chesskid like confirmed town. Town would take the initiative. You had none. You flipped scum. No surprises

The only thing that I regret about the claim is not saying that it made me a 1 or 2 shot bulletproof; it was good enough that my lynch was governed later.

[Faraday]

Totally, since mod meta indicated I like limited BP townies.

[Faraday]

(and I do, still hate town watchers though..[/wifom])

[Andrius]

Magua, he wanted to outsource his kill. I know he didn't, but the notion started with the outsourcing.

Magua, next time we're scumbuddies, I'm day-vigging you D1. See what you say after that.

Zdenek, the number of bullets you can withstand is NOT the issue. The bulletproof thing was enough; but the fact you should have gotten a confirmed town guy read, and you didn't.
Failure to trust a confirmed town = FAILSCUM.

[Zdenek]

Zdenek, the number of bullets you can withstand is NOT the issue. The bulletproof thing was enough; but the fact you should have gotten a confirmed town guy read, and you didn't.
Failure to trust a confirmed town = FAILSCUM.

If CK3 had ever been in danger of being lynched, I'd see your point, but he wasn't.

[Magua]

Magua, he wanted to outsource his kill. I know he didn't, but the notion started with the outsourcing.

You quoted his *scumbuddy* and tried to use his scumbuddy's argument. Does that not, right there, tell you that you're stretching, maybe, a little bit?

Trust me. I get it. You suspected hasdgfas. You suspected him and you were right. Man, if only we'd listened to you. The game would've been ours. We were fools. But, alas, the moving hand, having writ, moves on.

Here, I made you a cookie:


Can you kindly stop it with the caps lawke rage now?

[popsofctown]

I stand somewhere between Magua and Andrius. I think that you have to hand anyone who kills a scum lots of town points, but as endgame starts coming you should start considering the possibility that he's scum. Especially since cow played very scummy all game.

[Gammagooey]

So yeah this was a fun game to watch.

Is the Fire emblem mafia game you guys talking about one of the earlier ones or a bunch of them in one or based on path of radiance/radiant dawn or what exactly? (i've only played most of the way through path of radiance)

[Locke Lamora]

I stand somewhere between Magua and Andrius. I think that you have to hand anyone who kills a scum lots of town points, but as endgame starts coming you should start considering the possibility that he's scum. Especially since cow played very scummy all game.

This. It's absolutely the logical play to consider someone who shoots scum to be confirmed town and, like Magua, I will do the same every time. If he's still alive 8 nights later in 3-man LyLo and there hasn't been any effort to find scum coming out of the slot, then it's time to reconsider that read. I can't say I would have done it myself, though. Hell, I was sure there was something wrong with the assumptions people were making about the setup and who was confirmed/near-confirmed town on D7, but Cow was not someone it occurred to me to look at. For that reason I was dubious about Pops and Shadow, but Cow was basically almost as confirmed town as Benmage. Speaks volumes about how effective the strategy was, in the end.

[Seacore]

Just a heads up, my mini-theme is coming up soon. Faraday, I expect a pre-in from you, since I'd love to have you in one of my games. Other pre-ins are also welcome.

[AdumbroDeus]

So I kept up with this thread for the most part (fell behind at the end unfortunately), but the game was ridiculously fun to watch, too bad it never got up to me in the replacements. C'est la vie.


Also, this should've been feature prominently in the endgame.






Yes, I wanted Stark to win, so sue me.


Pre-in me for A Feast for Crows mafia.

[Xtoxm]

Like. a. BOSS.

(sorry, Xtoxm)

No problem! Wasn't expecting to be killed that early lol.

Great work Cow. I can't believe that gambit worked as well as it did. I barely followed the game after I died, but I checked in recently and saw you were the only one on our team left and people had you dismissed as town. Was like, holy shit, he's gonna win it.

[hasdgfas]

Done and done.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Ah. Makes good sense.
Now I know what to do: can't convince them? Fakeclaim a Cop-Guilty.

I can't wait to see you implement this. I predict the following sequence of events -

1. Andy - Fake-claim scum Cop guilty on Player X.
2. Player X flips Town.
3. Andy flips Town when hung.

Your large wall of text contains lots of hindsight bias.

I'll be looking forward to your play going forward to see how this taste of 'success' (in catching scum and being NKed) affects your future play.

Remember you kept calling me scum via dayplay in [REDACTED], yet when I flipped Town that seemed to be convienently forgotten.

[Faraday]

I wonder if Magna will ever be town in one of my games or if random.org hates him.

[Seacore]

If Faraday and I have accomplished nothing else in life, we've created a game that lead to cow's new avatar.

And that satisfies me.

[ooba]

Great mod scenes - enjoyed reading them!

[Faraday]

DON'T BE SPOILING YOURSELF untill you're done with storm.

[diddin]

So yeah this was a fun game to watch.

Is the Fire emblem mafia game you guys talking about one of the earlier ones or a bunch of them in one or based on path of radiance/radiant dawn or what exactly? (i've only played most of the way through path of radiance)

The first one will be about FE1 (the one with Marth), but I'll be making a PoR game in the future if this goes well. I don't have enough modding experience to do Larges yet, so I'm saving the more popular ones for when I can.

[ooba]

DON'T BE SPOILING YOURSELF untill you're done with storm.

Finished storm!

[Faraday]

RED WEDDING?

[AdumbroDeus]

RED WEDDING?

Not in this game!

[Faraday]

AMEN. KING IN THE NORTH FOREVER.