Scummies 2011 Nominations

[Vi]

Nominate Ythill's Of Rogues and Curses for best flavor

due to the obvious research and integrated roles and flavor scenes.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 23&t=15748

Second

[VP Baltar]

Nominate Ythill's Of Rogues and Curses for best flavor

due to the obvious research and integrated roles and flavor scenes.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 23&t=15748

Second

Thirded

[gandalf5166]

4thd

[Haylen]

I think it's a bit late ._.

[Mariyta]

Nominate Ythill's Of Rogues and Curses for best flavor

due to the obvious research and integrated roles and flavor scenes.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 23&t=15748

Second

5thed

[Percy]

Nominate AlmasterGM's DEFCON Mafia 2.0

for

Most Enjoyable Game

I know I seconded the nom for DEFCON 1.0, but this game was even better than the first. I loved this game. It was a fantastic development of the 12-player mini, the moderation and flavourtext were superb, and the game was a lot of fun. The roles were informed by flavour, balanced, and while the setup offers everyone vig powers, the game wasn't broken, and we still got to nuke each other. AMERICA FUCK YEAH!

[Faraday]

2nd

although I guess this'll be for the 2011 thread.

[Zorblag]

Yeah, this should be split off to the 2011 scummies nominations soon enough. Troll no thought of that before today which just goes to show that Troll be slow. In any case,

Nominate The Rufflig for Best 3rd Party Performace for his work as Serial Killer in The Prisoner Mafia.

With just PGO powers to protect him, he weaved his way through a reasonably strong town and and a reasonably strong scum team (player wise) and came out smelling like roses. It was an impressive performance all around.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Sotty7]

Yeah, this should be split off to the 2011 scummies nominations soon enough. Troll no thought of that before today which just goes to show that Troll be slow. In any case,

Nominate The Rufflig for Best 3rd Party Performace for his work as Serial Killer in The Prisoner Mafia.

With just PGO powers to protect him, he weaved his way through a reasonably strong town and and a reasonably strong scum team (player wise) and came out smelling like roses. It was an impressive performance all around.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

2nd

[Ythill]

Woot! 2011 scummies, here we come!

(My way of saying thanks, obv.)

[RedCoyote]

2nd

although I guess this'll be for the 2011 thread.

3rd

.

[Chronopie]

I nominate Andrew94 For

Best New Player

, for his work as Vig in Multirole Mafia. He almost went Three for Three on the scum, except he was Roleblocked N3.

(Although this should be 2011 set I guess)

[Lateralus22]

2nd

His reads here were incredibly accurate to the point where the mod was wondering if he had accidentally sent him the setup, had the town listened to him we would have achieved our perfect win.

[DemonHybrid]

I won't condone that.

Lateralus, he lied about being a roleblocker in our C9++. I hope you haven't forgotten that.

[Lateralus22]

Mhm, it's debatable. Honestly if he starts using the shift key (I don't mean this in an insulting way btw) and starts posting a bit more reasoning he'll be a forced to be reckoned with if he keeps up with his accurate reads. I do agree that his play was pretty bad that time around though.

Edit: Actually, I take back my second and change the nomination to

Most Improved Player

[Ythan]

I agree, one of the defining traits of a great player is capitalization.

[Lateralus22]

It's helps with credibility.

[Fate]

I agree, one of the defining traits of a great player is capitalization.

I'd sig this if I sigged things.

[gandalf5166]

I

second

the second one, as Fate deserves the first.

[mothrax]

His reads in multirole were great, but the reason he didn't go 3/3 were because he pretty much all out claimed vig, without doing so, knowing there was an incredibly high possibility of a scum rb.

[Equinox]

2nd andrew94 for Most Improved Player

[gandalf5166]

His reads in multirole were great, but the reason he didn't go 3/3 were because he pretty much all out claimed vig, without doing so, knowing there was an incredibly high possibility of a scum rb.

And? he still caught all three scum.

[Ythan]

Moth I'm not seeing what your beef is if it worked.

[ThAdmiral]

I nominate Andrew94 For

Best New Player

, for his work as Vig in Multirole Mafia. He almost went Three for Three on the scum, except he was Roleblocked N3.

(Although this should be 2011 set I guess)

2nded

He really did win the game more or less single handedly.

[SaintKerrigan]

I could've sworn there was an award for best performance in a losing cause, but I don't see the category now...

For 2011, I

Request a "Best Performance in a Losing Cause"

category, and for that category,

Nominate MagnaofIllusion

for his performance in

The Return to Liten

. By the end of Day 4 in an 18-player game, he was the only scum player alive, but he successfully took the game to lylo and was

that

close to pulling out the victory. The person casting the deciding vote had a difficult time choosing Magna over the other player, and I think this speaks volumes with regards to Magna's play. (Not to mention that I had someone outside the game guess who the scum was in lylo, and Magna was the person's last choice.)

Edit: Copy-paste works again, so I added the link.