Newbie 1067 - Game over - Town Win!

[Mist7676]

First post of page 3!! Well at first i was kidding. He is going to die anyways so why not kill him ourselves. This makes mafia have to choose out of the newbies or SE's but thinking about longer that is the worst idea ive ever heard so UNVOTE: well we should start thinking straight and kill dem mafias.

[PeRrY-_-]

sounds like a plan

[inspiratieloos]

Nacho is too sure of not getting lynched at the moment because of his ICness, I say we go after one of the SEs for now.

Mist, why would you even suggest that a cop claims on D1? Either he'll die or he'll get roleblocked and we lose all his usefulness for the game. Unless we just happen to have setup 1 and just happen to lynch the roleblocker. What good is knowing the setup when your power roles are dead/useless? Especially since the mafia will already know the exact setup when the cop claims.
Then you say you wanted to kill him while you claim that you thought he would die N1 anyway setting us all up for WIFOM, you also say you have experience playing this game...

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Mist

[Mist7676]

That is a common startagy in EM just a suggestion

[PeRrY-_-]

also on EM it starts night >.>

[Mist7676]

U can make day start

[Nachomamma8]

I didnt want to keep my vote up because what if scum quickhammered before I took it down. Where would we be then without our IC. Even if the mafia attemps to kill you tonight, we might still have the doctor around here to protect you. From the other site (epicmafia.com) a common startagy in this kind of setup would be for cop to claim. Mafia don't know if there is a doctor and if the cop is roleblocked we know it is Setup 1 or 2. If cop dies than we know that there is no doctor and we are left with a bunch of townies. Do you guys agree on that situation of cop claiming? I know here it might seem like a stupid stratagy and will lead us nowhere but I'm going to run a test game on EM and see how it works out. BRB.

Are there any other newbie games where you've suggested this plan?
I'm also failing to see exactly what the benefit of your plan is. Cop claims D1, cop dies N1. Doctor maybe protects him, but then doctor is roleblocked. Scum could fakeclaim cop, draw doctor protections to themselves, plow through town.

^ a quick short post -
We would be automatically finding the mafia if nacho was hammered. And btw guys just because someones an IC or a SE doesn't grant them town so don't make assumptions.

Unfortunately, this doesn't always work. Townies quickhammer too...

Nacho:

I wouldn't say my two posts have been guarded, but they were very brief. My first post was on a Sunday morning at 8.46am here, before I rushed out and went to an all day event (UFC, for those wondering.) The second post was at 6.23am this morning, before I rushed off to work. Most of the posts seemed to occur in my overnight and waking up, I don't have too much to say. Even if I did, it'd be "quick, type this and hit send" and then run out the door.
Being an absolute noob doesn't exactly help, either.

Well, I see you have excuses... But do you have suspicions? Give me some content and I'll be perfectly happy to remove the vote. Otherwise, I'll do my best to make sure you die today.

other hand: nacho we need some content please.

Why ask me to provide more when you don't comment on what I've already provided?

[Mist7676]

I have never suggested this unless i must have forgot. I just thought of it now but if there is no cop and mafia claims than we will find out if doc dies and cop doesnt. Or if reports are faked. If real cop claims and is docced by doctor. Mafia would have to get lucky to kill cop and roleblock doc. Its not that bad of a plan and sometimes works. As i said cop doesnt have to claim if they dont want to

[dysorder]

Well, I see you have excuses... But do you have suspicions? Give me some content and I'll be perfectly happy to remove the vote. Otherwise, I'll do my best to make sure you die today.

Content... Let's see.

Suspicions, the only real suspicion I have is Mist for raising a cop claim and while not quite suggesting it, but hinting that it could "work" here. I honestly don't think it would be a good idea at all, even if it does have its use over on EM. It seems a little odd, is all.

^ a quick short post -
We would be automatically finding the mafia if nacho was hammered. And btw guys just because someones an IC or a SE doesn't grant them town so don't make assumptions.

This is about as much as Escho has posted. For a couple of pages in, this doesn't seem like the work of a SE player. Shouldn't an SE know more about what sort of posting requirements are needed in this game? The statement that he made about IC and SE could also be an attempt to throw more heat onto Nacho, and the other SE, without entangling him.

[Mist7676]

Guys it was just a suggestion. We dont need to get all excited over it. Just a simple suggestion. All u have to do is say no and we r over it.

[PeRrY-_-]

U can make day start

most games i play are night start, but i see the point. i still wouldnt risk cop reveal day one

[Mist7676]

There is a mechanic that causes day start skips n1 goes straight to d1. Hearing all these disagremmences means that we rnt letting cop claim today.

[Nachomamma8]

Mod, prod Les Guilesser please?

Unvote, Vote: Hazard With a Glove

Unvoting as promised. Your post does have some good thoughts in it, dysorder; you just need to push the line of thinking a little farther for each and put a vote down. Which one is scummier to you?

My vote for Hazard is serving as a little incentive for him to answer my question, since we haven't head from him in a little while.

As of now, I have slight scum reads on Hazard and Les Guilesser, a decent town read on mist and inspirateloos, and a slight town read on dysorder.

[Escho]

@mod
V/LA for 2 days.

[Hazard with a Glove]

FYI, this isn't all that weird for Mist. I'm pretty sure he's town.

Sorry, I wasn't paying much attention to this game because of the theme game I was playing, but I died, so you've got my full attention.

Now, Nacho, which question are you referring to? The only thing I see is asking me what I have to loose from helping you pressure Dysorder, even though you no longer believe to be needing it, and whom I never did.

[Les Guilelesser]

\unvote: no one

\vote: dysorder

The reason I have voted for dysoder is because I want to protect myself against the line of conduct wrongly made by him.

[dysorder]

What line of conduct is that, Les? Is it that I randomly voted for you on the first page, during RVS?

[Les Guilelesser]

Is it that I randomly voted for you on the first page, during RVS?

Yes, "the first page" is the key word here, buddy

[jasonT1981]

Day 1 Vote Count 2

Nachomamma8 1 - Escho
Escho 1 - , Kcdaspot
Hazard with a glove 1 - Nachomamma8
Les Guilelesser 1 -dysorder
Mist 1 - inspiratieloos
Dysorder 1 - Les Guilelesser

Not voting

Mist
PeRrY
Hazard with a Glove

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[inspiratieloos]

I don't really see anything that suspicious right now, Les Guilelessers vote is strange, but more in a VI than scummy way.
Escho and Hazard have been too quiet, but Hazard promises to be better and Escho is away for now.

And UNVOTE: Mist for now, I'm not sure who to vote at the moment.

[Hazard with a Glove]

I don't understand what you are doing. Could you explain?

[Hazard with a Glove]

EBWOP: Aimed at Les Guilelesser

[dysorder]

Guilelesser's statements are a bit... strange, but okay.

I'll UNVOTE: and leave it at that. Escho's L/VA may explain his silence for the first couple of pages, so I'm a little lost as to where to look now. I still think Mist was acting a little strange, but nothing really concrete to base a serious vote on.

I'm hoping Perry can come through with a decent post like he's been claiming to be putting up, without actually saying much else...

[Kcdaspot]

UNVOTE:

I'm saving reads until page 5.

I'd like Les to post more, at least answer my questions from the start of the game...

Nacho... how do you feel about Perry? I'm getting slightly bad vibes there.

[PeRrY-_-]

well right now ive got nothing to really say. not trying to lurk but im new here trying to learn the ropes here, much much different than EM or in person. if you can squeeze a paragraph out of me its a miracle ^.^