Cthulhu Speed Mafia (Finished)

[TwoHeadedBoy]

EBWOP: tars, how the fuck did you think we actually got a vigshot? Did you even read that post?

FoS tars

PEdit: god dammit bob

[Ant_to_the_max]

After we lynch him THB and Ant are his scum buddies.

Nope. Not going to be that easy. And I am not allowed to sheep?

Texted Fugi. We both think the daykill looks most like a scum-daykill-WIFOM-frame against C-Worl. No one that's town would shoot that early, let alone someone who's made two posts. And I'm assuming daykill unless we find out there's some unorthodox role or odd mechanic that caused this.
~Pie

How would that be framing C-Worl? Besides the vote he had on C-Worl, there was no other interaction.
As for the death, my first thought was Rule 19...but w/e

[TwoHeadedBoy]

Modkills would be more public and usually result in the player being made a neutral survivor. And possibly end the day.

Think about it. Wagon builds on C-Worl. Someone who made one post, voted C-Worl and went v/la is shot. While it's possible it was a scumbuddy (or maybe CW himself) trying to break the wagon up... my gut says the kill is an attempt at framing him and CW is actually town.

Although yeah, it woulda made more sense to kill someone pushing the CW lynch heavier... I'm not as sure of myself after thinking about that, but I don't mind our vote on Cobbler now anyways.

If anyone claims that shot btw, I want them lynched. There's no way a townie would have made that shot.

~Pie

[C-Worl]

We start with 17 and on D1 we're down to 12 already. All 5 that are dead are town which means on D1 we're already getting close to Lylo. We can't afford mislynches and a lynch of me would be a mislynch. I am town. Notice that when I called Penguin scum he never actually denied that statement.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

*reads #103*
...

...don't get me wrong, C-Worl's not exactly the towniest person here either, but something's definitely up about that kill.

~Pie

[C-Worl]

*reads #103*
...

...don't get me wrong, C-Worl's not exactly the towniest person here either, but something's definitely up about that kill.

~Pie

To quote Mastin: "I am Townie McTownsperson from Townville USA"

[TwoHeadedBoy]

To quote Mastin: "I am Townie McTownsperson from Townville USA"

Mastin also said if Pine was scum he'd quit playing games under Mastin and quit posting in MD.

And you remember how that turned out.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

EBWOP

~Pie

[C-Worl]

He's playin under mastin2 now so he technically told the truth

[Ant_to_the_max]

Vote Count 4

2. vezokpiraka
3. bobsnox (1) - Amrun
4. Ant_to_the_max (1) - tarsonisocelot
5. RaudhrGarm
6. Nachomamma8
7. Twistedspoon (2) - Ant_to_the_max, Energetic Penguin,
9. Cobblerfone
10. C-Worl (2) - RaudhrGarm, TwoHeadedBoy
12. TwoHeadedBoy (1) - Cobblerfone
13. tarsonisocelot
14. Stels
15. Amrun
16. Energetic Penguin (6) - Twistedspoon, bobsnox, Nachomamma8, Stels, vezokpiraka, C-Worl

Not Voting:

13 Alive, 7 to Lynch

Someone with 2 votes on them (one being a guy that is V/LA) compared to a guy at L-1
If anything, I see it more of a revealer of Energetic Penguin lynch than a C-Worl lynch

BUT!!!! WITH 12 ALIVE, YOU ONLY NEED 6 TO LYNCH! AKA 6 PEOPLE ON PENGUIN, SCUM TAKE A DAY SHOT TO CHANGE THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A LYNCH AND THEY GET A QUICK MISS-LYNCH D1 ON PAGE 5

IMO proof that Penguin is town.

[C-Worl]

Actually with 12 alive you still need 7 to lynch. So it could have been an obvious method of derailing the Penguin lynch.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Hmm, not specifically stated in the rules.

@Mod: How many does it take to lynch now?

But like I said, possible derailer, but I just had my lightbulb and I got all excited >__>

[tarsonisocelot]

EBWOP: tars, how the fuck did you think we actually got a vigshot? Did you even read that post?

FoS tars

PEdit: god dammit bob

Apologies, it was more of a "THB asks repeatedly for vigshots+someone falls over dead->did THB get his wish/wtf???" than anything else. I didn't put enough thought into it.
Haven't played with day-killing scum before, but on reflection I don't think there's a town motive for shooting someone as inactive as them at this point when there are other people who look vaguely scummy around.

Sleep is a good thing.

PEdit: The vote count also reset so people would have a chance to realise and not quicklynch.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

I'm gone for like 6 hours and this happens? Crazysauce.

C-Worl, I doubt we're anywhere near lylo. There's no way 5 kills can happen before a lynch and allow for lylo soon. The game was said to be a bit bastardly, sure, but not unfair. My guess is that's probably the only time this many kills will happen in such succession and we have very few scum, maybe 2. Just a theory though. (Need to brush up on my Lovecraft to see if I can get anything from flavor)

As Pie said, we think the kill was a frame on C-Worl, and his reactions seem genuine enough (especially the one about anticipated lylo) that my scumdar isn't beeping quite so much on him. I was caught a bit off guard by his mindless sheep and stupid reasons, but I mix up newb tells and scum tells often. Cobbler is by far my strongest scumread and he needs the noose now.

~Fugi

P.S. if scum shot, thanks for killing random scummy lurker of all people. If town shot, coulda been worse, but you really should claim that you shot unless you have more and are protecting yourself.

[vezokpiraka]

C-Worl is town.

He likes Fate and he is trying to imitate him.

vote penguin

I bet Penguin had the shot

[Empking]

Vote Count 5

2. vezokpiraka
3. bobsnox
4. Ant_to_the_max
6. Nachomamma8
7. Twistedspoon
9. Cobblerfone (1) - TwoHeadedBoy
10. C-Worl (3) - Ant_to_the_max, Energetic Penguin, tarsonisocelot
12. TwoHeadedBoy
13. tarsonisocelot
14. Stels
15. Amrun
16. Energetic Penguin (3) - C-Worl, bobsnox, vezokpiraka

Not Voting: Nachomamma8, Twistedspoon, Cobblerfone, Amrun, Stels

12 alive, 7 alive.

[Stels]

Personally I don't see how EP is scummy, so IMO my other head is crazy.

That said.

Vote: C-Worl

GJ THB. You did it! You gave us an even lesser advantage!

I don't get it.

~Pie

@People voting for me: What's the reasoning?

You're scum.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: C-Worl

Can we please have mutilvig shots?

~Fugi

This remind you of anything?

[Stels]

Vote Count 4

2. vezokpiraka
3. bobsnox (1) - Amrun
4. Ant_to_the_max (1) - tarsonisocelot
5. RaudhrGarm
6. Nachomamma8
7. Twistedspoon (2) - Ant_to_the_max, Energetic Penguin,
9. Cobblerfone
10. C-Worl (2) - RaudhrGarm, TwoHeadedBoy
12. TwoHeadedBoy (1) - Cobblerfone
13. tarsonisocelot
14. Stels
15. Amrun
16. Energetic Penguin (6) - Twistedspoon, bobsnox, Nachomamma8, Stels, vezokpiraka, C-Worl

Not Voting:

13 Alive, 7 to Lynch

Someone with 2 votes on them (one being a guy that is V/LA) compared to a guy at L-1
If anything, I see it more of a revealer of Energetic Penguin lynch than a C-Worl lynch

BUT!!!! WITH 12 ALIVE, YOU ONLY NEED 6 TO LYNCH! AKA 6 PEOPLE ON PENGUIN, SCUM TAKE A DAY SHOT TO CHANGE THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A LYNCH AND THEY GET A QUICK MISS-LYNCH D1 ON PAGE 5

IMO proof that Penguin is town.

Not to offend you, but right now, you're making a fool of yourself. How in the world did you get 6 to lynch? It's 7. the requirement for the lynch hasn't changed. It needs to be 1/2 + 1. Invalid argument.

[Twistedspoon]

12 alive, 7 alive.

because that makes sense :/

anyways, catching up it appears my RVS vote has vanished

[Stels]

Because I didn't ask Empking to fix the vote count >_>

[TwoHeadedBoy]

Personally I don't see how EP is scummy, so IMO my other head is crazy.

That said.

Vote: C-Worl

GJ THB. You did it! You gave us an even lesser advantage!

I don't get it.

~Pie

@People voting for me: What's the reasoning?

You're scum.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: C-Worl

Can we please have mutilvig shots?

~Fugi

This remind you of anything?

Nope. But I guess you're having problems reading the part where Pie said we didn't have vig shots.

We'll still gladly take a few though.

~Fugi

[Cobblerfone]

Well, THB has indeed gotten better at organizing their hydra, and my vote's fallen off, might as well roll with it.

Well that kill seemed pretty random. I think THB's right, it doesn't match up with a vig's kill. They're only a couple ways I think it could be a vig, and I think both are unnecessarily guessy. I would almost think SK because of the randomness, but you have to work with the simplest solution so, I'll just assume a mafia-day-kill.

VOTE: Twistedspoon

He didn't seem supsicious enough to get my vote off of THB, but since I don't think THB is worth the lynch anymore, he's currently my best bet. I mean, guessing at the set-up on page 1? Plus, I don't like the Penguin-wagon. Seriously, how did that happen again? Maybe it's cause I'm a newb but band-wagoning because of some guy? Weird.

[bobsnox]

I'm here reading everything. I'm still good with my vote.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

Well, THB has indeed gotten better at organizing their hydra, and my vote's fallen off, might as well roll with it.

This is our 3rd game as a hydra, and Pie and I have been friends for years before starting this hydra. We were never disorganized this game, let alone disorganized then gotten together. That was an invalid reason then and now you're backing off saying something happened that never did.

Well that kill seemed pretty random. I think THB's right, it doesn't match up with a vig's kill. They're only a couple ways I think it could be a vig, and I think both are unnecessarily guessy. I would almost think SK because of the randomness, but you have to work with the simplest solution so, I'll just assume a mafia-day-kill.

VOTE: Twistedspoon

He didn't seem supsicious enough to get my vote off of THB, but since I don't think THB is worth the lynch anymore, he's currently my best bet. I mean, guessing at the set-up on page 1? Plus, I don't like the Penguin-wagon. Seriously, how did that happen again? Maybe it's cause I'm a newb but band-wagoning because of some guy? Weird.

The rest of that is super appeal-y to us. "THB is right," "THB isn't worth the lynch," and I don't like it even slightly. I'm really trying to look at this without some form or bias or not tunneling-ly, but I can't see this post as having any town motivation unless you truly believed what you were saying, and the instant change of heart and constant mention of us is not allowing me to believe this is genuine. TS vote doesn't seem genuine either.

Our Cobbler vote is staying until this scum dies.

~Fugi

[Cobblerfone]

This is our 3rd game as a hydra, and Pie and I have been friends for years before starting this hydra. We were never disorganized this game, let alone disorganized then gotten together. That was an invalid reason then and now you're backing off saying something happened that never did.

I think it was the formatting and the arguing in your earlier posts. It doesn't help that I didn't realize that the timestamps in your posts were the time of edits instead of from a private chat that you copy and pasted in. You see, I thought you guys chatted and then drafted your posts together, once I figured out they were edits it became easier to understand what was going on. They are edit-times right? (You were correct when you guessed I'd never played with a hydra. In fact, this is my second game on this site and my third total as a player.)


As for my vote, it really is more of a placeholder with only slight suspicion, but I don't think I have enough to go off of for anyone, which is odd, considering we're at page 5. (Maybe it's cause it's a large game?) I guess that's why people band-wagoned penguin. There's not a lot to go off of and he's one of the few that's even mildly suspicious.

Also, I love that I've only been a member a little over a week, and I'm already quoted in someone's sig.