Cthulhu Speed Mafia (Finished)

[TwoHeadedBoy]

All Caps command =/= argument

[17:19:06] <Guppy> can't decide if C-Worl is trying too hard as town or is trying to mudsling as scum
[17:19:41] <InflatablePie> is it bad that I immediately went to look at the TWBB thread <_<
[17:19:48] <Guppy> yes

Guppy is Fugitive.

~Fugi

[TwoHeadedBoy]

He pulled this shit in our bloodshed game and ended up being scum.

Read this entire page (or skim) and then look at the OP and see what we flip.

We argue as both town and scum. Get used to it.

@Antz: If you have a null-read on bob, why are you defending him?

looking at the dead list we must have a real mafioso threat considering a watcher, a cop and 2 masons are already dead.

I'm trying to think of a connection between the roles that could determine the mechanic. :/
Any ideas?

This is a bad post.

~Pie

[TwoHeadedBoy]

EBWOP: And yeah, that's not arguing. We'll show you arguing. Eventually.

~Pie

[Empking]

Vote Count 2

2. vezokpiraka
3. bobsnox (1) - vezokpiraka
4. Ant_to_the_max
5. RaudhrGarm
6. Nachomamma8 (1) - Cobblerfone
7. Twistedspoon (1) - Ant_to_the_max
9. Cobblerfone (1) - TwoHeadedBoy
10. C-Worl (1) - RaudhrGarm
12. TwoHeadedBoy
13. tarsonisocelot
14. Stels (1) - bobsnox
15. Amrun
16. Energetic Penguin

Not Voting: Nachomamma8, Twistedspoon, tarsonisocelot, Stels, Amrun, Energetic Penguin, C-Worl

[Ant_to_the_max]

Bad argument is bad argument.
But basically what I said would be bad is what TS said and you pointed out.

@C-Worl: how many games have you played with THB?

[RaudhrGarm]

V/LA to Saturday, 23rd of April.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

Bad argument is bad argument.
But basically what I said would be bad is what TS said and you pointed out.

Erm. What?

~Pie

[Twistedspoon]

VOTE: empking

Just testing.

Unvote; Vote: Empking

^ Cuz I can.

great, now we have a wagon oing that'll never get us out of RVS

[Twistedspoon]

VOTE: Penguin
forgot to use vote tags last time

[Twistedspoon]

VOTE: empking

Just testing.

Unvote; Vote: Empking

^ Cuz I can.

great, now we have a wagon oing that'll never get us out of RVS

just to expand on this point, remember that deadlines are only 1 week long

thus we need to leave RVS as soon as possible, and mod voting isn't going to do that

[TwoHeadedBoy]

thus we need to leave RVS as soon as possible, and mod voting isn't going to do that

I have a new RVS policy of voting those players with the best or most interesting usernames

VOTE: Penguin

...


~Pie

[Energetic Penguin]

I KNOW!

I was scared about posting first because I thought I might die if I did so >_>

So do we skip the RVS in this game and just start arguing right away?

What do you mean? Like random game mechanic that you die as first poster? Do you really need to ask that question?

You seem nervous from this post and scum are generally the only people who need feel that way.

Fos: Ant

I KNOW!

I was scared about posting first because I thought I might die if I did so >_>

So do we skip the RVS in this game and just start arguing right away?

lol people always suspect me day one until they get used to my style, so I figured I'd have at it.

I don't know how you start arguing if no one has said anything, so I don't know about skipping RVS. For now I'm definitely going to

VOTE: Stels

to see what reaction I get

I find it odd that you would need to tack on that rider of "to see what reaction I get". Isn't that the commonly accepted reasoning behind random votes?

just got the PM

Energetic penguin

I have a new RVS policy of voting those players with the best or most interesting usernames

anyways, serious now

looking at the dead list we must have a real mafioso threat considering a watcher, a cop and 2 masons are already dead.

I'm trying to think of a connection between the roles that could determine the mechanic. :/
Any ideas?

This post is full of worthless content and your others talk about leaving the RVS but do nothing to actually make it happen.

VOTE: Twistedspoon

[Cobblerfone]

Oi, I'm already sick of THB. And your gimmick, as I called it, is being two people in real life. It's annoying, because:

A. It's hard to fight two people with two different opinions.

B. You disagree with each other so no one will be able to get a proper read on you.

These things lead to confusion, and I think we can all agree that confusion let's scum thrive. So until I find someone that actually looks extremely scummy or you prove to be less of a hassle than I suspect you will be, I say THB is the best place for my vote.

UNVOTE: Nachomamma8

VOTE: TwoHeadedBoy

[C-Worl]

Vote Count 2

2. vezokpiraka
3. bobsnox (1) - vezokpiraka
4. Ant_to_the_max
5. RaudhrGarm
6. Nachomamma8 (1) - Cobblerfone
7. Twistedspoon (1) - Ant_to_the_max
9. Cobblerfone (1) - TwoHeadedBoy
10. C-Worl (1) - RaudhrGarm
12. TwoHeadedBoy
13. tarsonisocelot
14. Stels (1) - bobsnox
15. Amrun
16. Energetic Penguin

Not Voting: Nachomamma8, Twistedspoon, tarsonisocelot, Stels, Amrun, Energetic Penguin, C-Worl

The fuck?

[tarsonisocelot]

Just got the message.
That's a lot of N0 deaths, more than I would expect from just scum or scum + SK. Could some of them have targeted a Paranoid Gun Owner?

No reads yet so VOTE: Ant_to_the_max.
Was there any particular reason that you thought posting first was dangerous? If yes, are there any other things we should be wary of?

[tarsonisocelot]

PEdit: POST IN THE DAMN HYDRA

I don't think that that really counts as an argument, seems like more of a facepalm.

[bobsnox]

Just got the message.
That's a lot of N0 deaths, more than I would expect from just scum or scum + SK. Could some of them have targeted a Paranoid Gun Owner?

No reads yet so VOTE: Ant_to_the_max.
Was there any particular reason that you thought posting first was dangerous? If yes, are there any other things we should be wary of?

I'm always suspicious of the first person to post/question the previous night's events, so I'm wary of posting first. That's probably what ATTM meant.

Not liking the EPenguin nitpicking. I see scum do that all the time early in the game. It's actually the reason I was voting Stels (seen it from Stels before).

UNVOTE: Stels

VOTE: Energetic Penguin

[TwoHeadedBoy]

I'm always suspicious of the first person to post/question the previous night's events, so I'm wary of posting first.

O_O

4 deaths on Night Zero?

...

Not liking the EPenguin nitpicking. I see scum do that all the time early in the game.

It's actually the reason I was voting Stels

(seen it from Stels before)

VOTE: Stels

to see what reaction I get

WHY IS EVERYONE SO SCUMMY THIS EARLY ON

I CAN ONLY VOTE FOR ONE OF YOU

@MOD: CAN I BE GRANTED DOUBLEVOTING POWERS PLZ

---

36 is :goodposting:.

---

Oi, I'm already sick of THB. And your gimmick, as I called it, is being two people in real life. It's annoying, because:

A. It's hard to fight two people with two different opinions.

I don't see how. Let's say I think someone is town and Fugi thinks the same person is scum. It's possible to find both of us scummy, be it my reasoning for the townread or his for the scumread, or both.

B. You disagree with each other so no one will be able to get a proper read on you.

How do you know this? It's entirely possible to get reads on a hydra that has different opinions... have you played with a hydra before?

These things lead to confusion, and I think we can all agree that confusion lets scum thrive.

Just because 1 (your points A and B) leads to 2 (confusion) leads to 3 (scum thriving) doesn't mean A always leads to C. There's a fallacy for this, I think.

Anyhow, you're basically voting us because we're a hydra. Nice to know.

I really wish I had multiple votes. Or bullets.

@MOD: CAN I GET SOME VIG SHOTS PLZ

~Pie

[bobsnox]

THB - I was explaining this and why I can understand ATTM's comments

lol people always suspect me day one until they get used to my style, so I figured I'd have at it.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Nah.
Part about posting first was more of a joke. Heads were really rolling with 4 deaths and like Empking said, we are most certainly doomed at this rate

More stuff when I get home

[Amrun]

VOTE: bobsnox

Highest concentration of scummy posts so far.

I will be scarce this weekend; I can post to react to things, but don't expect in-depth analysis.

[bobsnox]

I won't be on for most of tomorrow but I'll be around tomorrow night. Please do not speed lynch me or anything crazy <_< call me paranoid but some people took something I said out of context recently in another game and I was toast within a few hours.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

Edit to an earlier post:

Just because 1 (your points A and B) leads to 2 (confusion) leads to 3 (scum thriving) doesn't mean 1 always leads to 3. There's a fallacy for this, I think.

I originally wrote ABC instead of 123 but changed it after I realized you had A and B as your points. Didn't wanna confuse.

THB - I was explaining this and why I can understand ATTM's comments

lol people always suspect me day one until they get used to my style, so I figured I'd have at it.

Again, your meta is not an excuse for scummy play. Why are you defending Attm anyways?

Unvote, Vote: bob

BTW, I like how Cobbler's vote on us is a countervote - didn't point it out earlier because I forgot my other head moved our vote. Noted for later though. Not sure if I find Cobbler scummy or not, but I've certainly got my eye on him.

Please do not speed lynch me or anything crazy

*looks at game name*

~Pie

P.S. - I'll probably try and slow down on the posting a bit until Fugi catches up and addresses some things.

[bobsnox]

To be clear, my "scummy play" has been pointing out that I was wary of posting first because I always suspect the person who posts first?

If so, that's crap. But it's Day One so I expect crap I guess.

[bobsnox]

I'm not defending ATTM. It was a natural extension of the first couple posts.

Whatever guys - all I ask is that you don't lynch me before I get back on tomorrow night. You will not be lynching me day one. I just want to see who else piles on if my bandwagon picks up momentum.

THB - what is your (plural <_<) opinion of Energetic Penguin?