Cthulhu Speed Mafia (Finished)

[Amrun]

How the hell is this game over?

[Ant_to_the_max]

But really though...
What is the policy on how to deal with them?

[quadz08]

..... *facepalm*

Hooooo boy. This game was... odd.

[Amrun]

To deal with who, supersaints?

idk, but if TS ever claims one again, he gets lynched immediately.

[Ant_to_the_max]

If TS ever claims anything, he gets lynched immediately >_>

And yes, Supersaints.

[Cobblerfone]

Congrats to TwoHeadedBoy for finding me on page 1. That was fun.

[Cobblerfone]

Also, sorry for hogging all the day kills, guys. The first kill was situational. I didn't want to go a day without a kill. And I thought he hadn't really posted; I didn't want to give myself away.

I wasn't lying about the "Stels looks more like he's acting in his scum way" by the way. If I were town and shown those ISOs I'd still probably vote Stels.

[Twistedspoon]

Also, sorry for hogging all the day kills, guys. The first kill was situational. I didn't want to go a day without a kill. And I thought he hadn't really posted; I didn't want to give myself away.

I actually forgot we had them, tbh

@ant: indeed, even I do not know the supersaint protocol

[quadz08]

I believe the accepted protocol is to force someone you find scummy to hammer. If he doesn't, then you lynch him instead.

[tarsonisocelot]

Also, sorry for hogging all the day kills, guys. The first kill was situational. I didn't want to go a day without a kill. And I thought he hadn't really posted; I didn't want to give myself away.

I wasn't lying about the "Stels looks more like he's acting in his scum way" by the way. If I were town and shown those ISOs I'd still probably vote Stels.

Not a problem.

First game as mafia.
Second game that ended up wildly imbalanced.
'Twas fun but.

[Stels]

Well, I hit Cobbler right on the head, suspicioned TS with reference to "somewhere else" although I didn't mean to, and tars right at the beginning... Although, I just want to say that those on my wagon, specifically vezok/C-Worl were stupid. Just saying.

[Cobblerfone]

You know, had we had to have gone one more day, I'd probably would've tried to get TwoHeadedBoy lynched. I'll let Vezokpiraka be the judge of whether that would've worked.

And what the heck, Nacho? I was worried after everyone said you were a great scumhunter. But had you not been a Mason, I'd probably make you the third lynch. I guess everyone has an off game every now and then.

[Meransiel]

Verity.

I think this setup was terrible.

[Twistedspoon]

Verity.

I think this setup was terrible.

you're just saying that cause you died pre-game :/

[Twistedspoon]

I liked the setup, but I think death is a bit of a harsh consqeuence for using an ability. Maybe just weaken, randomise or reverse the ability effect instead. Death was too nasty :/

[Cobblerfone]

Or the Deputies could have been given some hint that investigating would be a bad idea. And if both Deputies had figured it out, we would've had to have gone on for two more days at least.

[Meransiel]

Exactly. It's almost like lying. At least warn us something, a riddle, some breadcrumbs, anything. Plus, there were TOO MANY PRs for that to take effect.

[Cobblerfone]

Oh, and it might've been more interesting if no one could select any actions on night zero. Then the widdling down of the power roles would've probably been more eery. Plus everyone would've been able to play. AND there would've been the even more interesting problem for the Cthulhu to try to avoid lynching AND Daykilling power roles.

[Meransiel]

Or you could've just killed only the FIRST person to send an action every night and call it a day (lol).

[Twistedspoon]

Or you could've just killed only the FIRST person to send an action every night and call it a day (lol).

yeah

[bobsnox]

Or the Deputies could have been given some hint that investigating would be a bad idea. And if both Deputies had figured it out, we would've had to have gone on for two more days at least.

this

[Nachomamma8]

Well, the game was fast

[Meransiel]

I'll give him that, yes.

[Energetic Penguin]

So setup boils down to being: 3 scum w/daykill V. 3 masons + 6 townies + small chance deputy shares old cop's result before dying.

That's a bastard setup given that people were expecting a large theme game and ended up getting a mini sized game. Plus that people with PRs died randomly, was probably unfun for them.

[Ant_to_the_max]

We didn't get his results because he was never given any results. What this game boiled down to was
Kill scum on D1 and you have 2 deputies and 3 masons
Or
Don't kill scum on D1 and you have 3 masons with 2* more misslynches