Mini 1167 - iPod Mafia - Game Over

[MagnaofIllusion]

Vote Count 1.1 - As of post 50

Fate (4) - Nopointinactingup, Agar, crazypianist1116, GreyICE
bvoigt (1) - Glass
Katsuki (1) - Riceballtail
Agar (1) - Raivann
Lady Lambdadelta (0) -
crazypianist1116 (0) -
Surye (1) - Lady Lambdadelta
ThAdmiral (0) -
Riceballtail (0) -
Glass (0) -
Nopointinactingup (0) -
GreyIce (0) -
Raivann (0) -

Not Voting (5) - Fate, bvoigt, Katsuki, Surye, ThAdmiral

The Current deadline is May 18th at 9am EST. The Countdown can be found HERE

With 13 alive - 7 are required to lynch.

Activity Check - All good currently.

[Katsuki]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY BTW, LLD~!

[Glass]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 23&t=15670

This is what happens when you let Flavor rule a town.

I know because I've done it, and I've won games as scum using it.

Flavor speculation leads nowhere but downhill.

You know that someone would try and speculate that any non-rock songs are of a different factions.

Scum would JUMP on that.

Hey, I like that variation of "Hitler built autobahns" fallacy. Also using one example can prove any "fact" in mafia. And although it is true that if flavor takes over all conversation than it is very bad for town, simply speculating flavor being worse than staying in RVS? Nah. If you know that scum would jump on that, would it not be better to let this go through and then be able to easily finger the scum?

WHAT BENEFIT CAN COME FROM SPECULATING FLAVOR?

I made it big so you can't miss it.

I presented a perfectly reasonable reason in my previous post. And I wasn't saying: "HEY ANYONE WHO ISN'T ROCK IS SCUM" I was trying to get some information out on the table. Withholding this kind of information can only hinder the job of cops in this game.

Essentially, are you just fucking about and wasting our time as town?

Or are you using flavor as a tool as scum?

Your call Glass. ^-^

Seriously? Moving out of the RVS is hardly wasting time, if you want to see wasting time you can look at posts 43-49.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I am curious what reason LLD would NOT want to know this, it is not like scum can figure out PRs by genre

and if we have some kind of namecop it is in our best interest to confirm that all town are rock.

VOTE: LLD

I presented a perfectly reasonable reason in my previous post.

And I wasn't saying: "HEY ANYONE WHO ISN'T ROCK IS SCUM"

Liar.

As for your "perfectly reasonable reason", that's basically you doing speculation. You're speculating about not only FLAVOR, but also throwing out a "WHAT IF THERE IS A NAME COP" thing too.

Your "perfectly reasonable reason" is the only true fallacy I see Glass.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Query: If you didn't mean that anyone who isn't Rock is scum... why would a name cop help us?

Because as I see it... us claiming whether we are rock or not only aids a Name Cop... if you believe that a certain faction would all fall under a "non-rock" condition.

So essentially you're backtracking and lying.

[Glass]

YES, BECAUSE IF EVERYONE CLAIMS ROCK THEN IT IS PRETTY DAMN OBVIOUS THAT ALL TOWNIES ARE ROCK, IS IT NOT? THAT IS WHAT I MEANT BY CONFIRM!!!

If you didn't mean that anyone who isn't Rock is scum... why would a name cop help us?

In that case a name cop wouldn't help us out, WHICH IS WHY I WANT TO SEE.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

YES, BECAUSE IF EVERYONE CLAIMS ROCK THEN IT IS PRETTY DAMN OBVIOUS THAT ALL TOWNIES ARE ROCK, IS IT NOT? THAT IS WHAT I MEANT BY CONFIRM!!!

If you didn't mean that anyone who isn't Rock is scum... why would a name cop help us?

In that case a name cop wouldn't help us out, WHICH IS WHY I WANT TO SEE.

This info helps scum more than town.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Considering that Scum benefits from finding out that all town are rock songs, where as town gains nothing from that.

You know, unless your speculated name cop exists.

Which I think personally is just an excuse for you to defend your flavor based subtle rolefishing, when you got called on it.

[Glass]

rolefishing

lol?

[Glass]

This info helps scum more than town.

Meh, that really depends.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

rolefishing

lol?

Real cool quote of one word in my post, taking it entirely out of context.

What the post that this came from was saying, is that you and GI are both supporting something that gives info about our roles to scum.

[GreyICE]

Pedit2: Glass is a guy.

I BLAME THE NUMEROUS APPLETINIS FOR THIS.

Happy birthday!

Appletinis are the devil. Last time I lost about 3 hours

Also, I'm Dream On... by the Glee Cast.

I think MoI needs to start posting in Guys part 2

I don't think so. Anything Neil Patrick Harris is involved with is ... oh, right. Nevermind.

[Glass]

WTF WAS THAT ICE?

[GreyICE]

Me laughing at this general debate.

Oh and mentioning my name/genre for this name cop (Seriously, how the fuck did my minor throwaway become this ridiculous conflagration)?

I mean you realize we have enough people who haven't posted to make an entire scumteam, right?

[Raivann]

Haha! I can't decide which is funnier, that MoI has a cover song from glee cast on his ipod or that he gave you the song/role!

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Pedit2: Glass is a guy.

I BLAME THE NUMEROUS APPLETINIS FOR THIS.

Happy birthday!

Appletinis are the devil. Last time I lost about 3 hours

Also, I'm Dream On... by the Glee Cast.

I think MoI needs to start posting in Guys part 2

I don't think so. Anything Neil Patrick Harris is involved with is ... oh, right. Nevermind.

ITT MoI confirms GI's role name? >.<

[GreyICE]

I'm now confirmed...

























flamboyant!

[GreyICE]

Anyway, didn't we have an excellent Fate wagon going? And look at what he's done since his wagon fell apart. He's made just as many scummy posts after that as he did before it!

Unvote

Vote: Fate

Good wagon is good!

[GreyICE]

I got a PM.

Apparently Fate is lynch immune today, so we have to get a buddy

LLD and I are alignment confirmed masons.

Wait, actually?

YIPPEE

Vote: ThAdmiral

[Glass]

ICE, are you trying to bring us back into the RVS? I thought you said you hated it?

K, thought about it some more and I don't see how knowing that town is rock could possibly help scum. When I posted 59 I thought that it may help mafia come up with a reasonable fakeclaim, but that does not really make sense since if the town have no flavor knowledge as the scum could claim anything and if scum don't need to claim day 1 they can clearly see that the person lynched + NK were rock genre and make up a claim from there. So how does this information help scum LLD?

[Katsuki]

I just went and listened to my song...

It's terrible...

Not to mention, my PM includes the words "slut" and "slutty"...
FUCK YOU MOI.

[Glass]

katsuki, you don't have anything to say about the LLD-me exchange? Or anything game related for that matter?

[GreyICE]

ICE, are you trying to bring us back into the RVS? I thought you said you hated it?

No, that'd be a rather serious vote for a rather scummy poster.

[ThAdmiral]

I have no idea whether people are being serious or just fucking with me.

This game seems like it's going to be entertaining!

[bvoigt]

Sorry, I'll get a real post up this evening.