New York 134: Planet of Hats (Scum Win!)

[glowball]

don't worry Reck- the feeling is mutual.

[xRECKONERx]

Technically

claiming scum like that is against your wincon, and

technically

that's modkillable, and

technically

a modkill on scum wouldn't end the day, so

technically

we could get a lot of mileage out of this.

But a scumlynch is great all the same.

[xRECKONERx]

don't worry Reck- the feeling is mutual.

What feeling is mutual?

[glowball]

modkill whatever, I forgot I was in NewYork- I made a mistake, mod kill me black list me I am tired- I am tired of this game and I never even wanted to joined I was roped in by my other head who deserted me in the beginning and in the middle and at the end. I see why people would blacklist this hydra, but me? When I play I am dedicated- this game just was an annoyance from the moment I joined.

NINJA'D
the blacklist.

[Amrun]

Cease the wifom, scum.

what wifom? I just claimed scum. There is no question...

"- don't think town will win" "my teammate left me hanging" etc

Reck, chkflip flaked, this head is gllowball.

[bvoigt]

Congrats guys- I am kind of hoping for a town win because...well, I just don't think you guys will see it.

What do you mean by this?

[xRECKONERx]

modkill whatever, I forgot I was in NewYork- I made a mistake, mod kill me black list me I am tired- I am tired of this game and I never even wanted to joined I was roped in by my other head who deserted me in the beginning and in the middle and at the end. I see why people would blacklist this hydra, but me? When I play I am dedicated- this game just was an annoyance from the moment I joined.

NINJA'D
the blacklist.

And you're blacklisting ME? Why?

[glowball]

Amrun told me to shut up- and it is in the best interest of the game if I do. Sorry guys, I wish I could have been more invested but life got the best of me and for about 80% of the game I wasnt even playing in a hydra, I was by myself- which wouldn't have been a problem if I knew that from the beginning. Although, I am pretty sure the majority of you will blacklist me as well the Mod. I am truly sorry- now I am off to take the nap that I need.

NINJA'D
... are you serious?
People who blacklist other players after one game, are arrogant. I don't need to play with them. I don't deserve your blacklist- but your little comment earned mine. There should be some decent level of human understanding that I actually have a real life and things got the best of me. I explained what happened and if you choose to blacklist me then I don't want to play with someone like you anyway. Those types of people see only the game, and not the player beyond the game. It's just an internet forum- but some people are unusually arrogant.

[xRECKONERx]

I don't blacklist people for no reason. In fact, originally, I was going to blacklist your hydra partner. I wasn't even talking about blacklisting you.

In any case, thanks for the free scumlynch!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[bvoigt]

I feel like Reck is chkballin's partner.

[xRECKONERx]

nope, incorrect

BTW, I PMed the mod asking if we can haz a modkill on chkballin for playing against his wincon

[xRECKONERx]

I am tired, and I am sorry to my teammate- but at this point I don't like them very much anyway, they left me hanging the other night as well anyway.

chkballin said his teammate left him hanging. This would have to an active lurker or someone who isn't posting much, IE DGB or Vinegar Eater.

[xRECKONERx]

I feel like Reck is chkballin's partner.

okay but now I'm curious, why did you say this?

[Wraith]

Shit like this gets me a bad rep.

chkballin

,

Mafia Roleblocker

turned

Neutral Survivor

,

Modkilled Day 7

Forward appropriate night actions by

August 18, 2011

[Wraith]

Day Eight

NobodySpecial

,

Town Cop

,

Killed Night 7

With 6 alive it takes

4

to lynch.

Deadline for this day is

August 27, 2011

[bvoigt]

DGB is basically confirmed town, since she hasn't been around to send in a NK.

I feel like Reck is chkballin's partner.

okay but now I'm curious, why did you say this?

Gut, mostly. Also, chkballin's reasoning for blacklisting you doesn't make much sense: "I'm blacklisting you after one game because you blacklisted me after one game."

[bvoigt]

I still think the PGO claim makes Vinegar town. That leaves Reck, Amrun, and Celebloki.

[Nobody Special]

BAH!!!!!

[Amrun]

Well, the flip ninjaed a big post of mine where I analyzed chkballin. I saved it as a draft but I have no idea how to access it. (Anyone?)$

Long story short: no WAY is celebloki scum. Reck also gets townpoints.

Chkballin wifomed about dgb, but bvoigt was the only player chkballin didn't omgus.

VOTE: bvoigt

Their interactions were weird, and bvoigt's quick vote and few words yesterday make him stand out.

[bvoigt]

@Amrun: Just hit the "Load" button next to the "Save draft" button. I assume most of my questions will be answered in that post.

[Amrun]

That button doesn't show up. X.X

[xRECKONERx]

HAHAHAHA. Scum is scared now without their roleblocker to stop the cop from investigating them.

Vote: bvoigt

[xRECKONERx]

bvoigt tried to push that I was chkballin's buddy despite it not making any sense since chkballin said his buddy has been ABSENT and left him hanging all game. It makes zero sense. He's flailing now that his buddy outted himself.

[xRECKONERx]

Oh yeah, I had this post typed up last night after chk's flip:

Well that modkill shouldn't have ended the day, so that's bullshit. I PMed the mod to ask about it and he said "Well chkballin was going to get lynched anyway". Seriously?

But oh well, this game has been an absolute catastrophe so far anyway.

Confirmed non-VT flips:

Town Cop
Town 2-Shot Vigilante
Town Doctor
Town Miller

3x Mafia Goon
Mafia Roleblocker

Bulletproof Investigation-Immune Serial Killer

Remaining Claims:

DGB - VT?
VinegarEater - PGO
bvoigt - VT?
Nobody Special - Cop
xRECKONERx - VT
Amrun - VT
Celebloki - VT

I honestly don't think we have a Godfather at this point. There's already an investigation-immune SK AND a Miller. Throwing in a Godfather nerfs the cop power way too hard for a game this size, IMO. I'm going to run through some potential scenarios.

I stated earlier in the game that chkballin scum means VE might be scum, which is still possible. I need to back and look at where I drew that connection.

I also stated that "If chkballin is a backup roleblocker, then there's no way NS is a second cop". chkballin wasn't a backup roleblocker, which makes me feel a LITTLE better about Nobody Special's claim.

Unless there's more than one kill overnight, we're looking at a probable 1v5 situation here. That gives us only one more mislynch, I think:
D8: 1v5. Mislynch.
N8: 1v4. Mafia Kill.
D9: 1v3. Mislynch.
N9: 1v2. Mafia Kill.
D10: 1v1. Game over.

Okay, so we actually have TWO more mislynches. At this point in time, I'm willing to go with Nobody Special being confirmed town. Looking back, it seems that posts and 1315 were what lead me to my VE-chkballin read. And it still seems pretty accurate. I'm going to put VE as my #1 preferred lynch for tomorrow (/today).

A lot of this can change depending on who dies overnight. chkballin's final posts made it seem like his partner was inactive and leaving them out to dry, which would fit with DGB's lack of presence in the thread... but lack of presence in the thread also means lack of presence to submit night actions.

Town->scum list right now goes:
Nobody Special
Amrun
Celebloki
DrippingGoofball
bvoigt
VinegarEater

Though I will say that Amrun & Celebloki are essentially interchangable. Amrun gets a slight edge of Celebloki because I liked her interactions with chkballin' yesterday, but not by much.

We only have six people and two mislynches (plus two mafia kills) so I'd say we're in good shape either way.

[Amrun]

Yeah basically.if it's not him it's dgb.

P-edit: VinegarEater is not scum.