Mini 1211: Murder in Sicily [Over]

[bobsnox]

VOTE: crappy

cause... you're crappy

[iamausername]

VOTE: bobsnox

No comment on anything that happened in the first two pages? A random vote on a player who's not even here to react to it? No thanks.

[bobsnox]

haha this is funny. I forgot what game this was... went to the newest post and did a typical RVS. hhaha I'm a little ashamed.

UNVOTE: Crappy

Let me actually consider context now

[Friend]

VOTE WHISKERS

self-explanatory.

Iam, why do you think Whiskers' reaction was town?

[Panacea]

Sweet, we're official now!

Um, I'm pretty sure Substrike was just making a joke about the dayvig. Just sayin'. I also think Whiskers's reaction to it was a bit extreme.

I also don't think Friend is "snuggling up" to Substrike. Friend at the point of this post (#27) had said nothing to or about Substrike. That being said, I think Whiskers's vote

was

OMGUSsy.

I don't like this quote:

...Because I have a vote on me and you won't get blamed for starting the wagon?

This seems too jumpy to me.Or this:

If Scumhunter flips scum, then you can lynch me all you want,

because I'll admit, that would look really scummy.

If he's Town, it threatens his win condition to suggest we lynch the only conftown player he'd know of (himself).

I don't like the way Bobsnox so apologetically removed his vote when Iam called him on it.

Suspects are Whiskers and Bobsnox at the moment, but both are too weak for votes.

[Friend]

Panacea, it's so early in the game. Why do you feel the need to be tentative with your vote?

[bobsnox]

Panacea - I removed it because it was purely RVS when I didn't realize what game this was and the fact that RVS was done with. I should be voting someone who I think is scummy.

[Friend]

Bobsnox, who do you think is scummy?

[Panacea]

@ Friend: Because LTP Mafia and Tovarish have only confirmed, and Monk has only confirmed and complained about the wait time. Too many bad experiences with me getting tangled up with a player early on and scum slipping by.

@Bobsnox: I can see this only because the Limbo pregame thing wasn't really clear. But for the record, though, when you say you "forgot what game this was," do you mean you thought it was another game entirely..?

[Whiskers]

I said you could lynch me, because the original thought to post was
If scumhunter is scum and I'm very upset about his being Daykilled, I'd vote for me
Or,
...I'll replace out of the game.
The first doesn't serve any purpose, the second would be harmful to town and I won't do it anyway, But If I do something so obviously scum-telling as that, I would not resist a lynch. I'd hang my head and cry.

[Substrike22]

VOTE: Whiskers

Follow my thoughts from pre-game for reasoning.

[Friend]

@Panacea: Fair enough. Your response seems quite genuine.

Whiskers, why haven't you voted me yet if you were so insistent on me being scum?

[Substrike22]

I said you could lynch me, because the original thought to post was
If scumhunter is scum and I'm very upset about his being Daykilled, I'd vote for me
Or,
...I'll replace out of the game.
The first doesn't serve any purpose, the second would be harmful to town and I won't do it anyway, But If I do something so obviously scum-telling as that, I would not resist a lynch. I'd hang my head and cry.

Honestly this post make me feel you're scum.

Threatening to replace out in the face of a situation that looks bad is scummy.

The issue isn't Scumhunter's alignment, it was your reaction to the kill period.

[Whiskers]

I dunno.

Also, now we have more than three players in the game.

[PREEDIT]
Right, which is why I didn't say it. Not only would I Not replace out of a game, like, ever, but It would also be more harmful than helpful.

[iamausername]

bobsnox, why didn't you post anything while the pregame daykill shenanigans were going on?

[bobsnox]

bobsnox, why didn't you post anything while the pregame daykill shenanigans were going on?

I was way too busy and the game hadn't technically started.

Friend - let me get back to you this weekend. I need to read all the pregame stuff that I basically ignored <_<

Panacea - yes. I didn't make the connection obviously. I got the PM and was like oh yeah I'm in that one game that was supposed to start soon... guess I'll go post.

Sorry guys.

[monk]

VOTE: Panacea
Just because you have weak suspicions doesn't mean you can't place a vote down on someone

[bobsnox]

Going to a wedding in another city today. Will post more tonight.

[Panacea]

Iam, I think you missed the request. How can you read Whiskers's reaction as Town?

Monk, my suspicion of Bobsnox was so weak that had I voted when I mentioned it, I'd just have unvoted in my next post after he explained himself. I don't tape votes onto Weeble-Wobbles unless it's (apparently-bypassed here) RVS.

[Panacea]

Whiskers, why haven't you voted me yet if you were so insistent on me being scum?

I dunno.

Would you say it had anything to do with the consequences of OMGUS, Whiskers?

[Tovarish]

Vote- Whiskers

Normally, I would let something like his earlier comments regarding the daykill to slide, having been part of the joke and whatnot. His intransigence, rudeness and the overly sensitive replies indicate, at least to me that he has something to hide.

[Noramp]

I'm a little weary of this Whiskers wagon and the speed of which it is gaining momentum. Let us not forget we have all of D1 to decide not just pregame.

bobsnox, why didn't you post anything while the pregame daykill shenanigans were going on?

Do you feel that he has to post in a period where it is not required to post? (outside of confirming)

Also, now we have more than three players in the game.

Does this change the fact that in pregame you ultimately said Friend was obvious scum?

@Monk You vote Panacea for not voting what about everyone else who isnt voting? i count three people before this post and one after (me)

[Whiskers]

Also, Friend is scum-- not Omgussing, either, but he's snuggling up to Substrike, and already bandwagonning on the first, easiest candidate.

Vote: Friend

Also, like I said, we have MORE than those three player now, so any of them could be mafia, not just one of us three.

Is anypony coasting under the radar so far in this game?

{PREEDIT}

[Whiskers]

Darn it. preedit didn't work. But anyway, here it is:

I think he voted for Pana since she gave a read And didn't vote.

[Noramp]

Does that vote count Whiskers?