Mini 1219 - Bedtime Stories Mafia - Game Over!

[Neruz]

If Thomith is scummy, why make a second RVS vote?

OK, if Tomith is scummy, then why did you place another random vote?

Why not!

[Voidedmafia]

If Thomith is scummy, why make a second RVS vote?

OK, if Tomith is scummy, then why did you place another random vote?

Why not!

Um, wouldn't you usually vote your suspects? Even if this is RVS somewhat.

[Neruz]

If Thomith is scummy, why make a second RVS vote?

OK, if Tomith is scummy, then why did you place another random vote?

Why not!

Um, wouldn't you usually vote your suspects? Even if this is RVS somewhat.

I didn't say i suspected him, i said he scored some scum points. I'd need a hell of a lot more than just one rather mildly scummy reaction before i start 'suspecting' someone, especially given there are plenty of players who havn't even posted yet.

[weirdvoigts]

That makes no sense.

Even if it's just a few scumpoints, he's still scummier than everyone else, right? Why wouldn't you be voting the most scummy player?

~Wierdalexv

[Beck]

If Thomith is scummy, why make a second RVS vote?

OK, if Tomith is scummy, then why did you place another random vote?

Why not!

some people think double RVS votes come from scum, at least that is what Parama said in the last game we played.
I proved to him that it didn't but that is why people are grilling you, apparently on MS you are only allowed 1 RVS vote.

[Thomith]

Tbh i don't find Neruz scummy for not voting me, it seems like a town instinct to not vote if there is only one or two scumpoints on them but to rather wait untill someone with major scum points pops up.

[Thomith]

I still want to know why i scored scum points though Neruz.

[Voidedmafia]

If Thomith is scummy, why make a second RVS vote?

OK, if Tomith is scummy, then why did you place another random vote?

Why not!

some people think double RVS votes come from scum, at least that is what Parama said in the last game we played.
I proved to him that it didn't but that is why people are grilling you, apparently on MS you are only allowed 1 RVS vote.

For me, it's more like, you've already pegged thomith as scummiest out of all of us at this point; why the hell aren't you pushing that suspicion?

[hiphop]

VOTE: hiphop for having a name that is similar to hiplop.

More like he picked a name similar to mine. I have been playing for 2 years, and ever since he joined this year, people have been calling me hiplop. Even the cow, put hiplop in the player's list of the last game that I joined.

As for Neruz- I am trying to lynch scum, what are you trying to do?

[Thomith]

As for Neruz- I am trying to lynch scum, what are you trying to do?

what is this an answer to?

[hiphop]

His stance on the fact that he would rather random vote, then place a real vote.

[Voidedmafia]

His stance on the fact that he would rather random vote, then place a real vote.

Adding on to this, I ask again: Why are you not trying to push your biggest scumspect (even if only by a little) to verify or disclaim your suspicions, Neruz?

[Beck]

Omg, I thought I was playing with hiplop. Thank god it's a different person

[hiphop]

Omg, I thought I was playing with hiplop. Thank god it's a different person

Seriously?

[Beck]

I was on my phone, thought he just changed his avatar. I mean they look similar

[Rainbowdash]

Greetings everypony! Through the element of loyalty, maybe some bravery (or arrogence), this should be wrapped up soon.

No real point in getting into the offtopic discussion here instead of staying on track with looking at both Neruz and Thomith who already have dropped a few tells each. Thomith in 10 and Neruz in 19 are both easily enough to justify wagons, but they probably are not scum together. Ponies actually ignoring both of these for periods of time is quite confusing, but Deselby grabs third pick quite solidly.

Wierd is asking the right questions to Neruz. Even if he does suspect someone a little, it should be enough to justify a vote at this stage of a game. Bigger then being afraid of throwing down a vote which someponies always are against doing for some reason that I never have quite been able to understand, Neruz is making no attempt to further investigate his read of Thomith. You want to see if a gut feeling is actually justified or not through questions and applying pressure, not saying that somepony is a little suspect and then just sitting back down.

For Thomith being off, his response to being called scum for his early comment is way too jokey and seeming nervous for what obviously is more of a RVS stage comment about him normally drawing one alignment.

Elite case? No. Its where we start this though.

Vote Neruz

[Thomith]

Too jokey makes me nervous? When i get called out for "claiming" when i really was taking a jab back at hiphop for his first post, (i assume this is what you mean by "jokey" as i see no other time when i have been "jokey".)

Again i will say, i don't think Neruz is scum because they didn't vote for me, Town usually want to find more than one reason to vote someone so i don't see how this is scummy.

[hiphop]

Again i will say, i don't think Neruz is scum because they didn't vote for me, Town usually want to find more than one reason to vote someone so i don't see how this is scummy.

So town wants to vote for someone completely random, because they don't find the guy they think is scummy, scummy enough? To me, the scumtell above is the most scummiest thing said all game. My vote reamins.

[hiphop]

*remains

[weirdvoigts]

@Tomith: Would you explain town motivation for not voting their top suspect, even with only a small suspicion?

[Rainbowdash]

Too jokey makes me nervous? When i get called out for "claiming" when i really was taking a jab back at hiphop for his first post, (i assume this is what you mean by "jokey" as i see no other time when i have been "jokey".)

The response seems very off to me, not something that I could have seen myself coming up with. Almost as if you didn't know if he was being serious or not so tried to play it off with a joke.

Again i will say, i don't think Neruz is scum because they didn't vote for me, Town usually want to find more than one reason to vote someone so i don't see how this is scummy.

Town usually will vote for somepony with little to no reasoning. What type of poines have you been playing with?

[Thomith]

Town don't usually vote for no reasoning apart from in RVS, why would town vote for someone who they can't prove are scum? Wouldn't town want to find evidence before actually voting?

[Voidedmafia]

...Your use of ponies in place of people is slightly unsettling.

But both you and Hiphop have good points regarding Thomith. Could be scum bussing a partner, or town getting a bit too defensive, but I'm willing to go out on a limb about it.

Vote: Neruz

Town don't usually vote for no reasoning apart from in RVS, why would town vote for someone who they can't prove are scum? Wouldn't town want to find evidence before actually voting?

Yet, we're in RVS, somewhat. At this point, that slight scumread he has should be enough. You're just implicating him indirectly and starting to dig your own hole.

[weirdvoigts]

Lolyup, that's a great idea!

Instead of voting the only person who we actually think is scum, we're going to vote somebody completely randomly for no reason instead of him just because there isn't a full case on him.
~~
On a side note, Rainbowdash, it's really annoying when you refer to everybody as ponies.

~Wierdalexv

[Thomith]

So town should vote someone who they don't have many points on. K.