SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[Parabollocks]

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

Actually, i find the reaction to it more Null on their part and more concerned with projectmatt says.

[Vifam]

Why not just read the thread and comment on everything when you're done, it's three pages long.

[Parabollocks]

I don't thin scum would look so obvious out of the gate.

This was directed at the Isa wagon, right? You think that a scum would intentionally act obvious? No. A scum can act scummy unintentionally. This logic hurts my head.

Vote: Xeras

My bad. Your logic is still a tad illogical though.

Good news is, I was wrong about me finding it weird and Xeras/Vifam are probably town. See how magical RVS is?

I don't like this post. Did Xeras and Vifam objectively towntell to you, or did they just prove that you were attacking them based off of faulty logic? Why are they now town reads?

I like this from Matt.

@Vifam

multi-quoting is a style of mine, saves me time and gives me a visual reminder, i don't mean to intentionally clog up the thread.

[Parabollocks]

and also i do read the thread, i just quote things of interest.

Vote: DemonHybrid

[Vifam]

That's delightfully annoying and if you're going to do that EVERY catch up we are going to have a problem.


Why the vote on DH?

[Parabollocks]

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

Asking a player about a scumread is "Anti Town"?

So much scum motivation I can't even see it
UNVOTE:
VOTE: DemonHybrid

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

So... asking someone about their opinion in reads is scummy....

No.

Unvote, Vote DemonHybrid

I'm saying that the fact that this happened:

Why is David scum?

Followed by this:

Why is David Scum?

within the span of 5 minutes is fucking weird, and that I don't think that the BOTH of them could be town.

Interesting theory, but as reminded by Hoppster, it's tentatively Null, the point or 'logic' you are bringing up against them is very faulty, and it would be best if you pursue different avenues instead beat a dead horse.

so many analogies man it's amazing

ninja, i'm explaining it to you right now.

[Parabollocks]

okay read time

Town (towniest to not as townie..est.) Hoppster, Projectmatt, Xeras, Vifam, David
Null: Hiplop, the lurkers/people who aren't here, Isa
Scum: Demonhybrid.

[Vifam]

hnng


UNVOTE:


VOTE: VanillaCupcake


Ignoring a thread four pages into the day? Not cool, man.

[diddin]

Nah, I'm not. I don't see the scumminess in my actions just because you've done so as scum.

This is such a Scum response.

Vote: Isa

You guys are lame.


VOTE: Sunset

This was a stupid random vote.

hnng


UNVOTE:


VOTE: VanillaCupcake


Ignoring a thread four pages into the day? Not cool, man.

This is an even more terrible reason to vote someone.

Isa's scum. Don't see DemonHybrid scum at all. Also don't get why Hoppster is the god of towniness for everyone. Vifam from past experiences is a massive VI but he's been pretty scummy so far.

[DemonHybrid]

My bad. Your logic is still a tad illogical though.

Good news is, I was wrong about me finding it weird and Xeras/Vifam are probably town. See how magical RVS is?

I don't like this post. Did Xeras and Vifam objectively towntell to you, or did they just prove that you were attacking them based off of faulty logic? Why are they now town reads?

Vifam's answer read as something that no scum would ever say, even newer scum.

Xeras' vote and full-on challenging of my logic screams as someone who is scumhunting.

So, yeah, they towntelled to me in their own ways.

[DemonHybrid]

okay read time

Town (towniest to not as townie..est.) Hoppster, Projectmatt, Xeras, Vifam, David
Null: Hiplop, the lurkers/people who aren't here, Isa
Scum: Demonhybrid.

Huh. You stopped reading my argument right after that post. Any reason why?

[Vifam]

The random vote stems because I am not getting a strong read on anyone right now. Isa isn't ringing as scum to me.


Vanilla posted in a game earlier, I just wanted to point out he that he seemed to not be paying any attention to this thread despite it being a very brief read, how does that make my vote "Terrible"?

[Hoppster]

hnng


UNVOTE:


VOTE: VanillaCupcake


Ignoring a thread four pages into the day? Not cool, man.

Who?

Isa's scum. Don't see DemonHybrid scum at all.

Also don't get why Hoppster is the god of towniness for everyone.

Vifam from past experiences is a massive VI but he's been pretty scummy so far.

How can you say this diddin?

This hurts me.

It hurts me in my

soul

.

;_;

(Also: "everyone"? As far as I can see, it's just Parabollocks who has even mentioned any read whatsoever on me.)

You guys are lame.


VOTE: Sunset

This was a stupid random vote.

Was Xeras' vote for you stupid?

[Parabollocks]

okay read time

Town (towniest to not as townie..est.) Hoppster, Projectmatt, Xeras, Vifam, David
Null: Hiplop, the lurkers/people who aren't here, Isa
Scum: Demonhybrid.

Huh. You stopped reading my argument right after that post. Any reason why?

I find the base of the argument more important, my suspicision of you comes with what i quoted.

DH, where are you looking now, anyways?

[Vifam]

Actually


UNVOTE:


VOTE: Diddin

Also don't get why Hoppster is the god of towniness for everyone

Undermining Hoppster while hopping on the wagon on "scum" that Hoppster himself created.

[diddin]

Actually


UNVOTE:


VOTE: Diddin

Also don't get why Hoppster is the god of towniness for everyone

Undermining Hoppster while hopping on the wagon on "scum" that Hoppster himself created.

So we're in agreement on something. I'm just saying that I don't have as strong of a townread on Hoppster as other people do. He's null-town for now.

[Parabollocks]

Diddin, i believe i was the only one to give insight on Hoppster, why were you quick to assume that everyone had him pegged as town?

[Vifam]

Actually


UNVOTE:


VOTE: Diddin

Also don't get why Hoppster is the god of towniness for everyone

Undermining Hoppster while hopping on the wagon on "scum" that Hoppster himself created.

So we're in agreement on something. I'm just saying that I don't have as strong of a townread on Hoppster as other people do. He's null-town for now.

"Agreement"

What?

[DemonHybrid]

okay read time

Town (towniest to not as townie..est.) Hoppster, Projectmatt, Xeras, Vifam, David
Null: Hiplop, the lurkers/people who aren't here, Isa
Scum: Demonhybrid.

Huh. You stopped reading my argument right after that post. Any reason why?

I find the base of the argument more important, my suspicision of you comes with what i quoted.

DH, where are you looking now, anyways?

Concerned as to why you aren't interested in the aftermath nor the reasoning.

I'm looking at Isa and diddin. More suspicious of Isa, more curious about diddin.

[Parabollocks]

unvote

It's not i wasn't concerned, it's just that i took it as face-value, what you said was warranted but i was curious as to how you would react to a loaded vote.

what's your read on vifam/xeras now?

[DemonHybrid]

Good news is, I was wrong about me finding it weird and Xeras/Vifam are probably town. See how magical RVS is?

I'm trying to process Ira's actions up to this point.

My bad. Your logic is still a tad illogical though.

Good news is, I was wrong about me finding it weird and Xeras/Vifam are probably town. See how magical RVS is?

I don't like this post. Did Xeras and Vifam objectively towntell to you, or did they just prove that you were attacking them based off of faulty logic? Why are they now town reads?

Vifam's answer read as something that no scum would ever say, even newer scum.

Xeras' vote and full-on challenging of my logic screams as someone who is scumhunting.

So, yeah, they towntelled to me in their own ways.

[DemonHybrid]

I keep mixing up Ira and Isa. This is going to be a long game.

[Parabollocks]

so anything newer didn't change the read? (even though this only technically counts for vifam)

alright.

are you agreeing with the Isa suspicision because of Hoppster, or just for own reasons?

[DemonHybrid]

Vote: Isa

.

That last reply was fishy and deflective.

Own reasons, though Hoppster said that Isa's deflection didn't help her case.

[diddin]

Actually


UNVOTE:


VOTE: Diddin

Also don't get why Hoppster is the god of towniness for everyone

Undermining Hoppster while hopping on the wagon on "scum" that Hoppster himself created.

So we're in agreement on something. I'm just saying that I don't have as strong of a townread on Hoppster as other people do. He's null-town for now.

"Agreement"

What?

We agree about Isa being scum.