Secret Society Mafia - Game Over

[zMuffinMan]

That doesn't make sense as much sense as you think it does.

[Magister Ludi]

@Cult recruiter, me and muffin had a lengthy game with cult recruiter in it, where I was cult recruiter. Its a joke.

zMuffin: Cultrecruiter, ugh, isn't that the most hated role on mafiascum? Ugh and I pissed him of.

Max, Yos: You two like Ludis posting, from your asking of Baby Spice?

Vote: StefanB

[Magister Ludi]

How so muffin?

[zMuffinMan]

In fact, considering the anti-town probably have more insight into the setup, following one of their leads onto another player is probably better at finding the other faction than by following someone you think is town.

I suppose it makes sense if all you're doing is limiting yourself to looking for the "other" faction, but that still doesn't make sense.

Also, according to my

divination via random.org

thorough logic and reasoning, which is based on years of studying under mastin before becoming an apprentice to blackberry, MoI is werewolf goon, not mafia.

[zMuffinMan]

wait, that was stefan who called him mafia, not you. whatever. point still stands, he's a werewolf goon.

[Yosarian2]

Vote Ludi

Too many posts I don't like, spamming, strangeness.

Ok. What don't you like about his posts?

Spamming and strangeness, like I said.

More specifically he denied that he was spamming, though he is at times (Multiple one liner posts and outright fluff posts), and I find it weird that he asked Stefan to define strange whereas I would have thought asking Stefan to show or explain what he found strange would be normal.

I don't think he was "spamming" at all, assuming you mean "spamming" to be posting without content, he's probably posted more real content then anyone else in the game. I don't get how you can call his posts fluff, either.

Anyway, can you explain what was strange/scummy about his posts specifically, or what made you think he was "spamming the thread" and why you think that is a scumtell? It really feels like you're just echoing Otolia's posts to place a vote, and I don't like that.

[Yosarian2]

Max, Yos: You two like Ludis posting, from your asking of Baby Spice?

I already called him probably town, before Baby Spice posted; didn't you notice that?

[Yosarian2]

What is this nonsense? How does he even know one of them is anti-town to start with?

I don't know with 100% certainty, sure, but it's called a read. Would it have been better if I said,"Between the 3 of them,

I think

one is scum." ?

It feels like you're just repeating yourself without explaining here. Why do you think one of them is scum, based on their interactions?

[Alabaska J]

Interesting classification otolia. Posting has become "spam"

Of 18 posts, only one of yours contains more than 1 line. So yes, you are spamming.

One day you will learn that quality >> quantity, in the mean time you can continue to wank on your postcount.

Why does long length indicate quality, otolia. And in that regards,

Unvote
Vote: Otolia

Calling me out for quality and posting, while not providing any of your own.

5 bucks says that both these guys are town. (note: this is not intended to be an actual bet, please don't modkill me, kthx)

i agree with this one. seems like an early town-on-town squabble. scum rarely get into those. not the strongest tell, mind you.

VOTE: Global Warming
Because Al Gore told me it was bad.

This guy is confirmed town for Day 1.

Werewolves are another mafia faction. They'll have flavour something like "ripped to shreds" for kills. Cops can't detect them, but Seers can. Docs can't protect from them, but Herbalists (or something) can, because of Wolfsbane. There's a wiki on them I think.

There is no kill flavour in this game.
Though there may be specialised cops and/or doctors. Depends on the game.

Well utilizing the gamblers fallacy, you're more likely to be scum here!

And yes I did change my avatar =)


VOTE: Whispersilk
Just gonna sheep muffinman until I see something I don't like.

And this guy can be town too for the moment.

care to explain? or are you gonna tack on a buddy to reasonable logic and hope it slides by?

[TheJakalope]

What is this nonsense? How does he even know one of them is anti-town to start with?

I don't know with 100% certainty, sure, but it's called a read. Would it have been better if I said,"Between the 3 of them,

I think

one is scum." ?

It feels like you're just repeating yourself without explaining here. Why do you think one of them is scum, based on their interactions?

It's not a "Well, David said THIS, and that means one of them is scum!" Just look through the 2nd(?) page and look at how they interacted.

[Baby Spice]

Tell me Yos, why do you need to ask questions in a post where you quote the answers to those questions?

[sorgster]

@Cult recruiter, me and muffin had a lengthy game with cult recruiter in it, where I was cult recruiter. Its a joke.

zMuffin: Cultrecruiter, ugh, isn't that the most hated role on mafiascum? Ugh and I pissed him of.

Max, Yos: You two like Ludis posting, from your asking of Baby Spice?

Vote: StefanB

can you post the game for that if it is finished? Sounds like a bluff to me and something talked in a qt at night phase.

[Magister Ludi]

Go look at brightest day mafia, its not over, but we're both dead. Why would I lie about that?

[BBmolla]

Muffin are you scum?

[Magua]

Do not reference ongoing games, even ongoing games where you have died.

[Magister Ludi]

What the hell sort of question is that?

pedit: Sorry mod!

[Magister Ludi]

I just thought about it. That post from sorgster is incredibly weak. It doesn't look like town trying to find scum. It looks like noise.

And I know for some people page five is still early goings, but flash check his iso. Its pretty bad.

[Magister Ludi]

I actually reread page two. Magna, do you still want to speed lynch David X for self voting?

[Maxous]

Max, Yos: You two like Ludis posting, from your asking of Baby Spice?

Not particulary.

It's not a "Well, David said THIS, and that means one of them is scum!" Just look through the 2nd(?) page and look at how they interacted.

I think you're taking thier joking too seriously.

Muffin are you scum?

I don't get the point of this

[sorgster]

I actually reread page two. Magna, do you still want to speed lynch David X for self voting?

Why are you asking magna of all people? Also, speedlynching isn't good for town as it doesn't give enough information.

[Magister Ludi]

Why am I asking him? Because he wants (?) to do it, I don't, and I think it is anti-town. Read page two.

Thanks for informing me about the virtues of speedlynching!

[Yosarian2]

Tell me Yos, why do you need to ask questions in a post where you quote the answers to those questions?

Because either I feel like you haven't answered the question, or I don't like your answer, obviously.

You voted him because you said his posts were "spammy and strange"; I asked you why they were strange, and all you could say was "They were spammy and he said they weren't spammy". And now I'm asking you why they're spammy, assuming "spammy" means "a lot of posts without content", and why that spammy posting is scummy.

I want you to explain why you're voting for him. I don't think that you have, yet.

care to explain? or are you gonna tack on a buddy to reasonable logic and hope it slides by?

(shrug) I got a vaguely pro-town vibe from that post I quoted. Nothing too strong, really.

[Baby Spice]

I love it whem scum decide to misrepresent stuff that's still on this page.

But if you really want to pretend to be stupid:

Something kike 25% of the posts in the game are by Ludi.
Even on tbis page there are three consecutive posts, all real short, within a six minute timespam, as well as two consecutive posts with the same time stamp.

What point is there to asking if someone likes the Spice Girls? What point is there to asking MoI to list (all?) games where scum self voted in RVS? Or continuing to push it?

I already covered strange, thiugh the above with MoI that I cited is another good example of it.

[Magister Ludi]

You don't think asking someone who pushes something as scummy, to prove that the actual thought process comes from scum, is necessary?

Plus, some posts are about having fun, yeah, with people I like. Its why we're here, too.

[Magister Ludi]

Plus, you're obviously not reading. zmuffin states he has a serious vote on whispersilk. Considering the only things whisper has said is he doesn't like the spice girls, it was prime time for a joke. His response actually helped me get a read on zmuffin, considering I've had a few games with him now.