Mini 228 - Smash Brothers - GAME OVER

[inHimshallibe]

gah... perfectionism... taking over... **gauge**

[Iammars]

gah... perfectionism... taking over... **gauge**

Do I even want to know what that was about?

[Bacde]

I noticed.

[Bacde]

Err, my feeling dumb side would like to point out that my last post was directed at inhim >_>.

[Commodore Amazing]

Vote Count #1! With 12 players, it takes 7 to lynch!

2 armlx - Bacde, inhimshallibe
1 Assasin - rajrhcpfreak
1 Bacde - Chaos
1 Chaos - SinisterOverlord
1 SinisterOverlord - Someone
1 rajrhcpfreak - Assasin
1 Someone - Iammars
1 inhimshallibe - PBuG

Not voting: NanookTheWolf, indentureddjinn, armlx

edited for correctness, thanks inhimshallibe

[inHimshallibe]

Mental notes I've made thus far:
Nanook/raj exchange
armlx and indentureddjinn actually commenting on their no-votes


(Mod: Not voting: NanookTheWolf, indentureddjinn, armlx)

[armlx]

Meh. I don't early game random vote. Its a waste of my and the mods time.

[indentureddjinn]

I usually do random vote (just for fun), but that is because I'm usually one of the first to post in my games. Then, after dicscussion starts, I usually retract my vote. But, since we were well into the day before I posted, I saw no point of making a "fun" random vote and then retracting it more quickly than usual.

[Bacde]

Ding Ding Ding, two people again defending their no-votes? While not voting isn't scummy in the least, continually saying that you won't vote is... interesting.

Noted. Not to mention the fact that Inhim puts out all his notes upfront. o_O

[TBuG]

Average fos on armlx and indentured

Like Bacde said, that seem's kinda weird...

[NanookTheWolf]

Mental notes I've made thus far:
Nanook/raj exchange
armlx and indentureddjinn actually commenting on their no-votes


(Mod: Not voting: NanookTheWolf, indentureddjinn, armlx)

You also forgot to mention Iammars and I's exchange.

[Bacde]

Hes talking about exchanges that are worth noting. You and Iammar were just joking around.

Although I did notice he failed to mention me and him talking.

[NanookTheWolf]

Maybe, but I thought that Raj and I were just joking around as well .. at least I was.

[inHimshallibe]

Perhaps I thought more of your second exchange than your first.

[Iammars]

Either way, it's the beginning of the game. A lot of what happens here is a joke. I do wonder why inHimshallibe posted his mental notes. It seems a bit suspicious.

Slight FOS: inHimshallibe

[Someone]

unvote, vote Iammars

Gut.

[indentureddjinn]

FoS: Someone

That seems like a very hasty vote, especially with no explanation besides "Gut."

[Bacde]

I looked over a few of armlx's games, and discovered that he doesn't usually random vote without reason, so any confusion about him I had is now over. With that I will

Unvote: armlx

.

My gut is telling me that either indentureddjinn or Iammars is scum. Unfortunately until you run people up with votes day 1, you can't vote on anything besides gut.

[inHimshallibe]

OK, armlx semi-checks out.

unvote: armlx

vote: Iammars

- scummiest reactions to posts thus far.

[Iammars]

I'm just concerned that you posting your thoughts is your way of leading the town into what they think your thinking, when later on when you do it, you post something completly different from what you think.
Ehh... Maybe not. I'm just trying to spark some serious discussion. But, for the paranoid me, it's worth something.

[armlx]

Hmm...

Vote Indentureddjinn

I have a worse vibe about him then Iammars.

[NanookTheWolf]

FoS: Someone

That seems like a very hasty vote, especially with no explanation besides "Gut."

It's day 1, page 2, what more then gut does anyone really have at this point?

[Bacde]

I can probably spark some serious discussion with this: I was just re-reading the rules, and I noticed that in this game, Rule 2 "

[02] No communication outside the thread unless your role allows you to do so and then only in the game's nights.

" This means that the mafia can't talk during day 1. I'm sure we can use this to our advantage during today, but I still don't know how. Discussion?

Also, re-reading this thread (All 2 pages, woot!) I think Indentureddjinn is acting kind of scummy. He really freaked out about Iammars getting his first vote, and he admitted himself that he is acting different this game than he usually does. With all due respect...

Vote: Indentureddjinn

[SinisterOverlord]

Unvote

.

I can probably spark some serious discussion with this: I was just re-reading the rules, and I noticed that in this game, Rule 2 "[02] No communication outside the thread unless your role allows you to do so and then only in the game's nights. " This means that the mafia can't talk during day 1. I'm sure we can use this to our advantage during today, but I still don't know how. Discussion?

In my experience, that's pretty standard. All the games I've played in - where it's been specified and I've taken notice, at least, only allow the scum to confer at night.

In any case, with regards to the gut vote, that's also fairly normal. I mean, if you want to go on with a long post-by-post analysis of why someone's scum on page 2, then by all means, but I personally don't have enough insight to be able to logically deduce who's scum this early. So gut votes are pretty expected, though I do admit I question the reasoning if I'm on the recieving end.

[rajrhcpfreak]

I have nothing aginst NanookTheWolf

if i had it my way i wouldnt vote until real evidence is out. but someone voting for me, gives me something to base my vote on.

Inhim's vote of Immars, sounds almost OMGUS....

im not used to inhim posting his comments either.

FOS INHIM


PS more power to who refuse to random vote.... fight the system!!