In post 2084, Dave168 wrote:Mafia seemed underpowered - how did the traitor and rolecop relate to the rest of the scum team? could the results go back to the rest of the team?
Dropping RB in the JOAT for something else and I think it would have been completely fine.
Tracker + BG vs two scum w/encryptor is balanced enough as the encryptor is stronger than most will give it credit for.
Making it Doc+RB+Cop though when the next scum is going to be weaker than a goon (traitors rarely get recruited and even if it happened they would need to have their results) just throws off some balance. Especially when there are suddenly two roles (RB+track) who are exceedingly strong as scum numbers dwindel.
girth wrote:yeah well played scumteam, especially RBD and I agree the tracker clear on 2Birds was probably the crux that swung the game in favour of them. I always had a scumread of varying strength on 2Birds but the game theory put forward by RBD against his lynch was like super solid
Its easy to argue that type of game theory when its 100% correct. A tracker "went nowhere" is a towntell, it just benifited me to argue it quite a bit more than usual given that 2b1s was scum. Also you guys really really should have No Lynched that last day, would have made the game much harder for us since there was no good kill.
