NY 166: Knight-Errant 18p - Game Over!

[The Knight-Errant]

Vote Count 4.4

KX (3) - Evil Regals, Shattered Viewpoint, Metal Sonic
notscience (1) - zMuffinMan

Not Voting (7) - dopog, notscience, Marquis, meeps, Yraelz, KX, EddieFenix

Countdown:
(expired on 2013-10-03 15:00:00)

11 alive, 6 to lynch.

dopog is V/LA until Wednesday the 18th.

[zMuffinMan]

And on the subject of NotSci, why do you think he's town?

my reads (on everyone, not just ns) are primarily based on interactions with flipped scum and the general tone of the posts i've read.

where i'm up to, the interactions ns has had with

all

flipped scum indicates that, at the very least, he's not mafia. on top of that, i think his actual posts read town. this is the same for abdel-slot and evil regals. meeps i'm thinking is town just based on the content of his posts because there's not much in the way of interactions that are noteworthy, and eddie_fenix i'm thinking is not-mafia purely for interactions that happened around p21/p22/p23/p24 (i forget where exactly, didn't take notes, but it was somewhere around there when he was interacting mostly with beastcharizard).

your posts so far i've been fairly null on. i haven't really seen much in the way of posts that made me think one way or the other about your alignment and nothing you've said at the point i'm at has been memorable.

marquis' posts i have some issues with, and the interactions with flipped scum make some sense as scum-scum interactions.

and dopog's posts basically avoid talking about flipped scum altogether, and the other flipped scum basically avoid talking about him as well. at least where i'm up to in reading. this wouldn't be odd except for the fact that dopog has made several large catchup posts that simply neglected to mention flipped scum players, instead attacking players that have either flipped town already or are likely town imo.

i might finish reading tonight and see if any of my opinions on this change.

in the mean time, you can explain why you think ns is scum.

[zMuffinMan]

feeling lethargic, so will probably finish reading this tomorrow morning

[Shattered Viewpoint]

@Mod, shouldn't a living player be allowed to PM a dead player provided that the dead player doesn't say anything back? In that way, no living players receive any additional information or opinions which could influence their play from outside the thread.

I think you'll find that this violates most Moderator's rules, as well as Site Rules.

But what do I know.

[notscience]

Who is scum NS

[The Knight-Errant]

Prodded EddieFenix.

[meeps]

i want to post but not sure wat to post about

[Evil Regals]

i want to post but not sure wat to post about

How about you vote? Or reread the thread? Or give us who you think is scum?

[The Knight-Errant]

Also prodded Yraelz.

[Metal Sonic]

activity post.


still eating the popcorn waiting for the "show" to start

[The Knight-Errant]

EddieFenix has requested replacement.

[KX]

Don't worry Metal, thing will be happening soon enough, I just need to get a large chunk of free time. and @Muffin, already stated I think, but upon reading through the thread you'll find my reasons for thinking NotSci is scum, plus a couple dozen posts after it of NotSci flailing uselessly, which just proves the point more.

[notscience]

lol

You are just saying everything I do is flailing

Not bothering using any other word or going in-depth

So no, nice try scumfuck

MARQUIS IF YOU LET ME GET THIS HAMMER I PROMISE YOU A FUTURE HAMMER

[The Knight-Errant]

CrashTextDummie replaces EddieFenix.

[notscience]

Welcome, vote KX for great justice.

[CrashTextDummie]

Hai.

Just glancing at the last page, I see KX and notscience accusing each other of being scum, but neither is voting the other. What's up with that?

Guess some reading is required.

[notscience]

I have dibs on the hammer

[Marquis]

Hai.

Just glancing at the last page, I see KX and notscience accusing each other of being scum, but neither is voting the other. What's up with that?

Guess some reading is required.

town af, super town

[notscience]

Marquis bargain with me

[KX]

This is the first time I've said you're flailing NotSci. Thank you for you immense dedication to the game, going so far as to make sure what you're saying is correct, and not just fantasy existing only in your head. It must just take so much effort, I don't know how you do it.

@Crash, NotSci wants to hammer me, and I don't see the point in voting him as everybody in the game appears to townread him. I'd rather cast my vote somewhere that it'll do good.

[notscience]

This is the first time I've said you're flailing NotSci. Thank you for you immense dedication to the game, going so far as to make sure what you're saying is correct, and not just fantasy existing only in your head. It must just take so much effort, I don't know how you do it.

@Crash, NotSci wants to hammer me, and I don't see the point in voting him as everybody in the game appears to townread him. I'd rather cast my vote somewhere that it'll do good.

Don't worry Metal, thing will be happening soon enough, I just need to get a large chunk of free time. and @Muffin, already stated I think, but upon reading through the thread you'll find my reasons for thinking NotSci is scum, plus a couple dozen posts after it of NotSci flailing uselessly, which just proves the point more.

Hm

Interesting

I could have sworn you had more than that

Oh well

Also, please note the above post. It screams "I've locked myself into a scumread but I can't push it anymore because the guy is obvtown as holy fuck"

[KX]

You seem to be mistaken about a lot of things NotSci, glad to see you've finally admitted to one count.

Previously listed reasons still stand btw, as "it's the way I do things, don't hate" isn't a valid defense. And you never did explain to me how active lurking and noncommittal reads are policy lynch reason. Btw NotSci, not sure if you're aware of this, but stupidity isn't a towntell, otherwise I'd be with you on the obvtown as holy fuck part. Thinking about it, there was actually quite a bit to the case outside of the few tells I threw together in the end, and I bet I could make something good out of your recent posts. Maybe Metal will get his show after all.

[CrashTextDummie]

Did some selective reading (mostly D3 onwards with some backtracking). This is what I gathered so far:

Shattered Viewpoint claimed mason, Metal Sonic claimed bulletproof. Both are confirmed town in my eyes, the former for obvious reasons, the latter because no matter what the set-up, there would be a PR able to counter-claim if he was lying. This means that we have one of cop/doc/RB/tracker still hidden as well as an SK with 1-shot strongman/2-shot bulletproof/1-shot RB plus 1-shot cop/doc/RB/tracker left unaccounted for.

Beastcharizard claimed to have tried killing KX, and I'm taking it with a grain of salt. If he was telling the truth, I agree that KX being SK is the most probable scenario, but I'm not sold based on play.

I'm looking at zmuffinman and Yraelz for final scum because I have strong reason to believe that Beastcharizard was partnered with one of the people who flaked between D2 and N3. Leaning towards the former because of how the D1 Abdelrahman wagon played out, but have to read more. Maquis has also pinged strongly on several occasions starting with the HD wagon, and would be my first pick if flaker theory is wrong.

More tomorrow, I need sleep.

[notscience]

Make it then KX, don't just make empty threats and boring insults.

[zMuffinMan]

I have strong reason to believe that Beastcharizard was partnered with one of the people who flaked between D2 and N3.

go on...