Mafia 54: TGFKA Moses in Egypt - Game over!

[ShadowLurker]

i am not miriam

[vikingfan]

I like the plan, and as such, I am the miriam. Haven't hidden so far because I wasn't sure who to trust and was pretty sure I wouldn't be high on the 'must-kill list'. So far I've been proven correct.

I am leaning towards NOT proclaiming who I'm hiding with that night- unless I'm missing something. If I do and the person is town, then scum can just kill him and kill 2 people with 1 stone.

[vikingfan]

Scratch that last part, I understand the plan better now...

[ShadowLurker]

I like the plan, and as such, I am the miriam. Haven't hidden so far because I wasn't sure who to trust and was pretty sure I wouldn't be high on the 'must-kill list'. So far I've been proven correct.

I am leaning towards NOT proclaiming who I'm hiding with that night- unless I'm missing something. If I do and the person is town, then scum can just kill him and kill 2 people with 1 stone.

And we'd get a cop result.

Hide with kirbyphreak tonight.

Day breaks: If vikingfan and kirbyphreak are dead, we have a cop result

Day breaks: MM is dead, kirbyphreak is confirmed

Day breaks: MM is dead, and vikingfan is dead, kirbyphreak am scum


So let's lynch Primate or Mariyta now, I'm in favor of the latter, but if the town wants Primate, then I don't see any reason not to.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

I have no problem with the plan, and we have narrowed down our 3 scum to these candidates now:

8. MrBuddyLee
9. ShadowLurker
14. kirbyphreak
15. Mariyta
19. Primate
20. Rosso Carne

Primate's initiative for the excellent plan gets him off the hook for now. Now I like my other top suspect Mariyta, so

unvote, vote: Mariyta

[Yosarian2]

Eh, I'm thinking that if Primate's not scum, Mariyta's not either, or else she would have jumped on his bandwagon when we were all pushing her to do so before the most recent crash.

Primate's plan is good, and I don't really think he's scum either at this point.

unvote:primate

I'm leaning towards lynching either Kirby or Rosso. If Rosso dosn't return soon, mise well lynch him just because replacements are going to be impossible to find right now.

[kirbyphreak]

I like the plan, lets go with what SL said. Im fine with being hidden with. Mariyta is my favorite lynch candidate, followed by Rosso.

unvote(if im voting), Vote: Mariyta

. I think that makes 3.

[ShadowLurker]

Unvote Vote Mariyta

[MrBuddyLee]

OK, it looks like the only way for scum to win at this point is if they get a double nightkill by suckering Miriam into shacking up with scum.

I think that's what kirby's shooting for with the hiding suggestion, and I think he should be lynched. It also looks like he's distancing from one of {Rosso, Mariyta}. Obviously it's safer for Miriam to shack up with a confirmed innocent than with our most likely scum suspect.

Why would we guarantee scum a double kill like that? It's playing right into their hands.

confirm vote: kirby

[ShadowLurker]

OK, it looks like the only way for scum to win at this point is if they get a double nightkill by suckering Miriam into shacking up with scum.

I think that's what kirby's shooting for with the hiding suggestion, and I think he should be lynched. It also looks like he's distancing from one of {Rosso, Mariyta}. Obviously it's safer for Miriam to shack up with a confirmed innocent than with our most likely scum suspect.

Why would we guarantee scum a double kill like that? It's playing right into their hands.

confirm vote: kirby

If Miriam dies, we know kirby is definitely scum, and that narrows down another one of the people who we don't know the role of.

[creampuffeater]

I agree with the plan, and SL here. It tells us who the scum are.

Vote: Mari

Seems like the best we have now. We still have a double lynch here, too. So plenty of people here can die, narrowing up who is scum.

[Mariyta]

Does anyone feel like explaining their vote on me (preferably something a bit more substantial than "Seems like the best we have.")? It would be much appreciated.

On another note, don't expect me to defend much of armlx's play. I don't understand him most of the time.

[Primate]

We need for Rosso to confirm/deny before we go any further, really.

[Kelly Chen]

I talked to Rosso in chat... He knows scum is up...

The Thirty-Sixth Vote Count

5 - Mariyta (Rosso Carne, Machiavellian-Mafia, kirbyphreak, ShadowLurker, creampuffeater)
2 - Primate (Cogito Ergo Sum, HezLucky)
1 - Cogito Ergo Sum (vikingfan)
1 - ShadowLurker (Primate)
1 - kirbyphreak (MrBuddyLee)

not voting: Mariyta, Yosarian2

With 12 alive it's 7 to lynch!

Firm deadline is back on for

Saturday the 9th

, six days minus 4.5 hours from this post.

No majority is No Lynch.

[ShadowLurker]

Does anyone feel like explaining their vote on me (preferably something a http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/index.php
mafiascum.net Forum Indexbit more substantial than "Seems like the best we have.")? It would be much appreciated.

On another note, don't expect me to defend much of armlx's play. I don't understand him most of the time.

Who do you feel is the most suspicious?

[Mariyta]

I don't know. I don't remember much of what I read before the crash, and since I joined right before all the big explosions, I didn't get a chance to get a read on anyone. The only thing I have to go on is "the plan" and you're the only one who seems to not like it. As far as I can tell, it's a near-solid win for the town if we follow it.

[HezLucky]

Has Mariyta claimed anything?

[ShadowLurker]

No, there is nothing for her to claim other than Townie though.

[Primate]

Mari is meh.

MBL or Kirby, with preference to MBL.

[Yosarian2]

vote:kirby

The key is, though, lynching one of the unconfirmed, so even though I don't really think Miri is scum I'll be willing to lynch her if I have to. If we lynch basically any unconfirmed we should win, so let's just not do something dumb and have a no-lynch, mmmk? Remember we still need a full 7 votes to lynch, and as I don't think we have everyone back yet that might not be as easy as it sounds.

[ShadowLurker]

What don't you guys understand about that:

-We have TWO lynches today and can lynch two people.
-We have a deadline in under 4 days, with all these term papers and exams coming up, we need to hurry and COMPROMISE if the town wishes it.

[Primate]

Point.

vote Maryita

[vikingfan]

unvote

Right now, Mariyta is looking like a pretty good choice. Let's lynch Mariyta today and go from there.

vote mariyta

I'll hide with kirby tonight.

[vikingfan]

Oh, and I'll be gone over the weekend- may have access but not counting on it.

[Kelly Chen]

Final Day 4 Vote Count

7 - Mariyta (Rosso Carne, Machiavellian-Mafia, kirbyphreak, ShadowLurker, creampuffeater, Primate, vikingfan)

2 - Primate (Cogito Ergo Sum, HezLucky)
2 - kirbyphreak (MrBuddyLee, Yosarian2)

not voting: Mariyta

With 12 alive it's 7 to lynch!

You all toss rocks at Mariyta! How barbaric!

Fortunately, she is from the future, and does not have human rights under Egyptian law.

Mariyta -

Mafia

- Lynched day 4

GAME EVENT:

PHARAOH has extended the day.

And duly, the Egyptians began to debate the next person to die.

With 11 alive, it is 6 to lynch! Votes are wiped.