Open 9 - Basic Twelve Player (Game Over!) - before 400

[Fircoal]

Ripley brings up a really good point. Battlemage has some reasons to be scum. Though, I think he just said that as a joke. I also argee about the bad logic, so just to see how he ressponds

Vote: Battlemage

I just watched a newbie vote protown just to see how the protown responds.
I find this particular vote as scummy.

If Battle Mages vote was serious he looks scummy to me. I still have the feeling it wasn't. I mean c'moon who seriously thinks MC could be town?

I want to see what Battlemage responds. WE can't be sure if Battlemage is protown or not, and right now he is our best lead.

[Twito]

Ripley brings up a really good point. Battlemage has some reasons to be scum. Though, I think he just said that as a joke. I also argee about the bad logic, so just to see how he ressponds

Vote: Battlemage

I just watched a newbie vote protown just to see how the protown responds.
I find this particular vote as scummy.

If Battle Mages vote was serious he looks scummy to me. I still have the feeling it wasn't. I mean c'moon who seriously thinks MC could be town?

I want to see what Battlemage responds. WE can't be sure if Battlemage is protown or not, and right now he is our best lead.

And that's so not truth. We have MC remember. That's Masterchief. M-a-s-t-e-r-C-h-i-e-f. You just have to type vote before the two letter M and C. It's pretty simply.

And now I'm leading a newbie. But to the right direction. Unless BattleMage is also right direction.

Or maybe the newbies have an alliance and they are trying to get me to lead them so that they can later easily lynch me.

Sometimes I wonder..

[AndrewS]

Twito,
Your willingness to lynch someone merely based on a vendetta against that person is annoying. Please stop it. Yes, he is a real idiot - we just lynched in in Space Monkey mafia because he claimed mafia. And wasn't. But still, we've got to be smart about this game - we've already lost our doctor, we're looking at pretty bad odds here.

[Patrick]

The Everyone mourn for Sage votecount!

Twito (1) -- Masterchief
Masterchief (2) -- Twito, Lowell
Lowell (2) -- AndrewS, Battle Mage
AndrewS (1) -- Shadowlurker
Battle Mage (3) -- The Central Scrutiniser, Ripley, Fircoal

Not voting: IH, spectrumvoid
11 alive, 6 to lynch.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Fircoal's jumping on the Battlemage wagon seems a little opportunistic to me. Does anyone else think so?

[Fircoal]

Fircoal's jumping on the Battlemage wagon seems a little opportunistic to me. Does anyone else think so?

I'm not trying to jump on a wagon, it's just that he is the most scummy looking at this present point.

[Twito]

Twito,
Your willingness to lynch someone merely based on a vendetta against that person is annoying. Please stop it. Yes, he is a real idiot - we just lynched in in Space Monkey mafia because he claimed mafia. And wasn't. But still, we've got to be smart about this game - we've already lost our doctor, we're looking at pretty bad odds here.

But he is threat to the town no matter of his allignment..
I will think about it when something else catches my eye. I want to lynch him but that doesn't seperate me from following the game otherwise and possibly lynching someone else in the end.

[IH]

If everyone would look at the titles, some of this would be explained....

Obligatory Vote:Twito

The same could be said about you. Something about a newbie game that Thok only didn't count to ruin the game....

<.<

[Battle Mage]

wow i gotta say im quite surprised that everyone seems to think i-in my first Mafia Game here, is actually a baddie. Unfortunately i am not a Mafia, nor do i have any interesting role. I am a townie.
I dont expect you to believe me, as at this point it is all gut instinct and guess work, but i suggest that the willingness of 3 people to jump onto me, is a sign that one of theirs is in danger.
That means Lowell or Masterchief imo.
Those townies who have voted for me, i implore you to change your vote. We have already lost the doctor, and to lose another townie this early on would be catastrophic.
dont make a big mistake.
BM

*also, what is FOS?

[AndrewS]

(Finger of Suspicion - used to indicate that you are suspicious without voting for you)

[Twito]

Obligatory Vote:Twito

The same could be said about you. Something about a newbie game that Thok only didn't count to ruin the game....

<.<

Not really. I do read all the post unlike him and I participate. I do joke around however which can be coincidered equally dangerous I guess. I don't think so and there appear to be others too. I find you comparing me to MC very insulting.

And I really like that newbie game. I asked him before voting(not waiting for answer though.. make more clear rules will you. Just add "Votes without first unvoting count/don't count".) whether voting counts without unvoting. I was never planning on hammering myself thank you very much. Also it's on going game so it shouldn't be referred to too much.

[spectrumvoid]

wow i gotta say im quite surprised that everyone seems to think i-in my first Mafia Game here, is actually a baddie. Unfortunately i am not a Mafia, nor do i have any interesting role. I am a townie.

SV pops in now because she forgot to add this game on watch list.

Why the heck did you claim on page 2?

[Twito]

Why the heck did you claim on page 2?

Secound that.
We were basicly still random voting and you weren't that close to lynch. I mean c'moon you were at 3 and it's 6 to lynch.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

He's new... I'd give him a break.

In fact, based on that post, I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt. I remember what it was like to be new. My basic defense was and still kind of is "look, I'm not scum, I don't know how else to say it." I get the feeling that he's protown.

unvote, vote:Fircoal

because I'm still not sure about his vote on Battle Mage.

[IH]

I can just about see Battle Mage if he was scum saying to the others "hey, wouldn't it be funny if the doctor was Sage" and them agreeing, what the hell, may as well go for it, and then BM being unable to resist this post, a kind of coded "omg guys it worked how cool is that???"

.......?

unvote, Vote:Ripley

[Twito]

"look, I'm not scum, I don't know how else to say it."

Then again newbies say the same thing as their only defence no matter of their real allignment.. they always try to fool me!

[Twito]

I can just about see Battle Mage if he was scum saying to the others "hey, wouldn't it be funny if the doctor was Sage" and them agreeing, what the hell, may as well go for it, and then BM being unable to resist this post, a kind of coded "omg guys it worked how cool is that???"

.......?

unvote, Vote:Ripley

And me stupid replied to the same comment with a smiley face.. I guess you can also vote based on it..

[IH]

And me stupid replied to the same comment with a smiley face.. I guess you can also vote based on it..

Well, I replied with a vote, because, I mean, did anyone really apply any reasoning to voting for BM before this, and Ripley just kind of made something to fit into it..... I need to look over the thread again to see why TCS and Fircoal hopped on the wagon...

[Battle Mage]

cheers.
I wouldnt exactly say that im new to this game, as i have played it alot on other websites, but here everyone seems to take it alot more seriously, and its completely different. You guys are like the pro's, so ur gonna have to teach me as i go along. i mean, what do u mean by 'claiming'?

BM

He's new... I'd give him a break.

In fact, based on that post, I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt. I remember what it was like to be new. My basic defense was and still kind of is "look, I'm not scum, I don't know how else to say it." I get the feeling that he's protown.

unvote, vote:Fircoal

because I'm still not sure about his vote on Battle Mage.

[Fircoal]

I think I'm beginning to believe that Battlemage is not scum. Even though, he did claim too early.

Unvote: Battlemage

I don't think any one esle is that scummy.

Also, I didn't jump on the bandwagon, because of nothing, I thought, Ripley's post was good, and argeed with it.

[AndrewS]

Mage: Claiming is revealing your role.

[Twito]

I think I'm beginning to believe that Battlemage is not scum. Even though, he did claim too early.

Unvote: Battlemage

I don't think any one esle is that scummy.

Also, I didn't jump on the bandwagon, because of nothing, I thought, Ripley's post was good, and argeed with it.

You though Ripleys post was good and you agreed with it?

Vote: Fircoal

[Fircoal]

WEll, I argee about the bad logic, now that I look at it. It doesn't really add anything to the discussion of what happened. Battlemage has done some bad logic, through, this whole game.

[Twito]

Now that you look at it? And you already voted based on it. C'moon!

[Fircoal]

WEll I see that there wasn't any difference, about the other posts but 1 thing added that really didn't add much importance. I argeed about the bad logic, and thought he was the scummiest so that's why I made my vote that way.