The New Set-Up Review Thread

[JAMFTW]

The thing with the Lyncher role is that it totally makes sense given the Castle theme. During Season Two of the show, there are two episodes where this stalker of Kate Beckett is trying to kill her.

I have no problem giving a Jester (Not a role I'm considering for this game) or Lyncher a win condition that lets them win with whatever group winds up winning the game.

Faraday, could you explain further what you mean by "accounted for" ?

[AGar]

Doesn't a lyncher's wincon usually dictate that once their target is lynched, they leave the game?

[izakthegoomba]

I need a reviewer for a semi-open large normal. It'll be a few months before I get to run it, but I'd like to get it done.

Still need a reviewer. Preferable two.

[Faraday]

Doesn't a lyncher's wincon usually dictate that once their target is lynched, they leave the game?

Yes.

[Me=Weird]

I still need a few reviewers for Cheese Mafia. Please PM me.

[Bowser]

Thanks, Empking!

I'd like at least 1 more reviewer.

[izakthegoomba]

Thanks, Empking!

I'd like at least 1 more reviewer.

[animorpherv1]

Thanks, Empking!

I'd like at least 1 more reviewer.

Thanks, Empking!

I'd like at least 1 more reviewer.

[izakthegoomba]

Dammit ani, you rumbled us. Yes, it's true. We're both CSL alts.

[CSL]

Liar. I'm in your mish-mash game.

[Robocopter87]

Unforgotten Realms Mafia? Schoompy of Awesometon version
Spongebob Mafia?
Left 4 Dead Mafia?
Borderlands Mafia?

Ooooooh.... Borderlands Mafia...

Yes. That'll do, pig. That'll do.

[Robocopter87]

Actually. I think Portal Mafia is a cooler idea with a lot of potential for mechanics.

*goes to check and see if his brilliant idea was taken this time*

[Robocopter87]

GLaDOS took it. Looks like he just used it as flavorish stuff. I was thinking more of Portal mechanics.

So Borderlands it is.

[Vi]

GLaDOS took it. Looks like he just used it as flavorish stuff. I was thinking more of Portal mechanics.

It's okay to run a game with a flavor that some other game has, as long as the games aren't running at the same time.

[Trumpet of Doom]

That said, AlmasterGM claimed Portal 2 in the LT Queue and sounded like he was going to be doing some crazy mechanic-y things with it. He sounded like he was interested in having someone help him work out the mechanics; I don't know if he still is, you might try talking to him about it.

[chkflip]

I've got a Large Normal ready but I'd like a review of it.

Thanks in advance.

Scott Brosius gave it a once over, I've changed some things, and am now looking for a couple more reviewers before I turn it over to the Large Normal crew.

[Robocopter87]

That said, AlmasterGM claimed Portal 2 in the LT Queue and sounded like he was going to be doing some crazy mechanic-y things with it. He sounded like he was interested in having someone help him work out the mechanics; I don't know if he still is, you might try talking to him about it.

Nah, I'll let him be. i'm not experienced enough to be of much help. Besides, Borderlands Mafia is way more intriguing to me.

With that being said, what are the balanced Town/Scum/Third Party for a large theme game of around 25, 24 or something in that area?

[Magister Ludi]

If you are asking generically, usually a group of five for scum or two groups of three or four, and third party varies greatly, depending on how you plan their win conditions and how powerful you make them. Rest town.

[Hoppster]

I need a reviewer for a Mini Theme (13p), comparethemeerkat.mafia.

No flavour knowledge needed.

MEERPUPS ARE VERY SAD

Yeah, still need this. Thanks in advance.

Don't make me have to bug you over PM.

EDIT: Yay I'm sorted.

[chkflip]

I've got a Large Normal ready but I'd like a review of it.

Thanks in advance.

Scott Brosius gave it a once over, I've changed some things, and am now looking for a couple more reviewers before I turn it over to the Large Normal crew.

Thanks Darth Yoshi (even though I've been ultimate lazy Flip and haven't sent the set-up to you yet);

still looking for one more reviewer.

Empking stepped up; MAN SHIT. I'm also cross-reviewing with Hoppster.

If my set up

still sucks

after this.... man, I'm hopeless. xO

[animorpherv1]

That said, AlmasterGM claimed Portal 2 in the LT Queue and sounded like he was going to be doing some crazy mechanic-y things with it. He sounded like he was interested in having someone help him work out the mechanics; I don't know if he still is, you might try talking to him about it.

Nah, I'll let him be. i'm not experienced enough to be of much help. Besides, Borderlands Mafia is way more intriguing to me.

With that being said, what are the balanced Town/Scum/Third Party for a large theme game of around 25, 24 or something in that area?

Depends on the amount of power, but if it's purely town/mafia, ~20 town should be great.

[SnakePlissken]

Right I have a set up for Kiss (The Band) Mafia. If you have knowledge of the bands history it will help but not necessary (Mini Theme).

[YawningAngel]

I have a 19-player game about to go with PRs that are non-standard but (intended to be) fairly weak. Is there anyone who might be able to take a quick look over it?

[Timeater]

Just post the setup since its open, Yawning.

[Empking]

Just post the setup since its open, Yawning.

Though of course you don't want to clutter the thread.