Mini 456: Ultimatum Mafia - Game Over!

[mneme]

Re "honor" -- BM, do you understand and obey Lynch All Liers? Why or why not?

[Yosarian2]

Indeed, it was so obvious that pro-towners would vote to kill BM that I (correctly) figured out that Yosarian2 was scum because he voted to save BM.

Heh...I guarentee you that if I was pro-town I would have voted to save BM. In fact, I probably would have done it sooner and defended him harder if I was pro-town. That's kind of irrelevent though.

[Stewie]

@Stewie-again, you miss the possibility that VD

was

Conservative-scum, in which case the town would have been even more screwed.

It was a very small possibility, and even if so we did not intend to lynch all the conservative scum before lynching VD. Therefore, if VD was indeed conservative scum all we would have to do lynch the other two conservative scum first, then lynch VD thinking he would come up liberal. If he came up conservative we got the same result: eliminated a scum group when the other was at minimum force. In short, it was a really small possibility and it didn't make a difference in what the best strategy was for the town anyways.

[MeMe]

last post