Open 623 (White Flag) - A Moment in Time (Over)

[SirCakez]

Yes, I'm down for the Cakez lynch. He's pretty much confirmed scum.

When can we lynch this?

[TheCow]

n

[pistachi0n]

I'd lynch Cakez, he was my original scumread.

[SirCakez]

I'd lynch Cakez, he was my original scumread.

Of course you would, you're probably scum.

[TheCow]

Who

isn't

scum?

[SirCakez]

Viva, Ranger, myself, and then one of the remaining four.

[Cerberus v666]

Viva are we ever going to see your thoughts you were about to offer up to Ranger before she decided you were possibly scum?

[Cerberus v666]

Also, umm. Hmm. Need to fact check ranger on all the cakez stuff. Other than the vca/NKA stuff of course, which *can* be faked as he seems to think it is, but. I kinda don't think scum would just focus all their efforts on deliberately setting up a mislynch on a single slot on particular in LYLO. Kinda a too many eggs in one basket sorta thing.

Also, what defense of cakez have you seen me make ranger? The first paragraph of this post is the first thing I've said that's meant to suggest we shouldn't lynch him in particular. I just think Karnage and TheCow are more likely to be scum. Speaking of Karnage....is meta really the main reason for your read on him? Nothing else based wholly on this game?

[pistachi0n]

Who

isn't

scum?

You aren't.

[Ranger]

Also, what defense of cakez have you seen me make ranger?

To name a few? 2102, 2066, very strongly 2065, 2060, among others.

[Ranger]

Also,

Speaking of Karnage....is meta really the main reason for your read on him? Nothing else based wholly on this game?

Absolutely not. Karnage's play this game has been all sorts of town. The point I had of concern was checking Karnage's contribution levels, to see if the level I was seeing would potentially be a scum-indicator when all other indications said town. I did so, and found a strong contrast, reaffirming the already-existing evidence: Karnage is town.

[Ranger]

Eh, today's the leap year. If the game ends, it'd be interesting to see what Day In History Drixx uses.

VOTE: SirCakez.

I'll risk it.

[Viva La Gloria]

Don't be fucking Firebringer.

Please.

[Viva La Gloria]

RANGER.

[Viva La Gloria]

I don't think Sircakez is scum and I've had absolutely no issues pinning him as scum in the past.

Why the hell are you townreading Pistachi0n?

[Ranger]

I'm not pulling a Firebringer.

This is an informed decision.

Everyone has checked in.
Everyone has provided their thoughts.
I did

thorough

reading for the game, and everything points to SirCakez being scum.

Everything I've read tells me Karnage and TheCow are both town.

I don't see any combination where SirCakez is not scum.

[Ranger]

Why the hell are you townreading Pistachi0n?

Honestly if I'm wrong about you being scum then it'd be pistachi0n as the third, which is why I'm advocating lynching Cerberus tomorrow because he's a safer bet for scum than you would be.

Yet there is no scum team where SirCakez is town. Not that I can see. I've looked.

If this is the wrong decision, I will take full responsibility for the loss. I'm

really

confident it's the right call, though.

[Viva La Gloria]

Walk me through your Karnage townread.

I'm not feeling this.

[Ranger]

I'm fully confident TheCow is town here. My read there will not budge.
Yonom looked town overall to me, and Karnage has continued to look town overall to me. I've liked what he's said and what he's seen.
That leaves four names for three scum.

And of them...we've got SirCakez, who

literally every single nightkill

points to. No scumteam would be this dedicated to framing a player for a lylo mislynch. None. Scum might make one kill for wifom. Maybe. At most I could see two. But all three? The simpler answer is instead scum perceived a threat from the players they nightkilled. SirCakez fits that mold better than any other player.

[Ranger]

At this stage, my town suspicion on Cerberus is being shaken. I do suspect you are town, but I can't blindly agree with your read or reasoning, yet.

Btw, found this when looking at KAAG's iso.

KAAG's iso is almost entirely devoted to calling one slot scum (SirCakez), with the exception of Firebringer the D2 lynch. This is pretty much the only thing resembling suspicion on another player. I know it's not slam-dunk, he said he was re-evaluating his hard-townread, not really a true scumread, but: it makes sense for him to have died if he was on the right track of two scum. I think he was.

[Viva La Gloria]

I mean I agree that the EE nightkill was weird.

But the D1 kill was on someone who was fairly universally townread and making an effort to solve the game. I could see it easily if the wagons were town-town.
As for KAAG, he was literally the most fucking obvious town person I have seen in my life. It doesn't take a desire to frame Sircakez to kill him.

I did find the EE kill somewhat questionable but that doesn't mean that Cakez is scum. Also, Cakez knew who I was from a while back apparently, and Cakez if he were scum would NEVER leave me alive knowing who I was.

KAAG's iso is almost entirely devoted to calling one slot scum (SirCakez), with the exception of Firebringer the D2 lynch. This is pretty much the only thing resembling suspicion on another player. I know it's not slam-dunk, he said he was re-evaluating his hard-townread, not really a true scumread, but: it makes sense for him to have died if he was on the right track of two scum. I think he was.

Or they were just hitting people who were obvtowning it up and hoping to hide among the nulls.

[SirCakez]

Karnage has continued to look town overall to me. I've liked what he's said and what he's seen.

This is super vague reasoning.
And are you just going to ignore the like six posts in a row I made aimed at you a page or so back?

[Viva La Gloria]

Really not happy about this Sircakez vote.

I guess we just wait and see what happens.

[SirCakez]

I kind of think Ranger has to be scum here now just because of how awful her reads are and it would follow the "scum use night kills as evidence to push mislynch" theory I've had all game.

[Karnage]

I figure on the off chance cakez was town, scum would have jumped in for the quickhammer by now.

lets lynch scum

VOTE: cakez